Muthukkumar முத்துக்குமார்

@PTI_News 3 language formula is in place in Northern states (UP, MP, Bihar & Rajasthan) for last 60 years. What these states have achieved with respect to a state with 2 language formula ? Atleast one benefit?

@AK_Entertains @mkstalin Metro will come to all major cities of Tamilnadu - whether UG fund it or not. Chennai metro phase 2 is happening without UG grant.

@mkstalin Kadaisi vara ipdi pesi metro varama poradhuku Avan jeicha metro varum is far better People are the only ones affected

பா.ஜ.க. MLA-வைத் தேர்ந்தெடுத்தால்தான் மதுரைக்கு மெட்ரோ தருவோம் என்று பேரம் பேசுவதும், பிளாக்மெயில் செய்வதும்தான் மகாராஷ்டிர முதலமைச்சரின் வேலையா? அரசியலமைப்பின் மீது உறுதிமொழி ஏற்ற ஒரு முதலமைச்சர், எதிர்க்கட்சி ஆளும் மாநிலத்தில் வந்து இப்படி பேசுவதற்கு வெட்கப்பட வேண்டும். நிதி ஒதுக்கீட்டில் ஒன்றிய அரசின் புறக்கணிப்பை மீறி, தமிழ்நாடு அரசு நிறைவேற்றி வரும் சாதனைத் திட்டங்கள் எத்தனை என்று அவருக்குத் தெரியுமா? தெரியாவிட்டால் கேட்டுத் தெரிந்துகொண்டு பேச வேண்டும். டபுள் எஞ்சின் என்று நீங்கள் பீற்றும் டப்பா எஞ்சின் மாநிலங்களையும் தாண்டி, #DravidianModel ஆளும் தமிழ்நாடுதான் Double Digit பொருளாதார வளர்ச்சியைச் சாதித்துள்ளது என்பது நினைவில் இருக்கட்டும்.

@ShyamSPrasad @shruthihm1 This diluted stand is only weakening your opposition for Hindi. Never ever agree for a 3 language formula - it is the front door invitation for Hindi.

As long as Madhya Pradesh does not make Kannada a compulsory passing subject in its schools, no student in Karnataka should be mandated to learn Hindi. No compromise on this issue. #GoBackGovernor

@Rebellionaire1 Their plan is to make Sanskrit as National Language. NEP paves red carpet for it. DMK should expose this evil plan along with Hindi imposition protests.

CRYSTAL CLEAR PROOF 👇👇👇👇👇 NEP 2020 promotes Sanskrit. It leads to Imposition of Hindi. 👆👆👆👆👆 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 We request thinkers of other regional languages also to react. 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Union Minister Piyush Goyal has reacted to TN CM's strong protest against '3 language formula'. He has said "I challenge MK Stalin show me one place where in NEP, we've said Hindi is compulsory." This article proves that in the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, Hindi and Sanskrit are given strategic priority compared to other regional languages. 👇👇👇👇👇 1. Entire Dedicated Paragraph Praising Sanskrit (Paragraph 4.17) -------------------- The policy devotes a long, detailed paragraph exclusively to Sanskrit. The NEP 2020 singles out Sanskrit as a language that will be mainstreamed across all levels of education. It calls Sanskrit as an important modern language in the Eighth Schedule of the Indian Constitution. A classical language with literature greater in volume than that of Latin and Greek combined. Containing "vast treasures" of knowledge in mathematics, philosophy, grammar, music, politics, medicine, architecture, metallurgy, drama, poetry, storytelling, etc. (called "Sanskrit Knowledge Systems"). It explicitly states: "Sanskrit will thus be offered at all levels of school and higher education as an important, enriching option for students, including as an option in the three-language formula." The policy proposes that Sanskrit Universities will move towards becoming multi-disciplinary institutions, broadening their scope and influence. 👇👇👇👇👇 2. Other classical languages mentioned for namesake only ------------------- Other classical languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam, Odia, etc.) are covered in just one short paragraph (4.18) with much milder language: Other classical languages are acknowledged for their "rich literature," but the policy only says they "must be preserved" and "will also be widely available... possibly as online modules." There is no equivalent detailed praise, no comparison to Latin/Greek, and no strong recommendation to offer them at "all levels" like Sanskrit. NEP recommends teaching Sanskrit in interesting, experiential ways, including through Simple Standard Sanskrit (SSS) textbooks and "Sanskrit through Sanskrit" (STS) method. In higher education (Paragraph 22.15), it states that "Sanskrit will become a natural part of a holistic multidisciplinary higher education" if a student chooses it. No other language is given such priority. 👇👇👇👇👇 3. The Three-Language Formula and Hindi ------------------ While the NEP states just for name sake that "no language will be imposed on any State," the practical implementation of the Three-Language Formula often favors Hindi in non-Hindi speaking states. The Hindi Belt Influence: In Hindi-speaking states, students often choose Hindi, English, and one other Indian language (often Sanskrit). However, in non-Hindi speaking states, the "second" or "third" Indian language choice frequently defaults to Hindi due to the availability of teachers and resources, compared to the scarcity of resources for other regional languages (like Tamil or Kannada) in North India. 👇👇👇👇👇 4. Sanskrit gains functional importance ------------------ The NEP places a heavy emphasis on teaching the "traditional knowledge of India." Since a vast majority of ancient Indian scientific, philosophical, and medical texts are written in Sanskrit, the language becomes the primary vehicle for this curriculum. By making IKS a part of the mainstream curriculum, Sanskrit gains a functional importance that other regional languages (which may have their own distinct folk traditions) do not receive to the same degree in the national framework. 👇👇👇👇👇 5. Resource Allocation and National Institutions -------------------- The policy mentions the strengthening of Sanskrit institutions and the use of Sanskrit to teach other subjects. While the policy proposes an Indian Institute of Translation and Interpretation (IITI) for many languages, the reality is that the historical budgetary allocation by the Central Government has significantly favored Hindi and Sanskrit over the "Scheduled Languages" (the 22 languages in the 8th Schedule). 👇👇👇👇👇 6. Document Tone and Cultural Framing ---------------------- The NEP document frequently uses Sanskrit-derived words (e.g., Jnan for knowledge, Pragyaa for wisdom, Satya for truth) even in its English text. It strongly links education to "ancient Indian knowledge", which is heavily tied to Sanskrit traditions. 👇👇👇👇👇 6. Indirect Imposition of Hindi --------------- Although the policy repeatedly says "no language will be imposed" and gives flexibility to states and students, the structure benefits Hindi. Hindi-speaking states can meet the "two native Indian languages" requirement easily with Hindi + Sanskrit. Non-Hindi states already teach their regional language + English. Adding a third language often means Hindi or Sanskrit, creating an unequal burden. The overall emphasis on "native Indian languages" in a national policy is often interpreted as indirectly promoting Hindi as a link language. 👇👇👇👇👇 Summary of the Bias 1. Sanskrit receives far more rhetorical weight, detailed promotion, and concrete implementation plans. 2. The three-language formula, combined with the above, makes it easier for Hindi/Sanskrit to dominate in practice. 3. This creates a practical tilt toward a Sanskrit-Hindi centric view of Indian culture and education. 4. The other classical and regional languages are just treated as secondary options. 5. The depth, length, and enthusiasm of the language used for Sanskrit is noticeably greater than for others. 6. The structure benefits Hindi and facilitates indirect Imposition of Hindi. ------------- NEP link education.gov.in/sites/upload_f… 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 We request thinkers to record valid arguments. 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 #hindi #hindiimposition #impositionofhindi #languages #classicallanguages #twolanguages #threelanguages

@boldmovenone @sunnewstamil @ECISVEEP Why Tamil teachers are not appointed in permanent post, similar to Hindi or Sanskrit?

@SMuthukkumar @sunnewstamil @ECISVEEP x.com/i/status/20410…

தமிழ்நாட்டில் PM SHRI பள்ளிகளில் தமிழ் மொழி ஆசிரியர்கள் 0 #SunNews | #PMShriSchools | #TamilNadu

@AamIndianTweets @PTI_News Only Maithali is recognised.

@SMuthukkumar @PTI_News Can u tell Marwari, Mewari, Bhojpuri, Maithali, Awadhi, Bundeli are mother tongue of which state then ?

TN can't accept three language formula, will follow dual policy of Tamil, English, says DMK leader Udhayanidhi

@boldmovenone @sunnewstamil @ECISVEEP Share the Factual data, if available

@sunnewstamil @ECISVEEP should take stern steps on this dmk owned family channels who spread fake news.

@dchopra77 @PTI_News When will you say NO to our tax money?

@SMuthukkumar @PTI_News All of 14 states which are ahead of TN in the list have 3 language formuala at school level. And its BIMARU vote who decide what happens all over India no other way round. we dont cry we decide,

@dchopra77 @PTI_News Answer to my basic question of direct benefit of learning 3 languages in BIMARU states in economical or social indicators

@dchopra77 @PTI_News BIMARU states are ahead of Tamilnadu in HDI?

@SMuthukkumar @PTI_News Just for information TN is at rank 15 th on Statewise Human Development index. Did all TN able to stop killing of their brethen in Srilanka. Compare no of billionaire from Hindi heartland + Gujarat and rest of India you will understand .

@dchopra77 @PTI_News Still, their per capita GDP & income is at bottom

@SMuthukkumar @PTI_News They have highest no of billionaire in India.

@AamIndianTweets @PTI_News Current debate is for the states with mother tongue as Hindi

@SMuthukkumar @PTI_News u missed Maharashtra the richest state which has 3 language formula .. and there are Gujarat, Delhi & West Bengal as well having 3 language formula

@dchopra77 @PTI_News Even after getting all PMs historically, getting the policies custom made to suit them and studying 3 languages, why they are economically & socially way below states with ZERO PMs, not favorable policies and only 2 languages?

@SMuthukkumar @PTI_News They have got multiple PM from their state and their vote decide all policies taken by govt.

3 language formula is in place in Northern states (UP, MP, Bihar & Rajasthan) for last 60 years. What these states have achieved with respect to a state with 2 language formula ? Please list down. வட மாநிலங்களான உ.பி., ம.பி., பீகார் மற்றும் ராஜஸ்தானில் கடந்த 60 ஆண்டுகளாக மும்மொழி முறை நடைமுறையில் உள்ளது. இரண்டு மொழி முறையைக் கொண்ட ஒரு மாநிலத்துடன் ஒப்பிடுகையில், இந்த மாநிலங்கள் என்ன சாதித்துள்ளன? தயவுசெய்து பட்டியலிடவும்.

Stalin has reacted negatively to the CBSE's proposed three-language framework, calling it a "calculated and deeply concerning attempt at linguistic imposition." "Under the guise of promoting “Indian languages,” the BJP-led NDA government is aggressively advancing a centralising agenda that privileges Hindi while systematically marginalising India’s rich and diverse linguistic heritage," he posted on X on April 4. He alleged that the three-language formula under the NEP is a "covert mechanism" to impose Hindi on non-Hindi speaking regions. Alleging that students in southern states would have to compulsorily learn Hindi under the new language policy, Stalin asked whether students in Hindi-speaking states would learn Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam, Bengali or Marathi. #MKStalin #CBSE #ThreeLanguageFormula #NEP2020 #HindiImposition #TamilNadu

@SaktiGounder265 @dpradhanbjp Dravidian parties will hit six even with a yorker ball. He is throwing a no ball 🤡

Hon. Minister @dpradhanbjp ji Anyone with a pea sized brain will know that hindi imposition will not be accepted by admk and dmk(The only parties which have chances to win assembly elections in TN).Don't know who is giving these ideas to create ruckus that too close to election

@ValueIn84502221 @SamirPradhann It depends on your age and monthly expenses. Young and exponential spender, even 15 crore is not sufficient. You are early 50s and frugal life style, even 2 crore corpus is sufficient for FI.

@SamirPradhann In India, even Rs. 4–5 crore can mean financial independence, if a person is financially literate, smart and disciplined.

10 Cr = Financial Freedom in India. 🇮🇳 50 Cr = Financial Freedom in the world. 🌍 Do You Agree?

@Parthas07750932 @AgentSaffron All the best for your dreams to come true

@SMuthukkumar @AgentSaffron TN is immaterial Reservation from all Karunanidhi,EPS,JJ needs caste census.Karunanidhi never asked Census frm Cong2009,nor EPS for Vanniar=10% 2021;DMK/ADMK do anything for votes I meant Modi who got got consti validity from EWS to 3-talaq is superior to these D-grade ADMK/DMK

If Tamil Brahmins are smart they can cut a deal with DMK. Stop opposing them politically - in return DMK doesn't bother them. No use supporting NDA anyways because NDA pretends brahmins don't exist.

@Parthas07750932 @AgentSaffron Sorry. My limited brain capacity is unable to reach your orbit of thinking. Limited point is EWS will never get implemented in Tamilnadu, like 3 language formula.

@SMuthukkumar @AgentSaffron Population of SC/ST/OBC/FC will always be greater than reservation coz 100% reservation without merit is impossible. Merit is the priority for jobs/education across world. Reservation is just opportunity In merit if 10 ppl exist all 10 must get;in reservation only some% get in

Over many decades, anti- Brahmin approach has got diluted by DMK. It served the purpose and the power shift is complete. Brahmin's anti-DMK stand is keeping them away from power than DMKs anti-Brahmin stand. If Brahmins accept DMK also as a choice, they can get their fair share in power over the period. I am afraid, if you people can play your cards rightly, you can regain many lost privileges through the same Dravidian eco system.

@lucid_madhu Not really. TB are politically marginalized in TN. DMK has moved onto other Boogeyman like BJP taking state rights , language rights, NEET etc

@Preejit98228437 @whiteuhearttu 3 language formula is in implementation in Northern states (UP, MP, Bihar & Rajasthan) for last 60 years. What is the differential performance these states have achieved with respect to a state with 2 language formula ? Please list down.

@whiteuhearttu Optional schemes ≠ structured school learning. Not every student has access or continuity outside school. If that logic holds, why teach English in school at all? Education should ensure equal opportunity, not depend on optional programs.

Why not ? we've got better options 🖤❤️ Video context : Under ‘Vetri Nichayam Scheme,’ students get trained in the language they prefer. A student who benefited thanked the government in German. #VoteForDMK