
Manoje Nath
7.3K posts

Manoje Nath
@ManojeNath
Retd. IPS, Former DGP. The Outsider. Neither too left to lead a revolution nor too right to be the mascot of ‘new India.’
Patna, Bihar Katılım Ocak 2010
709 Takip Edilen668 Takipçiler

The biggest challenge is the internal strife,the million mutinies raging inside.I have never seen the caste children simmering like this ever before.
Communal tension never absent is at its peak .No one talks about the siege within.Thr pacificatory institutions of democracy have been jettisoned .
English

@stas_gryshyn Exactly, If India waits until the pressure turns into a real military crisis, it will become much harder and more expensive to handle.
Preparation has to start early, not after the situation gets out of control. 🇮🇳
English

India’s two front challenge is slowly turning into a four front one. 🇮🇳
For years New Delhi mainly focused on China and Pakistan.
Now the situation around India’s neighbourhood is changing rapidly as well.
After the power change in Bangladesh and continuing instability in Nepal, anti India politics has increased sharply in both countries.
Bangladesh has seen:
• Massive rise in anti India rhetoric after the regime change
• Radical Islamist groups becoming more politically visible
• Stronger calls for closer China and Turkey alignment
• Aggressive narratives targeting India’s Northeast and border regions
Nepal has seen:
• Official maps claiming Indian territories like Kalapani and Lipulekh
• Anti India nationalism openly used for domestic politics
• Rapid expansion of Chinese political and infrastructure influence
The bigger geopolitical reality is becoming difficult to ignore now.
The US backed the political transition environment in Bangladesh, while China is rapidly expanding its footprint across both Bangladesh and Nepal.
Bangladesh and Nepal are nowhere near India militarily.
But hostile political environments around India’s borders can still create serious long term strategic pressure if ignored.
India will need to prepare for that reality carefully. 🇮🇳

English

@SandyAhlawat89 Exactly .As of now this is the centre stage of our concerns .
English

Delhi Gymkhana Club with roughly 14K members, has dominated the national conversation today.
That is about 0.042% of Delhi’s population.
And roughly 0.001% of India’s population.
Yet almost every prominent handle, commentator and power circle voice has spoken about it nonstop.
Speaks volumes about our national priorities, our echo chambers and who gets amplified in India.

English

@npojha There you have hit the nail on the head ,a privilege becomes something intolerable if you aren't the one so blessed .Simple.
English

This @DelhiGymkhana kerfuffle.
The only relevant point is absence of due process and not adopting a legal way of undoing legitimate decisions of the past which are no longer in sync with contemporaneous sensibilities.
1/n
English

@ManojeNath @KolvekarC @_pallavighosh I love Wellington club❤️, my Dad was posted their in the 80s, and we were kids, loads of foreigners, horses, hounds and songs like " "there's a hole in the bucket dear Lyser"
English

Let’s talk about the gymkhana club - yes it’s s den of entitlement , snooty behaviour by most members — looking down a on those who don’t ’ fit in’ .. retired babus who think they should matter the most .. Brit stiff upper lip rules - while others like IIC have bent - at gymkhana you can’t wear t shirts beyond a point .. no branded t shirts ..
English

@avatans That is an old hat recycled and worn till it has become tattered. The bureaucrats look after them very well .If they dont who will,poor sods.
English

Remarkable response by this retired bureaucrat KC, a former India ambassador, justifying the “Gymkhana Club” privileges. It gives you a glimpse of the mentality of Indian Babudom.
“… bureaucrats since 1947 worked for salaries well below private sector doles.”
No one forced these Babus to work for the GOI. Why didn’t they work in the private sector?
Interesting choice of word “doles” here. “Doles” are a feature of state, not private sector.
Is he for real?

English

@KolvekarC @_pallavighosh Gymkhana in Wellington perhaps the oldest of such colonial relics. This is lorded over by the military.
English

@_pallavighosh Nahi re .. all are not bad. I’ve been to that club and the members who invited me were very nice to me. Why is everyone talking as if they are doing something wrong over there? That’s not the only elite club in India. We have Bombay Gymkhana here, Willingdon Club near Tardeo
English


@SouleFacts People should be watchful .Trump has a habit of getting away with whatever he demands,don't know why .
English

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s visit to the Missionaries of Charity in Kolkata is no diplomatic courtesy. It is a calculated pressure move aimed at pushing India to unfreeze certain NGO accounts that actively receive American and foreign funding, ostensibly for conversion activities on Indian soil.
India cannot afford to blink. New Delhi must hold its ground and resist any external arm twisting on matters of domestic regulatory sovereignty. The Missionaries of Charity’s FCRA registration, blocked in 2021 and reinstated in 2022, remains valid only until December 31, 2026. That deadline now sits at the centre of a quiet but deliberate diplomatic offensive. India must not let it become a leverage point.


English
Manoje Nath retweetledi

Reality Check 🫚🌶️
A men tested DMART Haldi & Red Chilli Powder in lab costing ₹20,000
After testing, the results that came will shock you:
1) Aerobic Plate count (Bacteria used in Haldi)
Limit~ 1,000,000 CFU/g
Actual~ 1,100,000 CFU/g
Difference~ 1.1x
2) Enterobacteriaceae Count (Bacteria used in Haldi)
Limit~ 100 CFU/g
Actual~ 1500 CFU/g
Difference~ 15x
3) Enterobacteriaceae (Bacteria used in Red Chilli Powder)
Limit~ 100 CFU/g
Actual~ 500 CFU/g
Difference~ 5x
Means according to FSSAI standards limits it failed in test.
Just imagine around 43,000 packs of DMART brand haldi + mirchi powder are being sold daily.
But from DMART side :
• No Clarification
• No Explanation
• No Action Plan
This is the condition of the biggest retailer store chain of India 🤡


English
Manoje Nath retweetledi
Manoje Nath retweetledi

जो आज मंदिरों का पैसा है, जो टेंपल में हम और आप डोनेट कर रहे हैं, अगर वो Acquired Temple है या Notified Temple है तो उसका पैसा सरकार को जा रहा है — इस बात में कोई शक नहीं है।
इसके बारे में हमें और आपको मिलकर आवाज उठानी चाहिए।
मैं ये पूछना चाहता हूँ कि ऐसा क्यों है कि सरकारों को सिर्फ और सिर्फ मंदिरों में ही “mismanagement” दिखता है? किसी Church या Mosque में mismanagement क्यों नहीं दिखता?
और अन्याय की हद देखिए…
You are presuming कि यह मंदिर important है, यहाँ mismanagement हो सकता है — बिना किसी allegation के ही Section 23 of Karnataka Act में notify कर दिया जाता है।
अगली 19 तारीख को हुबली, बेलगाम और धारवाड़ में फिर केस है। लड़ाई जारी है।
लेकिन सबसे बड़ा सवाल यह है कि पूरा Act ही unconstitutional क्यों नहीं माना जा सकता?
2013 से इस मुद्दे पर लड़ाई चल रही है। Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Puducherry और Telangana के Endowment Acts पर Supreme Court ने notice जारी किया था।
लेकिन सोचिए…
जब Waqf Amendment Act 2025 को challenge किया गया, तो मामला सीधे Supreme Court में entertain हो गया।
पर हिंदू मंदिरों के लिए लोग 12 साल से लड़ाई लड़ रहे थे, उम्मीद थी कि अब Supreme Court फैसला देगा, और अचानक कह दिया गया — “Go back to High Court.”
यह सिर्फ कानूनी नहीं, बल्कि समानता और न्याय का भी प्रश्न है।
हिन्दी

@TRAI I have already complained to you twice about the harassment that I am facing at the Hands of number 140 909 8621 .Yet it goes on unabated .Can you please do something about it ?

English

@Chellaney @arunp2810 Does political leadership still fear a couple?
English

My op-ed on how Modi created, and later weakened, the position of Chief of Defence Staff (CDS).
Since Gen. Bipin Rawat’s death in a helicopter crash in late 2021, Modi's government has appointed only retired Army officers as CDS — a shift that reflects both a rethink of the CDS office and a broader instinct toward institutional “coup-proofing.” japantimes.co.jp/commentary/202…
English

Dear @MamataOfficial,
You are non-practicing lawyer cannot appear in court anytime you wish.
According to the Advocates Act of 1961, only advocates whose names are currently enrolled with a State Bar Council and hold a valid Certificate of Practice (CoP) are authorized to practice law, which includes appearing and arguing in courts.
Technically you are not entitled to appear, plead, or practice before courts/tribunals.
Fyi, non-practicing advocate generally should not present in court as an advocate/counsel wearing band for appearance or arguments.
Casual presence in court premises is different from formally appearing and practicing.

English

@patralekha2011 @kumarakshay1 Absolutely true .But that is a tall order they will rather get you petrol.
English

As an upper middle class resident of Delhi, I am happy to give up the car altogether. I can’t drive and I don’t have anyone to chauffeur me around. I like to walk and walking 7 or 8 kms a day is absolutely okay. Public transport or Uber for the rest. This is what I do whenever I am outside India. With zero hassles.
Give me footpaths which are usable and safe streets. Why are austerity- peddlers not talking about this? Is it because they have not walked in recent times and have no clue what it is to be a woman in a north Indian city and walk?
English
Manoje Nath retweetledi

Long read.
India’s official gold reserve: ~880 tonnes.
Gold sitting inside Indian homes: ~30,000 tonnes.
That means Indian households hold nearly 35x more gold than the RBI itself.
Now suddenly:
“Don’t buy gold.”
“Deposit your gold in banks.”
“Earn interest on idle jewellery.”
Why?
Because India imports ~700-800 tonnes of gold every year using precious foreign exchange reserves.
If even a fraction of household gold enters the banking system, the government can reduce imports & ease forex pressure.
Sounds like a good plan yeah?
But here’s the thing, as long as gold sits with citizens, families hold independent wealth OUTSIDE the system.
Especially women.
Especially during crises.
The state may call it “unlocking wealth.”
People call it security that cannot be frozen, tracked, devalued overnight, or locked behind institutional failure.
Because history teaches one thing:
The moment citizens surrender all real assets to systems, they stop owning security and start depending on permission.

English
Manoje Nath retweetledi

Forget Udhayanidhi for a second.
Did even one Hindu MLA stand up and object? Not one?
Nearly 200 Hindu legislators sat there listening to ‘eradication of Sanatan’ speeches in silence. Who exactly are they so afraid of losing power, losing votes, or losing relevance?
Sanatan has survived invaders, empires and massacres. But silence from its own people is a far greater betrayal than open hostility.
English

Shashi Tharoor gloats over the fact that in Keral, his home state ,Christians elected a Muslim,Hindus elected a Muslim, then Muslims elected a Christian.This according to him is the microcosm of the achieved utopia of our secular polity . Hindus must become invisible is the idea of secularism what oft was thought, but ne'er so well expressed. Thank you Tharoor for courageously stating it.
Smita Deshmukh🇮🇳@smitadeshmukh
Shashi's long post of secularism cannot hide a simple fact about Kerala elections: Hindus elected Muslims Muslims elected Christians Christians elected Muslims BUT Together, Christians and Muslims did NOT elect Hindus. Kerala demonstrated what has been the standard of Indian secularism.
English

