

SAF
10.1K posts

@2AFDN
Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) is a non-profit working to restore, defend, and expand 2nd Amendment rights through litigation. #2A










Andrew Willinger was on the Reload Podcast. Obviously, I disagree with his views on the Second Amendment and Bruen, no point in trying to rebut all that as it's the same old debates. But I do want to push back on his argument that the lower court consensus *is* meaningful. While we say only antigun circuits have ruled on AWBs/mags so far, Willinger argues that several Republican-appointed judges upheld bans. I think that is misleading though, thanks to blue slips. Lots of these "Republican" judges aren't really all that pro-2A. Judge St. Eve, who he cites as an example, has been anti-2A in several cases thus far, not just AWBs. I think even Willinger would admit that if circuits like the Fifth and Eighth ruled on this, they'd easily strike down AWBs. (The Fifth just ruled 3-0 that suppressors are "arms," for example). The Third Circuit may soon be the first to break this circuit unity. Also, the en banc rulings are far from unanimous. 7-4 in the 9th circuit in Duncan, similar with the 4th circuit in Bianchi. Both had dissents that were clearly more persuasive than the majorities (though I'm biased haha). That in and of itself is akin to a soft split.

In a lawsuit challenging Delaware's age-based rifle ban, the state argues that the court should listen to the cases upholding similar laws that SCOTUS denied instead of Lara, an actual Third Circuit case. The state also argues that just because 18-20-year-olds might have a right to carry guns, it doesn't necessarily mean they have a right to buy or possess them: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.usco…


CADOJ finally filed its awaited motion to intervene in Blank v. Santa Clara (our case against high CCW permitting expenses) as to the facial challenges against the authority of localities to charge additional fees, and as to the psych exam challenge. They say they will take no position on the as-applied aspects of the case.











