Cyril Achcar

1.1K posts

Cyril Achcar banner
Cyril Achcar

Cyril Achcar

@cyril_a

Prev. @StAndrewsHist, now @McGillGradStudy, studying Byz. Greek & Classical Arabic, interested: 14thc geography & Latin-Turk views. Curious of “Eurasian” M.A.

Montréal, Canada Katılım Ağustos 2009
1.2K Takip Edilen336 Takipçiler
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@daniel_dsj2110 Could easily be wrong - but is that not a young(er) Leo Strauss on the bottom? Can only name half of these men.
English
1
0
0
142
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins@daniel_dsj2110·
Here’s a shrine consecrated to the gods of neoliberalism which is located in the Department of Economics at UChicago:
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins tweet media
English
7
15
100
5K
Cyril Achcar retweetledi
Florian Louis
Florian Louis@flr_louis·
M. C. Gaposchkin, Andrew Jotischky, Thomas Madden et Jonathan Phillips (eds.) - The Cambridge History of the Crusades I : Sources and Crusading to the Holy Land II : Crusade and Settlement III : Crusading in the West and the Legacies of the Crusades À paraître en septembre
Florian Louis tweet mediaFlorian Louis tweet media
English
0
8
25
1.3K
Cyril Achcar retweetledi
mahdi
mahdi@_mahdichowdhury·
This is a magical book. One of the brightest heirs of Eaton's paradigm. Islam as environmental history, as labour history, as multiverse; vocalized in Malay, Tamil, Hokkien, Urdu, Punjabi, Arabic, Persian, English, etc.
mahdi tweet media
小賢者@Chiuchiyin

Westerners often miss that Islam in South East Asia is a syncretization of local culture, folk traditions and Chinese influences which make it very different from Middle Eastern tradition.

English
6
119
760
24.2K
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@DanielABeck9 @shahanSean It was a very common (Medieval) practice. Same was done as far as North Sea villages, fabricating charters given to them by Charlemagne, removing tax burdens (because who can go against big Charles?). Easily the most famous is the Papacy’s “Donation of Constantine”.
English
1
0
1
121
Cyril Achcar retweetledi
Florian Louis
Florian Louis@flr_louis·
Jason MacLeod - Political Thought and Eleventh-Century Populism The Meek, the Many, and the Meritorious during the Age of the Gregorian Reform À paraître en juillet chez Brepols
Florian Louis tweet mediaFlorian Louis tweet media
English
0
4
10
894
Mathias
Mathias@bucephalus424·
That Zhou Enlai swag
Mathias tweet media
English
3
19
297
9.7K
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TiltingatM3 It’s funny you say this, because there’s been so much recently published on the late Bronze Age/“palace economies”, that surely a whole new “stage” will be needed! I’ve always understood those stages, as Marx in dialogue with Locke, Rousseau etc, stressing M.o.P instead of civ.
English
0
0
1
75
npj
npj@TiltingatM3·
The Marxists who think that everything before capitalism and after the Neolithic Revolution was ‘feudalism’/‘the tributary mode of production’ have reinvented the savagery-barbarism-civilization stages from first principles.
English
5
0
40
3K
npj
npj@TiltingatM3·
Leo Strauss usually doesn’t openly correct himself or admit error, but the one explicit emendation I’ve seen is his judgement that Hobbes was the founder of modern political philosophy: “not Hobbes, but Machiavelli deserves this honor.”
npj tweet medianpj tweet media
English
6
14
144
24K
npj
npj@TiltingatM3·
The Discorsi are hard to teach since they’re so long, whereas when I taught in the core here you can do The Prince in one day if you want. It’s so light and bouncy—an allegro tempo, as Nietzsche says. Plus the ch15 is still very daring, and there’s lots to unpack in the allusions
English
2
0
6
281
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TiltingatM3 Haldon’s book on the Tributary M.o.P you mean? Or are you talking about another book?
English
1
0
0
19
npj
npj@TiltingatM3·
@cyril_a Having given it the ol’ college try—it is a book for specialists in Byzantine history (emphasis on Byzantine in its dual sense).
English
1
0
0
30
npj
npj@TiltingatM3·
The trade integration from Pax Mongolica led to such a large balance of payments deficit in Europe—Europeans didn’t make much Asians wanted, so silver flowed east to pay for net imports—that it caused a “silver famine.” The resulting monetary crisis led to the credit money system that forms the basis for modern capitalism.
Memory Medieval@MemoryMedieval

People will hate this but it has to be said.. Genghis Khan is vastly overrated. Yeah, the Mongols conquered a lot of stuff. They were good at war. But that's it. They didn't contribute to human society in any measurable way that affects anyone today. I will bet money you've never eaten a buuz dumpling or listen to throat singing. A large part of the Mongol's success comes from their sheer brutality towards common folk. And brutalize the common folk they did. Sack a castle and kill everyone. Come back two weeks later when people are rummaging through the wreckage and kill everyone again. Capture a bunch of men, women, and children, and make them march at the head of the army's assault, taking the casualties and filling up moats with their corpses. So sure, the war machine was impressive but the slaughter of millions of peasants is (aside from kind of sickening to consider) entirely unimpressive. And in exchange for the slaughter of so many the world got.... ? Mid asian food and terrible music? Weird horse products? "They are inhuman and beastly, rather monsters than men, thirsting for and drinking blood, tearing and devouring the flesh of dogs and men, dressed in ox-hides, armed with plates of iron... bulky, strong, invincible, untiring... They are without human laws, know no comforts, are more ferocious than lions or bears." - Matthew Paris (English Benedictine monk in the 1240s) "They should be called monsters rather than human beings, thirsting after and drinking blood, tearing apart and devouring the corpses of dogs and humans... Devoid of human laws, they have no knowledge of clemency.." "They are extremely arrogant toward other people, [and] tend to anger... easily... They are the greatest liars in the world in dealing with other people... They are crafty and sly... [and] have an admirable ability to keep their intentions secret... They are messy in their eating and drinking and in their whole way of life, [and] cling fiercely to what they have. They have no conscience about killing other people..." -John of Plano Carpini (1240s) "One cannot sufficiently defame the cruelty and artful ability for deception of that people... a certain ill-bred breed of inhuman humans, whose law is lawlessness, whose wrath is furious... overrunning countless lands, which it is dreadfully devastating, killing and horribly exterminating by fire all who stand in their way." -Ivo of Narbonne (1240s) A disgusting people who happen to get very, very good at warfare but highly overrated by people who value martial excellence.

English
35
139
1.5K
106.4K
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TiltingatM3 ...If only because Perry Anderson's historical materialist understanding of Byzantium left something to be desired, even if it did ask some good questions.
English
1
0
1
35
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TiltingatM3 I wouldn't be the best person to ask re his œuvre, as I haven't read too much on early Byzantine history; but he's well known. I more familiar w/ Whittow's "Making of Orthodox Byzantium" & Peter Heather's work. Haldon's "Tributary M.o.P" ('93) book looks interesting tho...
English
1
0
1
32
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TiltingatM3 I do wonder how this connects with the re-emergence of European gold coins (after a many centuries long hiatus) from 1252 in N. Italy. Something I need to read more on.
English
1
0
2
41
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TiltingatM3 It’s an intriguing idea. I think the point about the Mongols that should be stressed, is that they took advantage of a series of crises in northern Asia. They were great warriors, but all their neighbours (N China, Rus, Iran-Iraq) were facing huge systemic challenges around 1200.
English
1
0
1
55
Gareth Harney
Gareth Harney@OptimoPrincipi·
‘Augustus maintained that wars should only be entered into when the potential gains far outbalance the potential losses. He said that risking military action for a small return was like fishing with a golden hook.’ – Suetonius, Augustus, 25.
Gareth Harney tweet media
English
15
148
923
24.4K
ajitr73
ajitr73@ajitr73·
@AsimAli6 Also from Eaton's book. The founders of Vijayanagara were actually some sort of vassals of Muhammad Bin Tughluq. It's never mentioned in any adulatory text on that Kingdom... That reality is replaced by the more pleasing tale of Founders being blessed by a Hindu monk Vidyaranya.
English
2
0
3
369
Asim Ali
Asim Ali@AsimAli6·
Interesting article comparing Israel to the Vijayanagara kingdom, and the perils of not recognizing the limits of power. haaretz.com/opinion/2026-0…
English
10
32
160
11.5K
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@TomBFlanagan You joke, but this is literally how 15th century Humanists understood the rise of the Ottomans.
English
0
0
2
59
Tom Flanagan
Tom Flanagan@TomBFlanagan·
To monitor ‘the situation’ effectively it’s important to start from the beginning. The Phoenicians took Io, *before* we took Europa and Medea, and then Paris abducted Helen.
English
3
0
11
692
Cyril Achcar
Cyril Achcar@cyril_a·
@KEBuHCAH It’s funny you say this, I’ve found it a great way of practicing to read any new script. Did the same when I began Arabic, just for pronunciation practice, since cities are labeled in Latin and Arabic script.
English
0
0
1
455
Kevin Fei Sun 孙愷文
Kevin Fei Sun 孙愷文@KEBuHCAH·
a great simple way to practice reading Tifinagh script is just looking at Moroccan and Algerian place names on OpenStreetMap💡
Kevin Fei Sun 孙愷文 tweet media
English
9
4
127
9K