
Jaya Jha
9.5K posts

Jaya Jha
@jayajha
Product. Tech. Startups. Publishing. Development. Original Jokes. Liberal Politics.






From tomorrow, India becomes the ONLY country in the world to mandate SIM binding for WhatsApp, Telegram and Signal. Not the US. Not the UK. Not even China. Just India. The government says “cybersecurity.” Let’s fact-check that with their own data. They already blocked 9.42 lakh fraudulent SIM cards. Already saved INR 5,489 Crore through existing systems. Already froze 24 lakh mule accounts. The existing tools ARE working. So why put 100 Crore+ Indians under surveillance? Cyber fraud in 2024 was INR 22,845 Crore. Banking apps ALREADY have SIM binding. Did that stop it? No. Fraudsters use burner SIMs. They’ll keep using burner SIMs. This rule punishes ordinary citizens, not criminals. The Supreme Court in Puttaswamy (2017) ruled Privacy is a fundamental right under Article 21. Any restriction must be legal, necessary, and proportionate. This fails all three. Meta and Google have formally called it “unconstitutional” and “ultra vires.” Even former Qualcomm VP Parag Kar confirmed Apple’s iOS literally blocks apps from reading SIM identifiers. The tech doesn’t even support what the government is demanding. No public consultation. No parliamentary debate. No judicial oversight for disconnecting your access. WhatsApp Web forcefully logged out every 6 hours. Internet Freedom Foundation demanded a rollback. Industry challenged it legally. Government’s response? “No extension.” Yesterday I wrote about how the Whistleblower Protection Act was never implemented. Today the same government wants your messaging identity without a court order. Won’t protect those who expose corruption. But will track every message you send. This isn’t cybersecurity. This is a pattern.
