Angehefteter Tweet
Gulzar Rumi
478 posts

Gulzar Rumi
@Gulzar_here
A Believer of Tawhid. Forgive me if my words hurt your heart.
Beigetreten Mart 2026
13 Folgt4 Follower
Gulzar Rumi retweetet

When European powers arrived, Muslims were forced to confront an uncomfortable reality, a civilization that had once led the world was now being administered, humiliated, and restructured by people they considered culturally inferior in almost every meaningful sense.
That shock produced two camps and both misdiagnosed the problem, so both prescribed the wrong medicine.
Response 1 - The Modernists
These were the Western-educated Muslim intellectuals. Al-Afghani, Muhammad Abduh and their intellectual descendants. Their diagnosis: Muslims are backward because they rejected reason and progress. Their solution: absorb Western rationalism, science, and institutional models. Adapt Islam to modernity.
The problem is that they didn’t actually develop an Islamic methodology, they just borrowed Western epistemology wholesale and then tried to justify it with Islamic vocabulary. They were thinking in Western categories while speaking Islamic language.
The result was hollow. You got modernized Muslim states that were structurally Western, culturally confused, and spiritually empty. Turkey, Egypt, the whole postcolonial experiment.
Response 2; the traditionalists
Their diagnosis: the modernists are selling out. The solution is to return purely to classical scholarship, reject Western influence entirely, and hold the line.
Not wrong but it has a fatal flaw: it confuses preserving the tradition with engaging reality. The classical scholars were great precisely because they engaged their reality creatively.
Imitating them means doing what they did thinking hard not just repeating what they said.
Traditionalism ended up producing scholars who were technically brilliant inside the classical framework but completely unable to address modern political economy, international relations, or institutional design with anything original.
Both responses had the same root problem neither rebuilt the Islamic methodology of knowledge. The modernists abandoned it. The traditionalists fossilized it. Neither produced a living, breathing intellectual tradition capable of generating original answers to new questions.
This is the framework for understanding every Muslim political failure. The GCC states? Modernist template: Western institutional structure, Islamic branding. The jihadist movements? Traditionalist reaction that can destroy but cannot build. Neither has the intellectual infrastructure to actually govern or lead a civilization.
The Muslim world is still fighting a 19th century debate while the 21st century is happening around it.

English

@gujjar63673883 @qureshi2_sultan Don't Haryana & Punjab have Muslims?
English

@qureshi2_sultan worked in corporate for 10 years , 99 % of the male muslim colleagues around me have always been ugly pot bellied south indian or UP / bihari chuslims .
Stop creating imaginary story of 4-5 good looking muslim men , the fair good looking men in offices are haryanvi/ punjabi
English

What do think an average hindu boy working in BPO WILL DO,when he sees 4-5 smart, good looking boys in mid senior position, dominating the office, surrounded by hindu girls,totally in command of the organization
Ofcourse.. he will call Bajrang Dal and call it some Jihad.
محمد طارق🇮🇳@itsme_tarique
I can guarantee that the case if TCS is something else and not the conversion or Love Jihad @zoo_bear kindly deep search
English

@singhafied Doesn't punjabi have many dialects, which one is the original one?
Punjabi language is a noisy language, I never saw a Punjabi speaker speaking Punjabi calmly,politely & professionally. Urdu has an intrinsic nature of calmness & professional credential. Hopefully,I'm not biased
English

Switching to colonial-darbari languages like Urdu-Hindi from native languages lowers IQ by minimum 10 points and more
Core Hindi-Urdu belt is at par with Sub Saharan Africa now. Lehnda Panjab is deteriorating at same speed it’s replacing Panjabi. 1950’s to 2020’s difference can be observed with naked eye
Bheria ☪️@BheriaMS
Urdu is the lingua franca of the Muslims in South Asia, Punjabi Muslims have had a foundational role in Punjabi literature & a non-negligible one in Urdu literature as well. You can be proficient in multiple languages, why is that such a debate for foreigners (Indian Sikh here)?
English

@SensibleSperm @bandaofrabb We can't know which one is ancient, didn't all humans speak language from day one?
English

@Gulzar_here @bandaofrabb Which language is more ancient? Which was created to communicate with the Hindoo?
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 Don't tell me what's true or what's not.
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 That's not true.
U have to believe Muhd is last prophet and thus believe all mythical prophets before him, who were Jewish..
Mohd was upstart who appropriating Jewish religion inserting himself.
That's like me claiming the Last prophet.
English

@Gulzar_here @miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 Not by choice your grandfather had one option convert to islam or be beheaded and let you bebe raped by 50 Muslims. Your coward grandfather chose to convert to islam. It wasn’t really a choice. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 That's called Superiority . The Arab Prophet by the command of Almighty finished jewish supremacy once & for all . You might wanna read how Prophet risked his own life to oust Mercantile jewish out of Arabian peninsula.
Jews are masters of idolaters & polytheists
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 Jews literally created abrahmic religion, and a Arab nomad comes and call himself last prophet.
That's like Ahmediya, where a new prophet Mirza Ghulam came and called himself Last prophet.
How can they be superior than the OGs
Lmao
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 They own idolaters & polytheists. They don't allow mushriks to enter jewish settlement in Himachal pradesh. One of them said mushriks stink horribly & molest Jewish women
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 Only if it serve their interest else they dont
English

@MayorNewyork @bandaofrabb That's not Urdu. Bhaiyas speak avadhi bhojpuri
हिन्दी

@Gulzar_here @bandaofrabb Urdu is a language of kothas. It was born in kanpur Uttar Pradesh. Language of dehati malnourished bhayias. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 The essence of Quraan & Islam is in Tawhid. Everything else is secondary & not too important.
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 Lmao, how can u be Muslim, if u dont believe abrahmic myths.
Abraham, Moses, Noah, Adam and all.
U ain't a Muslim, coz u call these as myths
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 You don't have a comprehensive knowledge of Abrahamic Religions. Goyim is for Christians & Polytheists & idolaters.
Muslims are superior to Jews . I never heard otherwise except from brahmamical mushriks .
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 Such a inferiority ridden goy.
Jews exist just to show Christians and Muslims their auqat.
Entirety of abrahmic religion was made by Jews. They just don't accept converts.
This is why people like u exist.
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 Trust is a personal investment. On a collective level, it asks for incentives & mythologies. Therefore,to put the trust of people into God, God is often depicted as a Harsh Judge Or a loving merciful Affectionate one.
Forgive me for oversimplifying.
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 And why should u be trusted, whom 2 billion Muslim won't trust lmao
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 Yeah... I'd be put to death for speaking as such in shariat implemented countries.
It's okay. I would in that scene prefer to shut myself up.
I understand shortcomings of people & emotional attachment . I forgive even if I'm killed. 😉🥲
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 Why r u deflecting to krishna?
U do realize u can be executed under sharia in almost every Muslim country, for saying Muhammad wasn't perfect man after revelation lmao.
This just shows u can't trust quran as it is apparently told by an imperfect man.
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 Coz I know u.
Don't worry brother.
I know u.
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 You are an epic testimony why mushriks are illiterate people.
Education doesn't bring moral change in you people. I know your brahmanism is incompetent to improve someone morally but modern education could had done. Maybe, you downplay Ethics and Etiquette
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 He was normal guy.
I only believe Ahmediya as true Islam.
Coz Islam is itself, Ahmediya religion for Jews.
Basically Muslim are goyims.
Jews don't convert, else there would be no Muslim. U don't even realize this.
U r 4-5th grade convert.
English

@miragechazer101 @VoidSpecter001 Why would I be? Bhumihars live in East India
English

@Gulzar_here @VoidSpecter001 U r Bhumihar Saar.
I know u coz I have talked to u before.
English

