joaquind

116 posts

joaquind

joaquind

@joaquind

San Ramon, CA Katılım Mayıs 2008
101 Takip Edilen78 Takipçiler
Luis Capobianco
Luis Capobianco@luiscapobianco·
Too much fuzz about DeepSeek. But how good is an AI so controlled by the Chinese government censorship? What else does the Chinese government controls about this AI?
English
1
0
0
96
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@burkov I agree that human intelligence is much more than language but we *humans* always tout spoken and written language as the vehicle of our advancements. How do you known our internal neural nets are not doing exactly that: predicting next word in stringing things together?
English
0
0
0
43
BURKOV
BURKOV@burkov·
Don't let them fool you: AGI today is no nearer to us than it was two years ago. While ChatGPT might appear to be a step closer to AGI, from a scientific standpoint, it's not: training a neural network to predict the next word is not groundbreaking science. Achieving AGI would necessitate multiple significant scientific breakthroughs. I'm talking about genuine breakthroughs, where real scientists engage in real science, not just enlarging the scale of the autocomplete.
English
238
280
2.1K
627.6K
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@ylecun Once auto-regressive models master planning do you still think we are very far from AGI?
English
0
0
1
158
Yann LeCun
Yann LeCun@ylecun·
Please ignore the deluge of complete nonsense about Q*. One of the main challenges to improve LLM reliability is to replace Auto-Regressive token prediction with planning. Pretty much every top lab (FAIR, DeepMind, OpenAI etc) is working on that and some have already published ideas and results. It is likely that Q* is OpenAI attempts at planning. They pretty much hired Noam Brown (of Libratus/poker and Cicero/Diplomacy fame) to work on that. [Note: I've been advocating for deep learning architecture capable of planning since 2016].
English
227
711
5.7K
1.4M
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@karpathy I think this would be even more useful for people that are vision impaired
English
0
0
0
54
Andrej Karpathy
Andrej Karpathy@karpathy·
I wish I could ask questions of GPT about things that I’m randomly looking at or working with. An omnipresent assistant. Feels tractable, current constraint I think is the ease of I/O, mostly on the embedded side. (prompted by wanting to ask a Q about a paragraph in a book)
English
122
84
1.5K
397.7K
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@ylecun @ylecun You only refer to the pitfalls of LLMs in the context of Generative Question-Answering (e.g. ChatGPT), but what about Extractive Question-Answering where answers are extracted verbatim from the document text itself, thus is more reliable (no hallucination)?
English
0
0
1
18
Yann LeCun
Yann LeCun@ylecun·
Good article on LLMs at Forbes. The media are starting to agree with my much-criticized statements about LLMs. "LLMs as they exist today will never replace Google Search. Why not? In short, because today’s LLMs make stuff up." forbes.com/sites/robtoews…
English
88
170
1.1K
399.6K
Yann LeCun
Yann LeCun@ylecun·
AT&T could make those wild claims with confidence because the underlying technology for all of these wonders was actually being developed at Bell Labs. (I was working there at the time). [The tablet-like "fax from the beach" thingy was an actual AT&T product].
Ben Recht@beenwrekt

These 1993 AT&T commercials predict the future with freakish accuracy! Every single thing exists in 2023. (Of course, none were brought to us by AT&T.) youtube.com/watch?v=RvZ-66…

English
8
27
188
95.1K
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@ylecun Right, I don’t think anyone is denying what @fraser or @ylecun said. The problem is that META did not package it right in their first attempt to expose it to the public, while OpenAI did. Just acknowledge this and let’s move on.
English
0
0
1
348
Yann LeCun
Yann LeCun@ylecun·
From the head of product at OpenAI who just left OpenAI.
fraser@Fraser

@ylecun This wasn't meant to be controversial. I'm saying the same thing as LeCun: "It's nothing revolutionary, although that's the way it's perceived in the public," the computer scientist said. "It's just that, you know, it's well put together, it's nicely done."

English
79
124
936
512K
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@xamat @JustinBasilico I also feel we should talk about the convergence of RecSys, AdvSys and Search (IR) which are fundamentally converging to the same base architecture!!!
English
0
0
1
248
Xavier (Xavi) Amatriain
Ten years ago @JustinBasilico & me published a blog post describing an architectural blueprint for Recommender Systems. I'm now revisiting it by including several alternatives published since, and a new one that in some ways includes all the previous ones: amatriain.net/blog/RecsysArc…
Xavier (Xavi) Amatriain tweet media
English
8
40
214
31.8K
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@xamat @JustinBasilico Great recap!! Not sure your new blueprint introduced anything novel @xamat. For example previous blueprints already have separate models for retrieval and ranking.
English
0
0
0
196
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@ylecun Hey, humans make stuff up… does that make ChatGPT less useful? I think it should defenitly be improved by clarifying fiction from fact through citing sources. The reason ChatGPT is so different (and better) to what Meta has done is the task and the data it was trained on.
English
0
0
0
93
Yann LeCun
Yann LeCun@ylecun·
Excellent WaPo article about large language models and chatbots that corroborates what I've been posting recently: they are useful but they make stuff up. They detail the reasons why large tech cos have been hesitant to release such things for public use. washingtonpost.com/technology/202…
English
58
187
796
197.2K
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@alansaid And advertisements and e-commerce search/recs are contextualized recommendations that try to satisfy multiple objectives (e.g. customer, publisher, advertiser and platform objectives)
English
0
0
0
136
joaquind
joaquind@joaquind·
@alansaid Well, search is just a form of. Contextualizad recommmedations (the context here is given by the query that represents user intent)
English
0
0
0
139
Yann LeCun
Yann LeCun@ylecun·
@DataChaz @Meta @facebook You are making my point. Ask yourself why Galactica was pilloried and crucified while chatGPT (which has similar flaws) was welcome as the second coming of the Messiah?
English
52
11
332
108.7K