Tyler Shandro

8.2K posts

Tyler Shandro banner
Tyler Shandro

Tyler Shandro

@shandro

Husband, dad, and lawyer. Former Alberta MLA and former Minister of Health, Minister of Justice and Solicitor General.

Calgary, Alberta Katılım Aralık 2007
574 Takip Edilen16.3K Takipçiler
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
Separatists also love to quote the Quebec Secession Reference: “The democratic principle identified above would demand that considerable weight be given to a clear expression by the people of Quebec of their will to secede from Canada…” They’ve never answered how a referendum which will end up with about 30% turnout will be “a clear expression” of anything. And with no government party with a mandate to negotiate separation, how do separatists even think this should be given any weight, let alone “considerable” weight.
Tyler Shandro@shandro

Nothing in Justice Leonard’s decision prohibits separatists from running a separatist party with a separatist platform in the next general election. Democracy lives through long established processes for democratic participation. Why won’t separatists run on a separatist platform in a general election?

English
39
25
117
20.2K
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
Nothing in Justice Leonard’s decision prohibits separatists from running a separatist party with a separatist platform in the next general election. Democracy lives through long established processes for democratic participation. Why won’t separatists run on a separatist platform in a general election?
Eva Chipiuk, BSc, LLB, LLM@echipiuk

Today’s ruling by Justice Leonard essentially found that the citizen-led independence petition process cannot proceed because the government did not fulfill certain constitutional responsibilities owed to First Nations. But here is the important point: the Alberta government did not initiate this petition process. Citizens did, through a lawful statutory mechanism created by the Legislature itself. So how does a court conclude that the government failed to fulfill duties that had not yet even arisen or been carried out, particularly when the government itself had not initiated the referendum process? It is also important to understand that the Alberta government has always had the ability to call a referendum on independence at any time if it chose to do so. That is not in dispute, and it was not the legal question before the Court in this case. Nothing in today’s ruling prevents the Alberta government from calling the very same referendum itself tomorrow. So think about that carefully. A citizen-led democratic process established by law is effectively halted, not because citizens failed to follow the legislated process, but because of obligations assigned to government itself. Yet the government retains the full ability to ask the same question directly. Courts and those in government must always have regard to the overall interests of justice, including democratic participation, the integrity of legislated statutory processes, and public confidence in lawful democratic frameworks established by the Legislature. I figured it would be appropriate to reflect on a few words from the Supreme Court of Canada: “…liberal democracy demands the free expression of political opinion” and political speech lies at the core of the Charter’s guarantee of freedom of expression. The Court further affirmed that freedom of expression includes “the right to attempt to persuade through peaceful interchange.” — Harper v. Canada The Supreme Court of Canada has also held that: “…the right of each citizen to participate in the political life of the country is one that is of fundamental importance in a free and democratic society.” — Figueroa v. Canada And in the Reference re Secession of Quebec, the Supreme Court of Canada recognized that democracy is grounded in the participation and democratic will of the people, and that a clear expression of the will of citizens carries constitutional and political significance that cannot simply be ignored. Specifically, the Court confirmed: “The democratic principle identified above would demand that considerable weight be given to a clear expression by the people of Quebec of their will to secede from Canada…” — Reference re Secession of Quebec So how does any of this truly reconcile with a situation where government itself can ask citizens a question through a referendum process, but a group of citizens following a lawful statutory process established by the Legislature is not permitted to ask the question? What message does that send when citizens engage in lawful democratic participation, comply with the very process created by government, and yet their voices are disregarded or treated as something to be feared? Democracy is not strengthened when lawful citizen participation is restrained or silenced. In this case, it was not government stopping the process, but the Court. That reality raises profound questions about the role institutions play in democratic participation and how citizen engagement is treated when it touches controversial political issues. After all, citizens do not hold institutional power. Their power is their voice. And if even that voice can be restrained after citizens lawfully engage in the exact democratic process created for them, what meaningful role are citizens truly left with in shaping the political future of their province and country? What do you think? Should lawful citizen participation be encouraged, even when institutions disagree with the message?

English
233
76
367
175.2K
Tyler Shandro retweetledi
Arsen Ostrovsky
Arsen Ostrovsky@Ostrov_A·
This is one of the most jaw-dropping, chilling interviews I have seen. Watch this Rabbi from London, respond to question about the terror stabbing in Golders Green!
English
1.2K
6.5K
28.2K
1.9M
Tyler Shandro retweetledi
Jason Kenney 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇮🇱
Putin is a weak loser. He just lost his closest European ally. He lost his dictator friends in Venezuela and Syria. His allies in the Iranian theocracy are in tatters. His stooges lost elections in Moldova & Romania. He lost the support of Armenia, and it’s only a matter of time before the Georgian people throw off their corrupt pro Putin regime. He lost his effort to stop NATO expansion, pushing Finland & Sweden into the alliance. He has lost over 1.3 million Russians to battlefield casualties. And now he is losing his war against Ukraine, falling back in many areas & controlling less Ukrainian territory than he did 4 years ago.
Jason Kenney 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇮🇱 tweet media
English
1.4K
3K
12.4K
347K
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
Also importantly, when @ikwilsonsays “Alberta will just keep honouring the treaties”: how would First Nations know that? What certainty would they have? Why would they trust the new legislative and judicial branches of a country that doesn’t exist yet? What have separatists done to show First Nations that they would be a trustworthy partner in signing and upholding a treaty or any legislated right for a First Nation? I’m guessing any Chief will have questions about the trustworthiness of separatists.
Rise Of Alberta@RiseOfAlberta

Keith Wilson responds directly to one of the most common arguments used against Alberta Independence. A critic claims First Nations make independence impossible. Keith breaks down why that claim does not hold up.

English
4
1
7
3.1K
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
The biggest mistake @ikwilson makes: he treats separation as though it can and will be unilateral. (“It will just be status quo. Alberta will just keep honouring the treaties.”) Separation needs a constitutional amendment. It requires negotiations. What is to say that Canada or First Nations will negotiate status quo? Indigenous rights would be renegotiated. And separatists are going to be shocked when they learn that First Nations will have a long list of rights they want renegotiated.   If separatists want to renegotiate the Constitution, why should First Nations be told they’re limited to “status quo”? Which means this is completely unknown and the separatists actually have no plan.
Rise Of Alberta@RiseOfAlberta

Keith Wilson responds directly to one of the most common arguments used against Alberta Independence. A critic claims First Nations make independence impossible. Keith breaks down why that claim does not hold up.

English
1
1
1
608
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
A bigger mistake @ikwilson makes is he’s assuming treaty rights are the only rights of indigenous people. They are not. There’s also various land claim settlements, s. 35 of the Constitution and the rights they have in the Indian Act.   That makes a big difference for his mistaken thesis that dealing with First Nations would be so easy.
Rise Of Alberta@RiseOfAlberta

Keith Wilson responds directly to one of the most common arguments used against Alberta Independence. A critic claims First Nations make independence impossible. Keith breaks down why that claim does not hold up.

English
0
2
3
684
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
Not the worst mistake @ikwilson makes, but there is only one Crown: His Majesty. The powers of the Crown are divided in the Constitution between the two levels of government. (And the separatists are proposing to take all of the federal government’s powers.) There are not “two Crowns”.
Rise Of Alberta@RiseOfAlberta

Keith Wilson responds directly to one of the most common arguments used against Alberta Independence. A critic claims First Nations make independence impossible. Keith breaks down why that claim does not hold up.

English
0
0
0
517
Tyler Shandro retweetledi
Fared Al Mahlool | فريد المحلول
On the ninth anniversary of the chemical attack on Khan Shaykhun in the countryside of Idlib, Syria. On April 4, the Assad regime, supported by Russia and the IRGC, dropped barrels from aircraft containing sarin gas on the town of Khan Shaykhun, resulting in the deaths of many civilians, including children and women. This painful tragedy can never be forgotten. We stand in solidarity with the families who lost their loved ones in this devastating attack. We will not forget what these criminals have done to the Syrian people over many years.
Fared Al Mahlool | فريد المحلول tweet mediaFared Al Mahlool | فريد المحلول tweet mediaFared Al Mahlool | فريد المحلول tweet mediaFared Al Mahlool | فريد المحلول tweet media
English
11
169
445
9.3K
Tyler Shandro retweetledi
Olena Halushka
Olena Halushka@OlenaHalushka·
Why would Ukraine — now sharing battlefield experience and technology with Europe and the Middle East — suddenly give up our people and land that russia has failed to occupy for over 12yrs, just because a real estate agent thinks this may lead to peace?
English
105
522
2.8K
28.3K
Tyler Shandro retweetledi
Lord (David) Alton
Lord (David) Alton@DavidAltonHL·
The Iranian dictatorship’s cruel barbarism was on display again at dawn today when 2 more pro democracy advocates were executed by the regime. Since Monday, 6 political prisoners and one 18-year-old protestor, have been executed. This follows the execution last week of 3 other protestors.  @YvetteCooperMP should urgently make a public statement condemning these executions, paying respect to the unimaginable bravery of courageous Iranians who have sacrificed their lives for freedom. Their heroism and that of thousands of others murdered by the regime must be the lode star guiding Iran’s future - a future based on democracy, the rule of law, protection of minorities and universal human rights: a future which must be shaped and determined by Iranians. @BobBlackman @JimShannonMP @HoAbedini @LiamFox @NualaLoan See x.com/i/status/20397…
Lord (David) Alton tweet media
English
75
594
809
30.6K
Tyler Shandro retweetledi
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
Istanbul. Meeting with Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew. The key topic of discussion was the plight of Ukrainian children and what they are forced to endure because of Russian aggression. I thank His All-Holiness for his support and constant prayers for Ukraine, the Ukrainian people, and our children. I informed His All-Holiness about the negotiation process aimed at achieving a dignified peace. We also discussed the development of the church in Ukraine. I invited His All-Holiness to visit our country to offer spiritual support to our people in this important year for all of us, as we mark the 35th anniversary of the restoration of Ukraine’s independence.
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський tweet mediaVolodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський tweet media
English
246
1.1K
6.3K
293.7K
Tyler Shandro
Tyler Shandro@shandro·
I’ve signed the petition from @bnaibrithcanada calling on the Government of Canada to establish a Royal Commission on Antisemitism. Canada must confront the alarming rise in antisemitic incidents and ensure Jewish communities can live safely and freely. Add your voice: bnaibrith.ca/royalcommissio…
English
17
10
52
14.5K