Matthew Sitman

64K posts

Matthew Sitman banner
Matthew Sitman

Matthew Sitman

@MatthewSitman

writer (matt.sitman at gmail dot com) // au courant lefty podcaster ( @KnowYrEnemyPod with @samadlerbell) // editorial board @dissentmag

New York, NY Katılım Ağustos 2012
3.6K Takip Edilen34.5K Takipçiler
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
@MichaelPBarber I agree, but I do think it can be interesting/telling how that continuity is narrated, and where room might be left for possible refinement or development, if not by outright introducing discontinuities, then by omission or emphasis
English
0
0
2
24
Michael Patrick Barber
Michael Patrick Barber@MichaelPBarber·
@MatthewSitman I think the key is that he, like his predecessors, wants to emphasize that his magisterium is in continuity with that which came before him. There are always those who--for very different reasons--want to claim otherwise.
English
1
0
1
22
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
Yes! I just started the encyclical this evening, but if you take a step back I think the fact that Leo took the occasion to re-narrate Catholic social teaching has to be among the most striking and essential features of the document
Erik Baker@erikmbaker

2) Near-total sequestration of sexual morality from "Social Teaching." Leo's genealogy of this tradition omits Humanae vitae entirely. No analogue even to the brief anti-trans digression in Laudato si' (echoed idiotically by other tech critics like Paul Kingsnorth)

English
2
9
113
8.9K
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
This relates to a previous post of mine about Leo's re-narrating Catholic social teaching at the start of the encyclical: it seems more than obligatory to me precisely because of how he seems to recognize he's setting it forth at the start of a (possible) new epoch
English
0
0
12
653
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
I'm still making my way through the new encyclical, but an early impression is that one way it most resembles Rerum novarum is how self-conscious it is about addressing a genuinely novel and disruptive force in society, something qualitatively and not just quantitatively new
English
2
0
39
1.4K
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
I suppose what I was really getting at was that he did what I describe and did in the way Erik was suggesting, because I don't necessarily disagree in some ways, but I think it depends. Laudato si' didn't start that way, though given how often elaborations of CST are tied to some anniversary of Rerum Novarum I admit Leo isn't exactly being wildly innovative in form
English
0
0
0
220
Casey Spinks
Casey Spinks@CaseySpinks·
@MatthewSitman I taught this Niebuhr essay in my Politics and Transcendent class this semester!
English
1
0
1
200
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
Side note for KYE nerds: Michael Oakeshott wrote not one but two essay on the Tower of Babel, unsurprising given his emphasis on the perils of "rationalism" (one of the Babel essays is in the Rationalism and Politics collection, the other in the On History volume)
Pope Leo XIV@Pontifex

Humanity, created by God in all its grandeur, is today facing a pivotal choice: either to construct a new Tower of Babel or to build the city in which God and humanity dwell together. In Jesus Christ, this humanity in its grandeur becomes the Way, the Truth and the Life, opening the path for each of us to grow toward fullness. #MagnificaHumanitas vatican.va/content/leo-xi…

English
3
4
63
5.3K
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
If, as Oakeshott once put it, man “is what he learns to become,” then Niebuhr and Oakeshott surely should be among the teachers from whom we seek guidance — instructors who can remind us of the perennial necessity of what Niebuhr called that “fruit of grace” wherein “faith completes our ignorance without pretending to possess its certainties as knowledge; and in which contrition mitigates our pride without destroying our hope.”
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman

@matthew_sitman/politics-after-babel-reinhold-niebuhr-michael-oakeshott-and-the-theological-defense-of-modernity-0ae1f4dfc9de" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">medium.com/@matthew_sitma

English
0
1
11
2.5K
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
@matthew_sitman/politics-after-babel-reinhold-niebuhr-michael-oakeshott-and-the-theological-defense-of-modernity-0ae1f4dfc9de" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">medium.com/@matthew_sitma
ZXX
1
0
8
4.9K
Matthew Sitman
Matthew Sitman@MatthewSitman·
@Sundividedlines @joeyan2 It's never been published, so I think I'll put it up on Medium so I can just link to it for anyone interested. Will update shortly
English
0
0
2
30