Teacher EcoSystems Matter

35.1K posts

Teacher EcoSystems Matter banner
Teacher EcoSystems Matter

Teacher EcoSystems Matter

@CreditFlex

Ed Jones, SkunkWorks\edu | Science of Reading mobile app https://t.co/m4S1HuApuh | High School Remixed

Katılım Nisan 2012
3.4K Takip Edilen1.6K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
Teacher EcoSystems Matter@CreditFlex·
@bryanrbeal For example, Cleveland's Catholic schools barely beat the Ohio average for 3rd grade, foundational reading. Yet Steubenville public schools completely tromp far wealthier schools across the state.
Teacher EcoSystems Matter tweet mediaTeacher EcoSystems Matter tweet media
English
1
0
6
1.5K
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
@SoLInTheWild @TheWritingRevol Brett, a bit off-topic, but I'm seeing that yours is a fairly well-off, and rather white-asian school. 1) Do you think this is the optimal grade for them to be learning these, or should it be earlier? 2) Would you hazard an opinion about such timing in less privileged schools?
English
0
0
0
6
SoL in the Wild
SoL in the Wild@SoLInTheWild·
Near the end of the year, once students had become fluent with each @TheWritingRevol sentence-level strategy, I added these charts to their case study booklets and shifted the cognitive work to them: generating their own sentences to expand and creating their own topics for sentence-type practice. An important consideration here is the instructional hierarchy stage of the content students are writing about. If students are still in the acquisition phase of learning the content itself, sentence-level work can easily overload working memory. But once foundational knowledge becomes secure in long term memory, these routines become powerful opportunities for generative learning and retrieval practice by requiring students to recall, elaborate on, organize, and extend knowledge through writing. Feel free to make a copy and use or edit to your liking. docs.google.com/document/d/16Z…
English
2
6
42
1.7K
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
@rpondiscio Funny thing is, when I press most of these people, they actually didn’t hate school. (A few did, mostly who didn’t get systematic reading instruction.) They’re just #EnglishMajoring—and doing it badly. Because they don’t know what else to do.
English
0
0
1
60
Robert Pondiscio
Robert Pondiscio@rpondiscio·
Tip for would be education reformers: take your lead from those who see value in the institutions you are trying to improve--not those for whom school (and childhood itself) was a misery, and whose aim is not to improve but to discredit and destroy.
Naomi Fisher@naomicfisher

This time of year, we put our 16-year-olds through a coming-of-age ritual. We make them sit in rows and write down things they have spent the last two years trying to memorise. We pit them against the clock, and prevent them from talking to each other. We tell them that this is the most important thing that they will ever do and their future life depends on it. We don’t just do this once. For most of them, we make them sit in rows and write things down between twenty and thirty separate times in the space of about six weeks. Maths, English, History, French, Biology….Again and again, they have to keep at it. Each time, we tell them how important it is and they better not have an off-day or be ill. Then we take their papers and we rank them. For some, the result will be accolades and glory. For others, failure and retakes. We know for sure that this will always be true, because these rituals that we call exams are designed to rank them. A third will always fail. There would be no top grades if we didn’t also have the bottom. It isn’t possible for them all to pass. And yet, every year, we talk as if this was not true. We pretend that it would be possible for them all to succeed, if only they and their teachers worked harder. Politicians talk about raising standards and accountability. We pretend that the problem is them not working hard enough, not an exam system designed so that hundreds of thousands fail. We blame them, not the exams. For the truth is that we have a coming-of-age ritual for our teenagers which involves a third of them being told they haven’t met the grade, that they are not good enough. We launch them into adult life telling them that they will carry the stigma of not understanding quadratic equations for ever. We put them all through intense stress, and then when some of them cave in we say they have anxiety and send them to see a therapist. And then we’re surprised when many of them say they just can’t carry on, that they don’t see the point. They don’t see potential in the future for themselves. We need to take a step back and ask ourselves why we do this to our teenagers. For the problem isn’t our young people. It’s not their fault that a third of them fail and many are chronically stressed. The problem is what we make them do. We’ve designed a coming-of-age system with a very high cost in human misery. Every year a new crop of teens will come of age, and despite their distress we just push them harder. We need to ask ourselves whether this is really the best we can do for our teenagers. We urgently need to think again.

English
10
1
47
4.4K
Cedra Crenshaw 🚢
Cedra Crenshaw 🚢@CedraCrenshaw·
Why do failing systems get to judge parents who actually educate their kids? The real question isn't "Are you credentialed?" It's "Why does a system that produces staggering illiteracy think it has authority over loving parents?" Take responsibility. Homeschool. nu.edu/blog/49-adult-…
English
3
3
14
164
Adam Boxer
Adam Boxer@adamboxer1·
If you thought we had "won" the argument about inquiry/discovery vs explicit instruction, go check out linkedin.
English
8
4
60
20.7K
Brian Huskie
Brian Huskie@HuskiesEduBlog·
@amandadeibert It's always a tricky comparison, because not every public school is the same, and neither is every homeschool family. That said, having a foot in each world, I'm confident that my example better fits the pattern.
English
1
0
2
167
Tom Loveless
Tom Loveless@tomloveless99·
Americans annually spend $60 billion on video games and $30 billion on books. That 2-1 ratio will have to shrink if adult and child literacy rates are going to improve. Good readers spend time reading. Currently, entertainment rules the roost.
English
3
0
3
473
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
@IlkhanSubutai @KXander1790 @AlBuffalo2nite The point is more that Black youth become engineers at 1/4 the rate they should. 1/6 in the harder disciplines. Similar for teaching. If you want to raise a people’s economics, you have to follow the well-paying careers. If you wan
English
1
0
0
17
A Gene Robinson
A Gene Robinson@AlBuffalo2nite·
Interesting comparison… but people are intentionally missing the deeper issue. Nobody is angry that young Black graduates are joyful after earning diplomas. Most people actually love seeing young people succeed. The concern is optics, discipline, and whether modern culture increasingly normalizes chaos in moments that historically symbolized dignity and transition into adulthood. There is a difference between exuberance and disorder. Buffalo Bills Football fans tearing down goalposts after a championship is also immature chaos. Conservatives criticize that too when it becomes destructive. But stadiums are literally designed around tribal emotional release, alcohol, noise, and spectacle. Graduation ceremonies are supposed to symbolize achievement, composure, self control, and readiness for professional life. That distinction matters. What some people are reacting to is not “Black joy.” It is the growing cultural tendency to turn every formal moment into performative spectacle instead of reverence, discipline, and honor. Many Black Americans themselves are saying this privately because they want their children perceived as serious, capable, employable, and prepared. And here’s the irony… Previous generations of Black Americans fought through segregation, humiliation, and genuine barriers while still carrying themselves with immense dignity at graduations, church services, military ceremonies, and public events. Suits pressed. Families proud. Conduct measured. They understood presentation affects opportunity. That is not “acting white.” That is understanding civilization, perception, and self respect. The deeper question is: Does culture elevate restraint, excellence, literacy, discipline, family structure, and achievement… or does it reward impulsivity and spectacle? That question applies to everybody. White. Black. Hispanic. Asian. All Americans. #SilentMajoritySpeaks #AStoneGroove
Nick Buckley MBE@NickBuckleyMBE

When black Americans ponder why they are failing in easiest country in the world to be successful - put this video on repeat. Culture. It’s always culture.

English
66
68
333
20.3K
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
@rodjnaquin Something I’ve been pondering: if a median 24 yo teacher asks ChatGPT a question about reading instruction, I’m thinking they may well get very different answers if they enter the exact same prompt into 1) A free, non-authenticated, instance 2) Their own paid acct. 3) My account.
English
0
0
0
35
Rod
Rod@rodjnaquin·
My blog from last December remains relevant—AI debates in education stall because we conflate wrappers (products like ChatGPT) with underlying models, misunderstand AI as oracle rather than text processor requiring human judgment, and treat offloading/plagiarism/hallucination as inevitable threats instead of design problems. Real issue: poorly designed tasks that never required much thinking anyway. rodjnaquin.substack.com/p/clearing-the…
Rod tweet mediaRod tweet media
English
3
3
15
1.1K
beanie0597_2.0
beanie0597_2.0@0Beanie05923291·
It’s truly amazing what God can do in just 29 short years. Happy anniversary to us!
beanie0597_2.0 tweet mediabeanie0597_2.0 tweet media
English
6
1
106
2.8K
Michael Munger 🏖️🔪👨‍🍳
I stopped assigning papers in 2016. All the assignments are video content. I give multiple in-class exams, with blue book essays. And I assign debates and in-class work, with videos of the "lectures" to be watched back in the dorm. Hot take: papers NEVER made sense, anyway.
Timur Kuran@timurkuran

AI just killed higher education’s old teaching model. We need smaller classes and oral defenses for every paper—implying more faculty time, hence more professors. Since banning AI is unenforceable, written work alone can no longer be trusted.

English
8
7
40
6K
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
@Innes434 I don't understand why they munged together G3-4 scores with G8 scores. My district, for example, is 4 years into using an SoR approach. The expectation would be that the 3rd grade scores should rise. But that would be lost in this data.
English
1
0
0
10
Richard Innes
Richard Innes@Innes434·
A new Education Scorecard ranks states and some school districts for academic progress from 2022 to 2025 educationscorecard.org/?utm_medium=em…. It's an interesting report and adds to the discussion, but I have questions. The Scorecard adjusts test results from different state assessments -- which are not directly comparable -- onto a common scale using results from the 2019 NAEP. I am wondering why a more current NAEP, either 2022 or 2024, wasn't used and if there are potential problems with this approach. The rankings are for overall state scores only. I suspect that things could look very different if the results were broken out and compared in a more apples to apples manner, such as looking at white student and Black student scores separately. Page 32 in the NAEP 2009 Science Report Card talks about why such breakouts are important. A similar logic should apply here. There can be a notable difference between making progress and current standing. Consider information in Figure 11 in the national Education Scorecard educationscorecard.org/wp-content/upl…. It shows Tennessee ranked 4th best for reading growth, well ahead of Massachusetts. But check below to see how Tennessee ranked for NAEP Grade 8 Reading in 2024 (most recent available) compared to Massachusetts. Tennessee ranks statistically significantly behind Massachusetts for white student scores. Why didn't the scorecard include current standings along with the improvement information?
Richard Innes tweet media
English
1
0
1
60
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
…stuff. Many of these young adults overcame bad k-8 instruction to rise to a higher level than they were otherwise destined. Good for that. Maybe nice courantes? 3/
English
0
0
0
16
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
…That sent men to the moon, and nearly obliterated abject poverty around the world. That made it possible for you to have an electronic platform to the world, and to connect to anyone, anywhere. Black Americans become engineers at 1/4 the rate they should. 1/6 for the hard 2/
English
1
0
0
23
Teacher EcoSystems Matter
This is the same culture that raised the rule of law to replace the whims of lords. That mastered the global seas. That banned slavery when Africa embraced it. That brought science and medicine to such heights that we died more of obesity than famine, injury, or disease. 1/
Hotep Jesus@HotepJesus

❓ Should black students dance at graduation? So, black students like to dance at their graduation. Why does that bother you, the so-called white conservative? How exactly does this affect your life? Do you hate to see black people joyful? Or do you hate the way black people dance? Where does it say that dance is not a part of celebration? Do you think your rigid stiffness and dull ceremonies make you better than the next human? The better question is, why aren't YOU dancing at your graduation? The cold truth is historical. You were neutered by the Puritans. In the 16th - 17th centuries, the Church of England shunned dancing. They saw theatre and plays as wasting time and promoting sin. They even showed disdain for excessive merriment. The sumptuary laws regulated what people could wear based on social class and wealth. This is the same agenda that led to the Salem Witch Trials. Are you not the same people who cry about freedom of speech and the Constitution? Do you not see how your reactions are anti-liberty? Once upon a time, you whites were taught to suppress your emotions. You were taught NOT to be human. You were homogenized and ushered into groupthink. This is in line with the communist agenda to suppress freedom of expression. You have learned nothing from George Orwell's 1984. So, I must assume that you are communists. At the very least, you are hypocrites and should remove conservative from your designation. You should praise Karl Marx and raise the flag of hammer and sickle. Because that's what your knee-jerk reactions favor. I say all of this to avoid calling you racist. Because I know you are not. There is no such thing as racism. When we call white people racist, what we are really exposing is racial insecurity. You are insecure people threatened by the people of dark skin out of the continent of Africa who enjoy freedom. You hate to see us express ourselves because you were taught not to. What we are witnessing is not hate but jealousy. With that said, I encourage you to break out of the puritan shackles of communism. I invite you to become human again. It is okay to dance in celebration of your accomplishments. No church of England will reprimand you. I promise you, it is okay to be free.

English
1
0
1
102
Vince Boley
Vince Boley@VinceBoley·
Teachers: "Have a great summer! Read some books and get some sunshine and sleep." Students:
Vince Boley tweet media
English
2
2
52
969