Dd

1 posts

Dd

Dd

@DarkPhoenixPics

Katılım Mart 2012
0 Takip Edilen193 Takipçiler
Dd
Dd@DarkPhoenixPics·
@petersavodnik Every time i read one of these retarded tweets the author always, always, never fails, has @thefp in their bio. Like. They are snatching up every proud anti Palestinian human they can to further their equally retarded agenda. Anyway god speed to this "journalist"
English
0
0
0
286
Peter Savodnik
Peter Savodnik@petersavodnik·
It doesn't matter whether Mamdani has "plenty of Jewish top staffers." His relationship with Jews is conditional: I like Jews if they reject this core part of their Jewishness. Many Jews, especially younger ones, are happy to rescind the Jewish connection to Israel, to pretend Israel is a recent "Zionist project" or settler-colonial concoction. That's easier. That's how you fit in, get ahead, signal to the world that you're a good Jew. The question is: Why must Jews prove to the world that they're a good Jew? Why must they rescind this core part of their Jewishness? We're not talking about a policy, or a government or prime minister, or even a war. We're talking about the very idea of a Jewish homeland. Note that the DSA people don't call themselves anti-Netanyahu (although they're definitely anti-Netanyahu). They call themselves anti-Zionist. They oppose the very idea of a Jewish homeland. As does Zohran Mamdani. As do all the Jews he has so graciously made room for. That's not tolerance or inclusion. It's certainly not in keeping with the great pluralism that defines New York. That's a double standard. That's antisemitism.
Carl@HistoryBoomer

This is the wrong story. We are not facing an anti-Jewish pogrom in NYC. My Jewish friends mostly voted for the socialists. Darializa Chevalier is bad because she embraces socialist economics, is anti-prison, and anti-policing. She's a godsend to the Republican Party. I said most of my Jewish friends voted for them, but I also know Jews who are convinced they are raging antisemites. I simply don't see it. Mamdani has plenty of Jewish top staffers, including his deputy mayor for operations and his police commissioner. He was raised by parents ensconced in the worlds of academia and film. He went to Bronx Science. These are not bastions of antisemitism. Of course, he is anti-Israel. Lots of lefties, including lots of lefty Jews, are anti-Israel. Some of the anti-Israel sentiment in America (on both left and right) is fed by antisemitism, but most is not. When I talk to Jewish friends shocked by the bombing of Gaza, they aren't being antisemitic! You can point out that Israel is defending itself, but they'll respond that self-defense does not justify the extreme violence they've seen. You can point out that there are worse horrors in the world (Russia vs Ukraine, Ethiopia vs Tigray, Sudan, Yemen, Myanmar), but those aren't supported by US aid. I think the political class's obsession with Netanyahu's government is bad for America, but it's our current political reality. And being angry at Israel doesn't automatically make one an antisemite.

English
112
99
646
52.6K