un-non-materialist

877 posts

un-non-materialist

un-non-materialist

@UMaterialist

Katılım Ekim 2023
329 Takip Edilen21 Takipçiler
Julius VA (aka Andy Lagopus)
@BlueRepublik The only person I can think of who would be a legit case for GMT, would be Ghengis Khan. Took a steppe tribe into a continent-spanning empire within his lifetime, and to this day 0.5% of the worlds population shares his genes. And then without him, it broke into smaller empires.
English
2
0
5
695
🔰Chief Georgist Shill 🔰
I am sick and tired of people treating the “Great Man Theory of History” as just the idea that heroes or wildly influential people exist. That’s not what it posits! Rather the GMT posits that the primary cause or even guiding force of historical change is these men, rather than a larger societal shift happening and them just taking an influential role at the forefront To take an oft quoted favorite and one of the best plausible cases for the GMT: Napoleon. Napoleon didn’t revolutionize France alone, the upheaval of French society and new thought therein predates him, it is completely impossible to deny this - the monarchy was overthrown 7 years before he took power, he had virtually no distinctive role in this massive initial shift. He certainly had a massive guiding hand later, but he wasn’t the *initial cause* of the wave of change, rather an exceptional man within it- but Napoleon is too exceptional and we don’t have enough of his ilk to justify the GMT applying to all of History, despite it possibly working with him (or a weaker version of it). As for Homer’s epics, these men were heroes, but also playthings of the Gods. They simply didn’t transform society, rather they’re a mythical retelling of old set tradition, and heroes engaging in adventures and conquest within this tradition. Funnily enough there’s a better example that Roman Helmet Guy could cite but doesn’t - Aeneas! Virgil’s account of the story much better reflects someone who created a new society and led the future, whereas Hector, Odysseus and Achilles simply… don’t. Your better case would be Agamemnon or Menelaus who actually started the war, but neither of them really made a cultural shift per se. There’s also the problem that the Greek Gods are truly the manipulators here, whereas the GMT ascribes a much greater sort of self-will and sovereignty of decision to its Great Men. Update: I thought about it, and Hector is a GREAT example of someone who people might talk about relating to the GMT but is absolutely not! Many people know of Hector, RHG cites him as a Great Man of History but under the GMT… he doesn’t even come close to qualifying! His brother steals a woman and he dies in battle. What history changed? None! Rather he’s a great man and amazing hero and popular figure *DESPITE* not having a massive effect on the course of history.
Roman Helmet Guy@romanhelmetguy

Homer is the original Great Man Theorist of history. He’s not telling you the Trojans lost the war because of climate change. He’s telling you the tale of Hector, Odysseus, and Achilles.

English
14
34
447
44.9K
.
.@Mv7LFC·
@UMaterialist @njbq7 @sam_isthere @shegoisback You're entitled to think that and I respect it but once again, if I'm right you are quite literally cooked. If I'm wrong then tell me what I've lost? Nothing.
English
1
0
0
13
.
.@Mv7LFC·
@UMaterialist @njbq7 @sam_isthere @shegoisback Judaism is for a specific people. So no, I couldn't be accepted by them. Islam claims to be the final universal message for everyone no matter how race etc, with one book, one language, preserved perfectly.
English
1
0
0
28
حَاء
حَاء@njbq7·
@sam_isthere @shegoisback I hope to see you while I'm in heaven while you're suffering in hell and they put the iron in your mouth full of dirt, you idiot
English
14
0
32
12.5K
Ryan Moulton
Ryan Moulton@moultano·
Every time we have immigration discourse I get tired of explaining to the "right" that a job is where you create more value than your wage, not a sinecure. Somehow it never actually gets through.
English
45
30
502
16.9K
Sridhar Ramesh
Sridhar Ramesh@RadishHarmers·
No. Send more Indians to America. Our population is much larger and we can easily subvert their democracy to our will. They lack the backbone to implement the only effective safeguard (permanent suspension of elections). Let's make Bharat larger. Let's make Bharat maha again.
Sridhar Vembu@svembu

Once again, my appeal to Indians in America on a visa. Please come home. Even if you feel it is hardship and sacrifice, self-respect should dictate your course. Let's make Bharat proud 🙏

English
142
81
1.6K
150.3K
Ben White
Ben White@ape_detective·
@ProphetableTrdr @moultano Because I want Americans to be better off. That’s why. When US tech companies are routinely going to US high schools and IQ testing the 16 year olds and offering the smartest ones free education, then we can be satisfied that our laws don’t disadvantage US workers.
English
2
0
7
203
Demosthenes
Demosthenes@Demosthenesxx·
@blueberry_phase @mattparlmer To you maybe, but to many it is their country... Its been a power since foundation cos it had a large European population at inception...
English
1
0
1
89
mattparlmer 🪐 🌷
mattparlmer 🪐 🌷@mattparlmer·
America is actually an economic zone, and always will be irrespective of whatever tantrum some interest group is throwing
English
55
43
543
35.8K
un-non-materialist
un-non-materialist@UMaterialist·
@RenaldyApreza @worqas China was an economic power. It had very limited power projection outside of its regional sphere for most of history. The arabs and the Europeans could be said to have beeen superpowers.
English
1
0
0
17
Apreza Renaldy
Apreza Renaldy@RenaldyApreza·
@worqas China was a superpower in all centuries of humanity except the 19th and 20th Century. Where both centuries were stolen by England and America . And now we return to the original position
Apreza Renaldy tweet media
English
1
0
3
359
Rahul
Rahul@RahulKurup17·
@mxtaverse If you can't afford to maintain your living standards in the US, you're already living like the poor in India. The US, China & India can keep their economic dick measuring contests going while its Europeans who just sit back and chill with their free education and healthcare.
English
2
0
7
479
James Eisen 🇲🇪
James Eisen 🇲🇪@JamesEisen1891·
Mussolini’s last words were just “shoot me in the chest”. Due to the just world fallacy we like to imagine that all psychopaths/petty tyrants are secretly super insecure manbabies with daddy issues, but in reality often they are perfectly at peace as they are.
Melian Refugee@escapefrommelos

>“And he’s so cowardly and blubbering and pathetic, as are most strong men when you remove their power and they’re and they’re faced with their imminent death, they rarely handle it bravely.” the opposite is actually true. but the worms who wrote this trash would’t know.

English
102
604
11.2K
2.8M
Slazac 🇪🇺🇺🇦🇹🇼🌐
One of my favorite Napoleon moments is when he was exiled to Elba and singlehandedly turned it around in less than a year, he was just That Guy
Slazac 🇪🇺🇺🇦🇹🇼🌐 tweet media
English
108
859
17.6K
860.9K
Maxwell Pompadour
Maxwell Pompadour@ShibaWienu·
@souljagoyteller Why would it be an offense to me if men are paying to see my partner naked? They're losers who can find a woman who actually wants them to see her naked
English
1
0
4
390
Sami Gold
Sami Gold@souljagoyteller·
What is it about OnlyFans paranoia. Do men genuinely have this existential dread about their girlfriends/wives selling images of themselves?
Boss Baby 🌚🌝@Boss_Bee_

Peachita

English
17
5
344
19.1K
netsky remix
netsky remix@iron_redux·
One of the things you don't notice when you're 17 but you do later, is just how much women _enjoy_ the male proclivity for violence
English
48
83
4.7K
256.5K