Joefrl

@umpire021 @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 I’m just saying “tie goes to the runner” is the same as “the bag or runner must be tagged before the runner tags the bag” and is also the same as “the ball must beat the runner” as it used to be written. Just three different ways to say the same thing, that’s all.

@joefrl @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 No shit..you're the one that said "ties go to the runner"...runner hit bag before 1B secured ball

Don't think it gets much closer than this

@JamesLarson47 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 I just showed you the MLB rule that shows you that you are wrong. Rules 5.09(b)6. It’s not how I see it, it is how MLB writes the rule in the book. The runner or bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner reaches the bag.

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Buddy, your opinion isn't relevant. It doesn't matter how you see it. I just proved to you that MLB is in align with what I stated to you previously. However, you refuse to admit that you're incorrect even in the face of overwhelming evidence. We're done here.

@JamesLarson47 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 MLB rules do not say anything specifically about ties, but they do say the runner or the bag must be tagged before the runner reaches the base. That didn’t happen here. Rules are rules!

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 And because you won't take my word for it... Grok says you're a moron.

@umpire021 @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 The runner or the bag has to be tagged before the runner reaches the base. Was the bag tagged before the runner reached the base? Wake up!

@joefrl @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Yup...says nothing about a tie goes to runner..

@JamesLarson47 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 That’s the myth, that there are no ties. But, that doesn’t matter. Ball still has to beat the runner per MLB’s own rules.

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Lol, I love how you think that is relevant. Buddy, a tie can't go to the runner because there are no ties in the eyes of the MLB

@JamesLarson47 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Read rule 5.09(b)6…….It’s in there. The very 1st sentence……The runner or bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner reaches the bag. In this case, the bag was not tagged BEFORE the runner tagged the bag.

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 I have. Many times. It's not in there. In the eyes of MLB, there are no ties. That's why it says nothing of ties in the rules. Ties don't exist that's why "Tie goes to the runner" isn't a thing.

@scottvt23 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There are no redos in baseball. If the ball beats the runner, he is out, otherwise he is safe. This ball did not beat the runner.

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Well if it’s not an out or a safe then it must be a tie and all ties must be redone!

@scottvt23 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Yes, OUT only if the ball beats the runner, otherwise SAFE. The ball in this case did not beat the runner, pure and simple.

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Does it say tie? No it does not! I don’t care if one beats the other by a billionth of a second! It’s OUT or SAFE! It’s a binary call. It’s either 1 or 0.

@umpire021 @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Rule 5.09(b)6……word for word.

@joefrl @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Absolutely no such thing..rule booknis correct...you're interpretation is wrong

@scottvt23 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Rule 5.09(b)6

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 You instantly lose 100 IQ points by making that argument. There is either OUT or SAFE, NO REPLAY! MORON!

@JamesLarson47 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Rule5.09(b)6……read it.

@joefrl @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Nope. Not a thing.

@joh83391 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There is a such thing as tie goes to the runner, the rule book just uses different words; The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 No such rule. Sorry.

@dalsx11 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There is a such thing as tie goes to the runner, the rule book just uses different words; The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 That’s not a real rule

@JamesLarson47 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There is a such thing as tie goes to the runner, the rule book just uses different words; The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 That was never a thing in baseball. There are no ties.

@scottvt23 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There is a such thing as tie goes to the runner, the rule book just uses different words; The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Show me that rule in any baseball or softball rulebook and I will sign over the deed to my house to you!

@umpire021 @BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There is a such thing as tie goes to the runner, the rule book just uses different words; The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@BalterBobb14932 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Stick to Curling...I see baseball rules confuse you

@Sam11028361309 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Wrong! The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 One of the biggest misconceptions in sports! Its actually not the case, rule book says the runner must beat the throw. A tie is not beating the throw…i think he beat the throw anyway

@chasinnova2 @RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 There is a such thing as tie goes to the runner, the rule book just uses different words; The ball must beat the runner or the runner or the bag must be tagged BEFORE the runner tags the base.

@RJ3000RJ @BaseballQuotes1 Yeah, there's no such thing. OUT! Ball was in the web before the runner tagged.

@castrovince Only physical mistakes can be errors, not mental ones like this.

This was correctly not ruled an error, which supports my theory that there should be no errors. If this isn’t an error, nothing is an error so let’s err on the side of no errors.