Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology

16.5K posts

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology

@ThinkingInCases

Thinking in Cases Criminal psychology & investigative reasoning Sources, articles, and research referenced in my analysis.

Katılım Kasım 2021

461 Takip Edilen529 Takipçiler

Sabitlenmiş Tweet

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·15 Mar

Welcome to Thinking in Cases (TIC). I focus on criminal psychology and investigative reasoning — examining behavior, decision-making, and evidence in real cases. The goal is to understand how events unfold, not to speculate about individuals.

English

659

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·24m

@ErinGreeneOne Gotcha - thank you.

English

Erin Greene@ErinGreeneOne·16h

@ThinkingInCases That it’s difficult to ID him, bc of the different looks.

English

Erin Greene@ErinGreeneOne·22h

Nancy Guthrie POI❗️ He 👀 different in every shot - do you agree❓

English

2.1K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·24m

@CathyQuinn1231 @NWDisorder1111 I completely understand that, and I agree — they deserve privacy and space to grieve. My intention isn’t to speculate about them, but to look at the broader patterns in the case. There’s a difference between analysis and accusation.

English

Chatty Cathy@CathyQuinn1231·15h

@ThinkingInCases @NWDisorder1111 Of course and rightly so in the beginning, but it’s been 2 mos - their cars, home & electronics have all passed inspection, they’ve been cleared. Ppl have gone to them, talked to employers, written horrible untrue things about them. Can’t they grieve in peace now?

English

New World Disorder 1111@NWDisorder1111·1d

Some of the residents of Catalina Foothills in #Tucson are rude, entitled jerks. Given that one of their neighbors, an elderly woman, was (allegedly) abducted from her home, they should be grateful that media, responsible streamers, and investigators are out there.

English

2.4K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·28m

@theleetch That’s an interesting angle. Blackmail would shift this away from a financial motive and more toward control or leverage. The question would be — what would they have on her that’s strong enough to drive something like this?

English

leetch@theleetch·10h

@ThinkingInCases What about blackmail for Savannah’s silence?

English

272

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

Multiple experts are starting to align on one thing in the Nancy Guthrie case: This may not be a typical ransom scenario. Former FBI agent Chris Roach suggests the behavior, timing, and communication don’t clearly match a crime driven purely by money. Instead, the focus is shifting toward something more targeted — and possibly planned. #NancyGuthrie #TrueCrimeAnalysis

English

5.8K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·43m

@CVPaz0alr @chiIIum Wouldn't it be hard to clean up?

English

C V Paz@CVPaz0alr·1h

@chiIIum If not a red herring, there must have been urgency on the porch to leave blood there and not clean up. Porch is inconsistent with “immaculate” interior of the home.

English

ⓒʜɪʟʟɪɴᴏɪꜱ@chiIIum·1h

How did investigators come to the conclusion that Nancy’s house was immaculate and it didn’t even look like a crime was committed? Did they just assume that, because nothing was broken or taken from the home (etc.)? Or did Annie tell them it didn’t look like anything happened and nothing was taken from the home?

English

1.5K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·16h

@MakeItCrafty I know she owns a car.

English

425

Make It Crafty@MakeItCrafty·17h

@ThinkingInCases Did she own anything that’s not at the house? An old car? Boat?

English

462

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·16h

@NWDisorder1111 …leaving! I always forget that lol. But, then again how does Savannah know Nancy was barefoot?

English

New World Disorder 1111@NWDisorder1111·17h

@ThinkingInCases Well, I believe the presumption is that he/she took down the camera prior to entering the home. ?

English

New World Disorder 1111@NWDisorder1111·18h

Who was the last person to see or talk to Nancy Guthrie other than a family member before the alleged events of March 31/February 1? What was Nancy's mood at that time? Did she express any sort of concerns or was she happy and upbeat?

English

1.8K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@NWDisorder1111 And, why is there no video of her leaving with porch guy?

English

New World Disorder 1111@NWDisorder1111·17h

@ThinkingInCases That's what I think. If the driver pulled up to the front drive, it would be picked up by the door camera. If the driver went to the garage area, wasn't there a camera in that area, too? And I'm curious if anyone can answer the questions in my post above.

English

141

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@hotwire405 @JLRINVESTIGATES 😥

QME

Capt KEVman!!!@hotwire405·17h

@ThinkingInCases @JLRINVESTIGATES I am NOT even opening that can of snakes!!!!!

English

Capt KEVman!!!@hotwire405·1d

Here is CHRIS ROACH on a Call with @JLRINVESTIGATES discussing his theory!!!

English

2.9K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@CoffindafferFBI Is he still alive?

English

Jennifer Coffindaffer@CoffindafferFBI·21h

Nancy Guthrie Porch Guy's Post Event Behavior: Why isn't anyone coming forward with 1.2 million reasons to turn him in? #NancyGuthrie #NancyGuthriekidnapping

English

5.3K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@JLRINVESTIGATES Why?

JLR©@JLRINVESTIGATES·2d

Perp definitely has a leg issue. Where is Nancy Guthrie?

ⓒʜɪʟʟɪɴᴏɪꜱ@chiIIum

English

315

36.9K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@chiIIum Why do you think he was wearing them that night?

English

ⓒʜɪʟʟɪɴᴏɪꜱ@chiIIum·18h

Anyone looking for Nancy Guthrie in Arizona should also look for a discarded pair of these 👇

Grok@grok

Roofers commonly use slip-on spiked overshoes or cleats like Korkers TuffTrax for traction on steep, slippery shingles. They strap or slide over regular shoes/boots, often looking loose/floppy with visible spikes underneath, and provide grip without being full crampons. Popular alternatives include Cougar Paws boots with specialized rubber soles.

English

5.2K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@hotwire405 @chiIIum Good point.

English

Capt KEVman!!!@hotwire405·18h

@chiIIum Makes you wonder if she has ever told her something in the past.....and Savannah did not believe her!!!!!

English

976

Why would Savannah say she was going to call the hospitals too if Annie told her she already called? Yikes. Good question.

English

147

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·17h

@TruCrimeBeliebr @NancyGrace That's interesting.

English

148

True Crime Belieber@TruCrimeBeliebr·19h

@NancyGrace posted Feb 1

English

2.2K

Thinking in Cases | Criminal Psychology@ThinkingInCases·18h

@Destinyb313 @PuzzlingCrime @tekc0mndr Can you see what you're replying to?

English

PuzzlingCrime 🕵️‍♀️🔎📰🚨🗞️@PuzzlingCrime·23h

The pictures being floated around of black and blue eyes on magnolia are from her rhinoplasty not from JLR. I hope he sues the motherfuck ever loving shit out of that lying Cunt.