Roger Thornhill retweetledi

Robert De Niro,
Your remarks this past Sunday, June 14, 2026, during the Rise Up, Sing Out event, a Concert for the First Amendment, at New York’s Town Hall expose the most contemptible anti-American cowardice. You declared that the phrase “we all love our country” sticks in your throat, that America “isn’t so lovable right now,” and that loving her resembles an abused spouse clinging to her abuser. You explicitly stated you “can’t love the country that’s led by Donald Trump.” This is not principled opposition. It is the spineless, self-serving betrayal of the nation that elevated an 82-year-old actor born August 17, 1943, in Manhattan’s Greenwich Village to global icon status.
You were raised in New York’s Greenwich Village and Little Italy neighborhoods by painter parents. Your paternal grandfather’s Italian immigrant line arrived in 1887 from Ferrazzano. This country welcomed those ancestors and handed you the unmatched opportunities of American freedom, capitalism, and culture. You parlayed them into iconic roles in quintessential American films - The Godfather Part II (Oscar for Best Supporting Actor, 1974), Raging Bull (Oscar for Best Actor, 1980), Taxi Driver, Goodfellas - and a personal fortune reliably estimated at $500 million, augmented by Nobu restaurants and other U.S.-based ventures. You have lived your entire life here, profited here, and continue to reside and work here in comfort while denouncing the very system that made your privilege possible.
Yet because voters exercised their democratic right and chose a president you despise, you publicly withdraw your love and reduce the United States to a political accessory you can discard. Your abuser metaphor is not bold rhetoric. It is grotesque inversion and elite petulance. America did not abuse you. It rewarded your talent beyond measure. True love of country has never been a fair-weather transaction contingent on presidents, policies, or election results. It has endured wars, depressions, scandals, and every flawed leader through the commitment of citizens who place the permanent republic above transient grievances. You, insulated by eight decades of success, chose instead to perform your conditional affection on stage for applause from like-minded elites.
This is not dissent worthy of respect. It is the treason of the comfortable. You use the First Amendment protections you claim to champion to attack the nation’s legitimacy when it fails to deliver your preferred outcomes. By equating America with one administration and pronouncing her unlovable, you cheapen patriotism into partisan litmus test and reveal yourself as an ungrateful hypocrite who has feasted at her table only to spit when the menu no longer suits.
America belongs to those who love her without reservation. This does not extend to those who announce their withdrawal of affection the moment democratic results displease them. Once you forgo that love, the reciprocal claim is forfeited. We owe no embrace to such conditional loyalty.
Take your films, your $500 million fortune, your Nobu empire, your Oscars, and your vile ingratitude. Leave. The United States does not require the patronage of men whose “love” evaporates at the ballot box. She will endure - stronger, clearer, and unburdened by your parasitic conditional affections.
-- Joseph Fosco
June 16, 2026

English























