

Tyler DeWitt
2.1K posts

@tyleradewitt
Educator, Speaker, Scientist, and Digital Content Creator, who believes science should be fun and education should be accessible.














I know. Sometimes I feel that it is so much for “optics” to show how hard the students are pushed, how many opportunities they have, etc. The problem is, there will always be a small number of wickedly smart (or wickedly well-tutored) kids who do OK (or even great), and their success is highlighted as proof that things are working just fine. BUT…there are far more kids who struggle in 9th or 10th grade but COULD do great with more knowledge and maturity, and it is those kids who are hurt most by schools or districts or parents that are eager to show how hard they can push their brilliant students.








Controversial take (I'm excited to hear from those who disagree with me): putting 9th graders into a true AP Chemistry course as their *first* high school chemistry course is cruel and unusual punishment. I know this is very common at fancy private schools in metropolitan areas. They say their classes are rigorous because the students are so brilliant and can handle it. Trust me: they can't. They are just as lost as confused as any 9th grader, at any school anywhere. I used to be a soldier in the army of private tutors that supported these overwhelmed and completely lost 14 year-olds. In some schools, almost every single student in these classes has to have a private tutor, working multiple evenings a week to backfill an entire year of pre-AP chemistry while simultaneously re-teaching the college-level material that is going by at a screaming pace. I strongly believe that education should be challenging. But it should be doable. It should not require hours and hours every week from private tutors. It should be like a workout that builds students up from the ground, increasing the reps or the weight or the distance a little bit every day. Asking students to run a marathon with no prior running experience is "hard," sure, but it's not productive hard. It's just for show. (And yes, in case you're wondering, I did know ONE student would could handle such a class. She got a 5 as a 13 year-old with no private tutoring. It probably won't surprise anyone that she was in medical school before many students her age had started college. But suffice it to say, she was a bit of an outlier and not representative of most 9th graders, even those at fancy "elite" private schools.)




