
You brainless prick.
No one said Umar was “closer to Allah than the Prophet.” That is a childish strawman manufactured because the actual point is unbearable to you. Umar offered an opinion; Rasulullah did not legislate from Umar’s tongue; then Allah revealed what He willed in agreement with Umar’s insight. One is revelation and Prophethood. The other is a magnificent virtue of a Companion. Only a theological calculator with missing buttons confuses the two.
The Qur’an itself commands Rasulullah to consult the Companions: “Consult them in the matter” (Qur’an 3:159), while Sahih al-Bukhari 4483 records Umar’s agreements concerning Maqam Ibrahim, the hijab and the Prophet’s wives. This does not elevate Umar above Rasulullah. It demonstrates the strength of Umar’s judgement and Allah’s honouring of him through revelation.
Your argument is therefore spectacularly backwards: Allah confirms a Companion’s insight, and you somehow convert that merit into “blasphemy” because your sectarian nervous system cannot tolerate a virtue of Umar.
Rasulullah conveyed the law infallibly. Umar anticipated it correctly. The first is Prophethood. The second is merit.
Confusing them is not tawhid or scholarship. It is polemical illiteracy performing somersaults.
English
























