J.T. Gardner

3.8K posts

J.T. Gardner banner
J.T. Gardner

J.T. Gardner

@JTGardner94

Shrewsbury, England Katılım Ocak 2010
446 Takip Edilen160 Takipçiler
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@IMPERATORAUS I would submit that this is simply not a theological matter. Questions of citizenship and the makeup of nations is a 'render unto Caesar' matter.
English
0
0
1
249
IMPERATOR
IMPERATOR@IMPERATORAUS·
In his Summa Theologiae, St Thomas Aquinas laid out one of the most charitable yet practical arguments concerning immigration that effectively shaped the West for almost 1,000 years. 1. Immigration must always be proportionate so that foreigners can properly assimilate into the culture and mode of worship of the state. 2. Citizenship – and associated rights – should only ever be granted after the third generation to preserve the culture, mode of worship, and constitution of the state. 3. The common good of the citizens must remain the highest priority of the state, meaning, the state's obligation to provide aid to its neighbours can never be at the expense of the citizens. However, Aquinas ends with the sobering reminder that some peoples and states are incompatible with one another, and these must be held as "foes in perpetuity".
Catholic Arena@CatholicArena

🚨 Pope Leo XIV has sent a WARNING to migrants, telling them how to behave when they arrive into new countries: 'Learn its language, to respect its laws, to get to know its customs, to participate in communal life and to offer your gifts with gratitude'

English
98
1.3K
6.6K
257K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@Catholic_George Alternatively/in parallel: fixating on one aspect of Catholicism and missing the wood for the trees.
English
0
0
1
32
O
O@ozzzmund·
@leamaric Why say sinophobic instead of just racist
English
1
0
1
233
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@DouggieDabbler No, Tim is more thoughtful than that; he just strongly believes in a very 21st century conception of Roman Catholic social teaching. That and he may be aware of how wasteful and incompetent MoD procurement has become.
English
0
0
0
21
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@timothy_stanley Is this going to be like Ian McEwan's book where the Tories are literal cockroaches?
English
0
0
0
39
Tim Stanley
Tim Stanley@timothy_stanley·
Hilarious AND terrifying? Come on, that’s worth a punt.
Tim Stanley tweet media
English
12
2
78
13.1K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@CapelLofft Arguably (with the 1911 PA) the last time the Crown made an actual impact on politics, darkly amusing that it was to further an act of national destruction.
English
0
0
0
17
Capel Lofft
Capel Lofft@CapelLofft·
It was a truly epic effort at obstruction from Balfour. Lloyd George carried most of it himself as Chancellor, voting in 462 of the divisions, but was sometimes relieved by Asquith, his junior minister and various others so he could rest.
English
2
0
18
2.1K
Capel Lofft
Capel Lofft@CapelLofft·
The Commons sittings to pass the People's Budget were insane. It took 70 days of parliamentary time and 554 divisions to pass, with sessions going until deep into the night - quite often until 3 or 4am and sometimes until 9am (!)
English
4
1
44
5.9K
Christopher Howarth
Christopher Howarth@CJCHowarth·
@JAHeale Nothing says "the Conservatives are back" as inviting Theresa May back into the tent. 🙄👻
English
2
0
18
553
James Heale
James Heale@JAHeale·
'Watch out, the Conservatives are back.’ The Tories launched their new £14.3 million HQ last night, with speeches by Boris Johnson, Theresa May and Kemi Badenoch spectator.com/article/inside…
English
71
51
269
28.9K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@Danjsalt Dale has been 'on a journey' as they say. He now will regularly now go to bat against migration controls. Revealed preference: Lives in Tunbridge Wells, population 98% white.
English
0
0
1
136
Dan Salt
Dan Salt@Danjsalt·
Perfect interaction as it is clear that Dale doesn't get what's happening in the country now
J Stewart@triffic_stuff_

Iain Dale left stunned by calm caller on LBC A composed caller named Mike told Iain Dale on LBC that Britain “will remain almost ungovernable until we have mass deportations”. The exchange was striking because the caller spoke in measured tones, clearly articulating a view held by millions of people across the country. Yet Iain struggled to process it, repeatedly falling back on “you can’t do that”. Mike highlighted the obvious disconnect: the British public have consistently voted for lower immigration, only for politicians to deliver record levels instead. “There’s a massive disconnect between the political class and the people of this country,” he said. “We never gave any consent to this and there’s certainly no mandate for the scale of immigration we’ve seen.” When Iain pushed back, saying you can’t deport people here perfectly legally, the caller was unflinching: Caller: “You mean end indefinite leave to remain?” Iain: “You can do that for future people but you can’t do that for people who have already got it. That would be outrageous.” Caller: “Yeah you can. Of course you can.” Iain: “From a fairness point of view, you can’t suddenly tell people who’ve got a perfect legal right to be here that we’re changing the rules now…” Caller: “You can, Iain.” Iain: “Well you can do that but is that really the kind of country you want to live in?” Caller: “Yes!” Iain continued to argue that you can’t “take it out on perfectly legal, law-abiding people”, clearly unable to grasp how widespread this frustration has become. The public didn’t always feel this way. Years of politicians ignoring the public on immigration have shifted attitudes dramatically. As the caller made clear, people never voted for this transformation and the consequences of fixing it now rest with those who created the problem. Well worth a listen. The gap between Westminster and the rest of the country has rarely been clearer.

English
24
44
391
9.6K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@CptHastings1916 Most histories I've read don't engage with the plain fact that the British public were enormously against having another go at the Germans until mid-1939. In general it's a period where historians are usually really blinkered by hindsight.
English
0
0
2
12
NPRG
NPRG@CptHastings1916·
The Lyman-Dannatt book is good if perhaps a little repetitive; however imo they don't take seriously enough the political & strategic constraints on HMG military spending 1918-1939, & don't really interrogate the assumption that Britain could & should have been preparing a large land force for a continental war.
English
3
1
9
1.2K
NPRG
NPRG@CptHastings1916·
Edgerton also seems to want to emphasise how technologically progressive the armed forces were as we entered the 2WW, which appears to contradict the argument in e.g. Lyman & Dannatt's Victory To Defeat that the interwar Army had been very slow to adapt to mechanised warfare.
NPRG@CptHastings1916

I will be very interested to see how David Edgerton expands the claim here that most food was not rationed in Britain in the Second World War and remained available in quantity (from the intro to Britain's War Machine). Presumably he means fruit & veg, fish, chicken etc

English
8
2
18
4.5K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@_Zojka Peruvians do sort of think of them as Americans. I once met a Peruvian woman in a Catholic church in the midlands who got very agitated at about being American. There's some broad conception of America being more than the USA in that part of the world.
English
1
0
1
255
Zojka 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇵🇱
Calling Ulstermen 'Irish' because they're on the island of Ireland is like calling Peruvians 'Americans' because they're in the Americas, it just looks silly
English
219
36
722
109.1K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@BretVDB Says more about the person's prejudices than the book itself. Just a classic bit of reverse snobbery.
English
0
0
28
2.6K
hodgestick
hodgestick@hodge_stick·
I’m not getting any Nigel Farage question time ads I feel so left out
English
2
0
8
425
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@nabulionee2 And yet, you'd never know who it was unless you had seen a portrait of d'Avout.
English
0
0
0
14
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@realhansard Tories got 34.4% of the vote there in 2019. If they lose their deposit, like you said they just become Blue LDs and tbh might eventually die out if Reform completes its professionalisation.
English
0
0
1
25
realhansard
realhansard@realhansard·
Getting 1% is a major crisis. It would confirm the party is no longer a national operation, but has turned into a version of the Liberal Democrats: competitive in some areas, irrelevant in others.
Luke Tryl@LukeTryl

Slightly disagree - at least from where party currently sit if you're the party strategists a seat that wasn't won in 2019 & Ref came second would always get squeezed Instead I think what should set off far bigger alarm bells is if party doesn't make progress in Aberdeen South

English
5
1
35
1.6K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@realhansard Maybe. Probably a recognition that the people they're dealing with are less quiescent than the English, combined with a plan to snatch them later with cctv etc with temperatures cool.
English
0
0
5
2.2K
realhansard
realhansard@realhansard·
One thing Northern Ireland appears to demonstrate, repeatedly, is that if numbers are above a certain level, the police appear incapable of arresting protesters.
English
160
691
14.5K
359.2K
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@ItsTaz1989 Yeah you can stretch the definition to include the defacto empire to well before Disraeli gave Vicky the title, but not THAT much before.
English
0
0
0
7
Taz
Taz@ItsTaz1989·
@JTGardner94 1847? Hakluyt would be surprised...
English
2
0
0
30
J.T. Gardner
J.T. Gardner@JTGardner94·
@BretVDB To be fair, may people were deceived by Carpenter's mistaken statement that Tolkien didn't read anything modern. That's only just being proven wrong. He nominated Forster for the '54 Nobel Prize etc.
English
0
0
1
116