GoFly
419 posts


@GoGoFly23 gpt 5.5 meshing a bullet hole? cool story for a demo, terrible for real engineering
i'd bet my paycheck it hallucinates the stress points
English

@GoGoFly23 哈哈!这些都只是课堂上学CAE的入门例子,除了课堂上用,连考试和面试都不用,除非送分。只能说AI非常外行,真正的,比如仿真所有的试验数据库AI能不能不交订阅费就帮咱搞到手?AI能不能把各零件的微小间隙给帮咱找到?只能说AI的泡沫的确灰常大。
中文

Most "3D datasets" are useless for training engineering AI
Pretty meshes. No construction history. No simulation. No manufacturing context. No assembly constraints. A model trained on that produces geometry that is useless for real world applications.
Not all 3D models are created equal.
What's actually needed:
- Feature trees: the construction sequence that produced the part, not just the final geometry
- Simulation-validated geometry: load cases, stresses, what the part can actually withstand
- DfM metadata: how the part is meant to be manufactured, and the constraints that implies
- Geometric and assembly constraints: how the part connects to other parts in assemblies
Anything less is nice-looking meshes with no engineering content.
If clean parametric 3D data is your bottleneck, let's talk.

English

GoFly@GoGoFly23
Dynamic simulation of abaqus bullet penetrating steel plate, static simulation analysis of cantilever beam and tensile plate with circular hole, modal analysis are carried out by using GPT 5.5 model of codex. AI is used to perform tedious simulation setup workflow, only communicating with codex text throughout, and the rest is handed over to codex to complete the simulation work. text to cae. Will AI replace simulation engineers? Or will simulation engineers integrate AI into their own workflow? #gpt5.5 #codex #cae #agent #model #openai
ZXX

Dynamic simulation of abaqus bullet penetrating steel plate, static simulation analysis of cantilever beam and tensile plate with circular hole, modal analysis are carried out by using GPT 5.5 model of codex.
AI is used to perform tedious simulation setup workflow, only communicating with codex text throughout, and the rest is handed over to codex to complete the simulation work. text to cae.
Will AI replace simulation engineers? Or will simulation engineers integrate AI into their own workflow?
#gpt5.5 #codex #cae #agent #model #openai
English

@MattiaFiumara @GoGoFly23 実際に生成されたものですが正しくありません。
ボリュームが片方にしか効かずに壊れてしまいます。
日本語

GPT Image 2 测了一组电路图生成效果,包含原理图、PCB、PLC、和微电子版图。
整体工程感、布局逻辑和图纸完整度让我这个外行看的是一愣一楞的
电气工程师会失业吗?
各位电气大佬来看看 GPT Image 2 生成的电气原理图如何?
#GPTimage2 #ai #GPT




中文

@GoGoFly23 If me, as an engineer, would open an article with these illustrations, it's quite possible that I'd close it without reading. At first they look lehot and then ... then it's clear that it's just AI shit.
Thechical drawings are techical for a reason. They should make sense.
English

@GoGoFly23 @seasonedslacker It's LLM. It should not be used for engineering, it will never be good because it's language model ffs
English

@losslandscape Yes, we need to give AI more precise prompts to constrain it to ensure more accurate output, but AI will indeed
English

One of my personal tests for new models is to ask it to generate simple ham radio circuits. Image 2 is the best yet, but it still gets a lot wrong.
Eventually, though.
GoFly@GoGoFly23
GPT Image 2 测了一组电路图生成效果,包含原理图、PCB、PLC、和微电子版图。 整体工程感、布局逻辑和图纸完整度让我这个外行看的是一愣一楞的 电气工程师会失业吗? 各位电气大佬来看看 GPT Image 2 生成的电气原理图如何? #GPTimage2 #ai #GPT
English

@AssistedEvolve It is true that using code to correspond to circuit diagrams may be more accurate, but how should it be done in practice?
English

@GoGoFly23 No this will not disrupt anything, its the wrong approach. However circuits as code is totally tractable and progress is moving fast in that direction
English

@tobjectpascal Your worries are very necessary. At present, the consideration of AI is not very comprehensive. Most of the circuit design also has many errors, but we can optimize their design through prompts.
English

@GoGoFly23 Yes and no
If anything it should help engineers, drive down cost and save the environment as less versions of the board will ge needed to fix issues
My question does it take heat into consideration if a chip is outputting lots of heat, we don't want capacitors directly nexttoit
English










