Tim Thielmann

5.1K posts

Tim Thielmann banner
Tim Thielmann

Tim Thielmann

@timthielmann

Director: Making A Killing documentary. Former indigenous rights lawyer. MLA Tara Armstrong’s DEI hire.

Victoria, BC Katılım Eylül 2023
1.2K Takip Edilen7.1K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
Unpopular take: Getting off the reserve alive is what makes an indigenous person a “survivor,” not having attended a residential school. Here’s why. You may want to bookmark this one. 1/10 🧵
Tim Thielmann tweet media
English
52
309
1.1K
55.3K
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
@TheReclamare This was a significant public service. Thank you for your work and brilliant exposition of the relevant evidence.
English
1
1
58
555
The Reclamare
The Reclamare@TheReclamare·
This🧵contains empirical evidence disputing the conclusion that the remains of 215 children were found in a mass burial at Kamloops Residential School. The burden of proof lies with the Tk'emlúps Lets go🌞
The Reclamare tweet media
English
42
373
1K
43.1K
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
In a democracy, you can die waiting for a heroic politician to save your nation. Or you can do the hard work of changing hearts and minds of the people politicians follow. Chris chose the hard path and he has cleared the way for change.
Billboard Chris 🌎@BillboardChris

Very good news! I asked @PierrePoilievre what he plans to do as Prime Minister of Canada about the abuse of child transition. He was more clear than he’s ever been in vowing to stop it!

English
4
14
96
4.8K
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
@RitaKarakas They are students not survivors and I have spoken with many of them and I have studied the TRC report. Have you? I have also listened to the teachers from residential schools. Have you? I’ve also listened to the defenders not just the critics of residential schools. Have you?
English
3
0
6
574
Rita S Karakas
Rita S Karakas@RitaKarakas·
@timthielmann Tim how about reading up on some history or better yet the testimonies of survivors?
English
2
0
40
638
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
Residential schools saved thousands of lives, but the stories have been buried.
English
48
34
326
40.9K
John
John@9781118555927_·
@timthielmann My uncle died in your residential school. My grandmother hid the rest after that. Literally it was your grandmother and grandfather who are to blame for inaction.
English
1
0
30
498
My Anne Kights 🔻
My Anne Kights 🔻@No_strin·
@timthielmann This may work on a 4 year old you duplicitous cunt. Your gaslighting is so monumentally ridiculous I had to chuckle.
English
2
1
27
136
🎚 The Great One🎚
🎚 The Great One🎚@BasedTJMiller·
My neighbour said the residential school was her only escape from being raped and beaten by her drunk Dad and Uncle on the reserve and many like her feel the same way, but afraid to tell the truth and go against the narrative. Billions of dollars + powerful forces involved.
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann

Nuns and priests and brothers cared for children who came to the schools and many cases because they didn’t have care at home. They are Canada‘s heroes not villains. Shame on anyone, perpetuating, absurd lies of murdered children in mass Graves.

English
3
7
26
537
Rob Crawford
Rob Crawford@Robbievicman·
@timthielmann I was going to put Iain high on my ballot just under KLF but he was removed from it completely when I voted.
English
1
0
1
55
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
If you’re number one priority is to avoid a liberal retrenchment, then the most important voting decision is to keep Milobar and Black completely off your ballot. This is true for everyone who is voting for KLF, Fulmer, or Elliot regardless of which you rank first. KLF has a consistently Conservative track record. Fulmer ann execute. Elliot has an aggressive policy platform despite her past ties. But Milobar and Black? both despise the base and backstab true conservatives. Milabar did it to Brodie when she stood up on the 215 claim. Black did it against Armstrong when she denounced UNDRIP.’s indigenous ethnonationalism. Let them run for the NDP next election. We don’t need them.
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann

Kerry-Lynne Findlay, Juri Fulmer, and Caroline Elliott have each prioritized removing UNDRIP from our laws and ending the grievance-based transfer of money, land, and power. They all say they’ll stop gender transitions for minors and appreciate the need for deep economic reform. Any one of them would be a major improvement over the previous status quo under Rustad. No politician is perfect. I think Findlay demonstrates the strongest commitment to these promises. Elliott has broad appeal, which matters in a general election. And Fulmer has demonstrated charisma, a willingness to take risks, and business success to draw from, which is critical for execution. All three will be on my ballot, and I would be willing to support any one of them if elected. Milobar and Black will not be on my ballot. Milobar carries too much water for the reconciliation industry, and Black strikes me as a phony, pandering Liberal — precisely the kind of politician so many of us joined the BC Conservatives to be rid of. Whatever your ballot looks like, happy voting, everyone!

English
8
8
46
2.2K
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
And anybody who knows me knows that I am not naïve. If any of these candidates betrays the base, the base will coalesce around a new leader. we will make sure of that.
English
1
1
7
225
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
@No_strin The arrival of Europeans increased indigenous lifespans from about 25 to about 75 and has increased indigenous populations by several orders of magnitude. It was the opposite of a genocide. It was a genocrescence— the growth of a people.
English
4
2
12
517
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
@Lord_grimz Well put and the same concern arises with immigration from the Third World.
English
0
0
2
82
Pontificating Paul
Pontificating Paul@Lord_grimz·
True. They saved lives indigenous people couldn't save before Western medicine came. It saved languages too despite languages being lost so that theyd survive the immersion of English Many missionaries figured out the languages and put them in written form . The west was good despite the serious issues that ensued, the most apparent in my view is the intrinsic harms assimilating a stone age society into an industrial one would have, which the West did not understand.
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann

Residential schools saved thousands of lives, but the stories have been buried.

English
1
0
5
227
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
Making a Killing now has over 1.4 million views across all platforms. It is about so much more than Kamloops. Watch it here: lowercase makingakilling.ca
English
0
5
15
904
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
@TheReclamare The narrative for indigenous people in Canada should be a coming-of-age story, not a folkhorror.
English
0
2
19
224
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
Nuns and priests and brothers cared for children who came to the schools and many cases because they didn’t have care at home. They are Canada‘s heroes not villains. Shame on anyone, perpetuating, absurd lies of murdered children in mass Graves.
English
12
82
260
3.5K
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
“ a lot of of us had positive experiences at native residential schools.” Thompson Highway. Excerpt from Making A Killing:
English
4
27
93
2.2K
Tim Thielmann
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann·
This is true in a literal sense. Thousands of lies were saved from TB because of residential schools. Here’s a thread with the data.
Tim Thielmann@timthielmann

You’ve probably heard about the poorly ventilated and cramped living conditions in residential schools of the early 1900s, where many students succumbed to tuberculosis and other diseases. It’s one of the reasons some people blame residential schools for “killing” students. But did you know that indigenous children who weren’t able to attend residential schools actually died in far higher numbers? That’s right. Residential schools SAVED the lives of indigenous children. Thousands of them. Let’s dig in. Tuberculosis and other diseases ravaged Indigenous communities in the early 20th century, killing children at shocking rates due to poverty, overcrowding, and isolation on reserves. Tragically, kids did die in residential schools too, often from these same illnesses. Yet, data shows death rates were far lower in schools than on reserves. Why? Schools, despite their early flaws, offered better medical access: improved ventilation, nutrition, vaccinations, and later antibiotics. This care was simply unavailable in remote reserve communities. In fact, this was one key reason some parents and officials sent children there: to protect them from the deadly conditions at home. Historian Ian Gentles' Quillette article ("Not a Genocide") crunches the numbers: TB death rates in schools plummeted from ~900 per 100,000 in 1907 to under 100 by 1921—a 9x drop—while reserve rates stayed stubbornly high. By 1943, schools were ~1/3 as deadly (230 vs. 627 per 100,000 for First Nations overall); by 1953, just 1/5 (20 vs. 100). Even during the 1918-19 Spanish flu, school deaths were only ~27% of reserve rates. Using the mortality rates above, Grok estimates that attendance at residential schools likely saved 2,000–4,000 lives compared to staying on reserves. Residential schools didn't kill thousands. The evidence demonstrates the opposite. Assessed in terms of their entire history, residential schools saved the lives of thousands of indigenous children from disease.

English
2
3
24
4.2K