Post

bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
please get rid of "malediction" and replace it with kodoku change "shred" to chigiri and the rest of the english names should be jp owl to fukurou, crow to karasu, banquet to en, play to yuu, and all of magatsumi's abilities too or just TL everything hate the inconsistency
v!z 🏴‍☠️@vizualls_

i lowk want the kagurabachi anime to call cloud gouger kuregumo, cuz why is only cloud gouger the only blade translated it sounds cool and all but it doesnt fit like imagine saying magatsumi enten CLOUD GOUGER tobimune and kumeyuri

English
16
10
219
6K
𝐚𝐲𝐚
𝐚𝐲𝐚@https_aya_19·
@Artispheria This is such a dumb take. The blades only need to be in japanese while everything else stays the same
English
1
0
9
441
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 why are half of the ability names japanese (CG's, enten's, suzaku) and the other half english then TLs should be consistent either all ability and blade names are JP or they're all english
English
2
0
7
401
𝐚𝐲𝐚
𝐚𝐲𝐚@https_aya_19·
@Artispheria Also some blades have English translations for their abilities (crow, owl, malediction) which are great bit I also like the Japanese names (suzaku, yui, Mei, nishiki) it doesn't feel constrained and saying they have to be eng/Jap is js restricting for no good reason
English
1
0
0
96
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 the only case where I understand a direct TL is crow, owl, and most of magatsumi's abilities where there is literally no meaning lost in a direct TL inconsistent translation for no reason other than aura isn't doing a good job of translation
English
2
0
2
75
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 the point of a translation is to be able to accurately preserve and carry over the meaning into another language. In the event where there is no easy way to do that (suzaku), it would be preferable to leave the ability untranslated instead of a bad translation for "aura points"
English
2
0
0
72
𝐚𝐲𝐚
𝐚𝐲𝐚@https_aya_19·
@Artispheria If we're talking dialogue translation I hear u but it's just ability names bro. Thisnis the same as in naruto calling abilities "technique" or "jutsu". It doems matter hut jutsu sounds cooler
English
1
0
0
16
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 I quite literally could not care less about aura or coolness in this context
English
1
0
0
18
𝐚𝐲𝐚
𝐚𝐲𝐚@https_aya_19·
@Artispheria And that's exactly your problem. Your lack of aura is what drives you to argue over meaningless translations
English
1
0
0
13
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 im explaining to you exactly why they're not meaningless and I didn't say I don't care about aura ever
bingle🇪🇹 tweet media
English
2
0
0
15
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 let's take "malediction" as an example. Kodoku is an insect jar ritual performed by ancient japanese sorcerers. Magatsumi is an insect themed blade and the "last remaining creature" could be seen as soga himself. He was neglected and locked up, and as a result Kunishige died.
bingle🇪🇹 tweet media
English
1
0
0
40
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 as you can see, the name kodoku has its own unique weight that the name "malediction" just... doesn't carry. Malediction is essentially a verbal curse. The meaning is lost and how the kodoku ritual ties into the narrative and its dichotomy with Enten is lost.
bingle🇪🇹 tweet media
English
1
0
0
11
𝐚𝐲𝐚
𝐚𝐲𝐚@https_aya_19·
@Artispheria A Japanese a word can have multiple meanings that are essentially synonymous to each other. The kodokunis a type of insects curse and the malediction is the act of bringing about destruction. This falls in line with soga since he felt the people of shokoku needed to be destroyed
English
1
0
0
7
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 My personal interpretation of what the "curse" is doesn't align with that but I'll admit that it's just my interpretation and not fact. I can see how you would argue it's a good TL but I personally still disagree
English
1
0
0
9
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 yes its almost like this entire time we've been bickering over our own personal preferences!!!!
bingle🇪🇹 tweet media
English
1
0
0
10
𝐚𝐲𝐚
𝐚𝐲𝐚@https_aya_19·
@Artispheria Bickering? No. Having an intellectual conversation through a respected medium? Yes
English
1
0
1
6
bingle🇪🇹
bingle🇪🇹@Artispheria·
@https_aya_19 that is true neither of us have devolved it to that point I apologize for the comment, I was letting my emotions take over for a sec
English
1
0
1
8
Paylaş