Dr C D Tilley

1.4K posts

Dr C D Tilley banner
Dr C D Tilley

Dr C D Tilley

@cdTilleyLondon

Dweller in Mesopotamia. Historian, surveyor, land economist. Interested in how societies organise themselves - C13th Oxfordshire and more widely. 𒌨𒁉𒈝𒆠

Iraq / Kurdistan / Mesopotamia Katılım Kasım 2012
1.9K Takip Edilen316 Takipçiler
Dr C D Tilley retweetledi
Tirthankar Roy
Tirthankar Roy@RoyHistory1·
My 2012 book, India in the World Economy(CUP), covered two thousand years of Indian economic history in 300 pages. Research and my views have since changed somewhat, but truly long‑run, integrative economic histories remain rare. What follows is a seven‑point summary.
Tirthankar Roy tweet media
English
9
98
625
22.3K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@dalipolitial @yuanyi_z I think that’s a better to think about it, really. I come across people today who have an idea that British power in India came about when something like the modern UK ‘invaded’ or ‘conquered’ something like modern India, which is a less helpful analogy.
English
0
0
3
224
Absurdipolitical
Absurdipolitical@dalipolitial·
@yuanyi_z About 90% of the British Indian Army in the mid 19th century was composed of Indians , does that mean that Indians invaded India? Lol.
English
5
1
117
20.2K
Yuan Yi Zhu
Yuan Yi Zhu@yuanyi_z·
There were no Indians in Dublin Castle, but there were Irish governors in every Indian province at some stage.
LS@LouiseS1996

@JoyInWinter @CareyBrian @yuanyi_z by this logic India also colonized Canada under the british empire. Doesn't make any sense, does it.

English
92
57
1.1K
213.1K
Dr C D Tilley retweetledi
Vahid Online
Vahid Online@Vahid·
نصب تصاویر #مجتبی خامنه‌ای همراه با آدولف #هیتلر عکس جعلی چهره رهبر جدید جمهوری اسلامی رو با استناد و افتخار به سخنان جعلی و چرندیات هرگز گفته نشده آن جنایتکار دیگر منتشر می‌کنند. عکس دریافتی از بابلسر، سه‌شنبه ۴ فروردین #Iran
Vahid Online tweet media
فارسی
208
1.7K
7.1K
286.4K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@bazzdgrogan @ItsTaz1989 Advocating state promotion of or provision of welfare sits more comfortably with C19th Tory ideology than with C19th Liberalism. Both parties later took a different turn. Thatcher described herself as a Gladstonian Liberal.
English
2
0
5
82
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@MinooFramroze What do you mean the earliest formalised English peerage? The earliest created title of the present English peerage? In which case, I agree. Though the parliamentary peerage in the sense it has existed until now didn’t emerge until the later fourteenth and fifteenth centuries.
English
0
0
1
13
Minoo Dinshaw
Minoo Dinshaw@MinooFramroze·
The earliest formalised English peerage is the Earldom of Arundel, c. 1138. The earliest Scots one, the ancient Earl/mormaerdom of Mar, unknowably predates 1115. If 2019 does prove the last creation, and 2026 the final expulsion, we cannot even tell how far back the roots run
English
8
16
142
6.9K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@yuanyi_z His profile says he’s a biblical scholar and author of ‘The Intertextual Tanakh’…
English
0
0
2
318
Yuan Yi Zhu
Yuan Yi Zhu@yuanyi_z·
You are fucking illiterate if you really think that this obit glorifies Khamenei.
Saul Sadka@Saul_Sadka

The Economist, in its “fighting back the tears” obituary for Khamenei, salivates with true depravity over Trump’s future death in grisly, if ecstatic, terms: “...when Mr. Trump’s body was ashes, eaten by worms and ants.” It makes the Washington Post and its infamous “Austere Islamic Scholar” obituary for Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi seem very quaint indeed. But I read the whole thing so you don’t have to. The key takeaways: 1. The USA is the Great Satan—no scare quotes. 2. For readers who don’t know what “Israel” is, the Economist helpfully translates it in parentheses as “the little Satan.” 3. Khamenei, otherwise known as “God’s Dictator,” had “divine right on his side” and had “countless reasons to hate the West,” which is an America-led “phalanx of morally corrupt countries.” 4. Khamenei was a sainted and humble man, dragged to power against his will, selfless and “heroically flexible” and unassailable—a “humble cleric from Mashhad who inherited the earth.” 5. Honourable in life, but perfect in death: what could be sweeter than delicious martyrdom? What could be “more deserving of paradise-to-come than to drink the pure draught of a martyr’s end”?! 6. According to the Economist, “Freedom, human rights, dress codes for women” are “tiresome Western tropes.” Yes, really. 7. All his troubles were economic: he was tormented by the West and by foreign enemies. All the crimes he ordered—beatings, killings, and so on—were, naturally, merely “a response” to those Western crimes. 8. He “rules by divine authority,” and “his tongue could channel God.” 9. He was just a ”mild-mannered cleric” gazed benignly from billboards and was a great teacher of forgiveness”. We have now surely reached the apogee of the decay of the legacy media in the West. Surely it can't sink lower than this?

English
30
68
987
46.1K
Greg Bagwell
Greg Bagwell@gregbagwell·
Not the sort of warning you give on Day 3 if things are going well or to plan.
Greg Bagwell tweet media
English
7
4
32
2.1K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@AaronBastani @sharghzadeh Yes, quite concerning the results when academics have political power. Snr German NSDAP were fascinated by history, archaeology, anthrpology, and sociology and funded them well. Goering and Hitler were said to have well-used copies of Kantorowicz’s Frederick the Second to hand.
English
0
0
0
548
Aaron Bastani
Aaron Bastani@AaronBastani·
Not long ago @sharghzadeh memorably called Pashtuns the last ‘high fertility whites’. True. Similarly, Iranians may have the last national political elite whose white people read German idealism. Bazargan, Khatami. Now Larijani.
National Conservative@NatCon2022

A man currently called the de facto leader of Iran, Ali Larijani, is a scholar of the German philosopher Immanuel Kant. He wrote his philosophy thesis on Kant. He has a daughter who worked at the Winship Cancer Institute in Atlanta but was recently doxxed and fired.

English
14
33
473
45.8K
Dr C D Tilley retweetledi
مملکته
مملکته@mamlekate·
Huge celebrations in the streets of Iran over Khamenei’s death, despite fighter jets maneuvering in the skies above.
English
35
538
2K
132.1K
Dr C D Tilley retweetledi
Open Source Intel
Open Source Intel@Osint613·
Iranians celebrated in the streets following news of Khamenei’s death.
English
167
2.5K
11.5K
564.5K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@TheWand68425335 I’m fascinated by the tendency to see Indian heritage from the British era as belonging in some way to the modern UK. India was in reality the centre of a cosmopolitan Asian imperial polity. Directed from the small islands in the Atlantic, yes, but something quite distinct.
English
0
0
3
413
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
“French historians have a highly centralised perception of their decentralised medieval past, while English historians have a highly localised perception of their centralised medieval past.” Good academic aphorism from medieval historian, Jean-Philippe Genet
English
0
0
0
36
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@sgautam206 @CorbettCornell2 @policy_uk @mattwridley Some Indians perhaps. Others might recognise India’s good fortune in having such a deep-rooted British heritage on which to draw. And the quote, by the way, implies Colton’s own people, the English. Hardly patronising.
English
0
0
3
21
Saurabh Gautam
Saurabh Gautam@sgautam206·
@cdTilleyLondon @CorbettCornell2 @policy_uk @mattwridley Ok I will explain. The quote assumes that Indians had fallen of their accord and had risen to a level to self govern. Indians on the other hand would say that one of the causes of their fall and staying there was the British colonialism.
English
4
0
1
572
Oliver Lewis
Oliver Lewis@policy_uk·
For anyone who is not aware this is the President of India’s home (originally the British Viceroy’s) designed by Edwin Lutyens. It is a perfect building, incomparably majestic. The inside is even better. A fine architectural legacy of the Raj for independent India. @mattwridley
Oliver Lewis tweet media
English
69
129
1K
86.5K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@sgautam206 @CorbettCornell2 @policy_uk @mattwridley I don’t. I think that’s an important idea. I talk to people all over the world who think they have an innate right to English-style governance but don’t seem to realise that British liberal democracy is the result of centuries of conflict and violence. Reflects well in India.
English
1
0
11
600
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
Good piece. Whether this is the issue over which to change tack is one question; those opposing it seem to feel it is. But a change is surely needed. How did London fail to protect the legal position from the manoeuvring of hostile actors? There is a long game Whitehall is losing
Ben Judah@b_judah

The truth about Chagos. My essay for @thetimes on the deal I worked on in government and what it says about Britain, America and the great game for the Indian Ocean. thetimes.com/uk/politics/ar…

English
0
0
0
95
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
@whippletom @PJacquerie @GHWTowler Leaving them to starve or succumb to disease in a dungeon in Pontefract, or the red hot iron poker are also constitutional precedents that come to mind for removing unwanted kings. As others have said, we do this sort of thing all the time in England. It’s all in hand.
English
1
0
1
17
Tom Whipple
Tom Whipple@whippletom·
@PJacquerie @GHWTowler At least you're a traditionalist about these matters - beheading is, I suppose, in our much-vaunted unwritten constitution as the monarch removal tool. It's what they would want.
English
2
0
0
50
Tom Whipple
Tom Whipple@whippletom·
My opinion, which I am prepared to back away from rapidly, is that there are no monarchists. There are people who don't like monarchy, and there are people like the monarchy as is, but who wouldn't if Prince Andrew was king. But monarchism is liking the system, not the occupant
English
81
1
44
47.2K
Dr C D Tilley
Dr C D Tilley@cdTilleyLondon·
“The story of the intelligence backdrop – how Washington and London garnered such detailed and accurate insight into the Kremlin’s war plans, and why the intelligence services of other countries did not believe them – has never before been told in full.” theguardian.com/world/ng-inter…
English
0
1
1
128