Shia't Ali علي
2.6K posts


@syedatweetss No....Black and white Imamahs started during abbasid time only,,,they didnt exist before...same is with green colour....there are no special rights for anyone
English

@Noor_as_Sunnah The wording in the hadith of Asma bint abu bakr clearly says Mutah al Nisa not mutah of hajj...!!!
You people put your own words to save yourself
English

@islam78619 It's hard to educate Shias, who don't want to be objective. No one denied that Mutah did occur during lifetime of Prophet(saws), It did occur and it was banned by Prophet(saws) himself. As for Asma then the correct view is that, its about Muta of Hajj.
English

Masha Allah! Beautiful Explanation
Sunnah Discourse@SunnahDiscourse
Our latest video on why mut’ah is deemed zina.
English

@Noor_as_Sunnah There are Hadiths from Asma bint Abu Bakr saying they practised muta during Prophets time...!!
Yes...Hujjah is Prophet saw not Umar ibn Khattab...
English

@islam78619 That needs to be proven with evidence. We have seen some scholars basing views on unreliable reports. So unless it's established then the claim is unproven. Moreover, the Hujjah in Deen is the saying of Prophet(Saws) not Sahabi or a Taba'ee.
English

@islam78619 I have given you the evidence. If you can't digest clear hadeeth that Umar says Prophet(Saws) prohibited it. The decisive evidence comes from the other Shia sects, who don't take Umar as Hujjah , yet declared Mutah prohibited relating it from Ali ibn Abi Talib. Case closed.
English

@islam78619 The ahadeeth are clear, one needs to be objective to understand them. What Jabir(ra) mentions in the hadeeth doesn't contradict the prohibition reported by multiple Sahaba, like Ali, Umar, Ibn Umar, Ibn Zubair, etc. While the prohibition reported by these Sahaba is Qati(definite)
English

@Noor_as_Sunnah dont give your opinions ..show us that it didnt reach him !
English

@islam78619 Jabir was from those Sahaba to whom prohibition of Mutah by MUHAMMAD(S) didn't reach until when Umar publicly re-stated prohibition made by Prophet(S). So to whom it didn't reach had Uzur of ignorance. That's why Umar didnt punish those who performed it during time of Abu bakr

English

@Noor_as_Sunnah I would suggest you to use your glasses and read this hadith that is sahih not hasan !!

English

@islam78619 Please use your glasses before you read this hadeeth. Umar(ra) said that, It was Prophet(saw) who allowed it and Prophet(saws) who forbade it.

English

@Noor_as_Sunnah How Umar ibn Khattab forbade Mutah which was allowed by Prophet (saw) ?
English

@islam78619 Jabir was from those Sahaba to whom prohibition of Mutah by MUHAMMAD(S) didn't reach, until when Umar publicly re-stated prohibition made by Prophet(S). So to whom it didn't reach had Uzur of ignorance. That's why Umar didn't punish those who performed it during time of Abu bakr.


English

Shia't Ali علي retweetledi
Shia't Ali علي retweetledi
Shia't Ali علي retweetledi







