@Yeetlethebeetl2 @restoretheW @TranscendentEva Some people need to medically transition. Others don't or can't. Being trans isn't all or nothing, there's many ways to be trans
English
Adrian_Redacted
4.8K posts
Adrian_Redacted
@AdrianRedac
Previously @AdrianReda25234 He/Him Lots of opinions, lots of fandoms
Edtwt || 20 || Neurodivergent เข้าร่วม Ağustos 2024
66 กำลังติดตาม49 ผู้ติดตาม
@AdrianRedac @restoretheW @TranscendentEva Then there’s no need for HRT or surgeries since it’s valid.
When someone socially transitions, do they become the sex they think they are?
English
There's a new biased Finnish study that anti-trans orgs are jumping on, like the Cass Review. It claims gender-affirming care is harmful, BUT it didn't even measure mental health, despite what it says. It measured trips to the doctor. I'm debunking every logical fallacy here.
English
@LizJone55098804 @DelJidz @TranscendentEva We don't know if they actually got much worse or not. We can't know with only recording how often they go to a doctor rather than why.
English
@AdrianRedac @DelJidz @TranscendentEva It indicates that those with GD may have an underlying condition causing the GD but also as those who had gender reassignment got much worse than those that didn't, that the reassignment itself may be the cause.
English
@j0970515696684 @gl4ssprince Yeah but there's not really a reason to ignore their advice
English
@AdrianRedac @gl4ssprince i agree that some trans men do end up having the same levels. it doesnt change the fact that most cismen still would ignore gym advice from them. same with ciswomen and using transwomen as body inspo. thats all im trying to say
English
I don’t think edtwt appreciates how thinspo a1ex c0nsan1 is. Like why don’t I see more threads of her??
English
@Yeetlethebeetl2 @restoretheW @TranscendentEva Socially transitioning is a valid form of transitioning. Not everyone is able to get hrt or surgeries.
English
@AdrianRedac @restoretheW @TranscendentEva -through hormone treatments, are you even transitioning?
Because it seems like the line for being trans is “because I said so”, which is also “because I made it up.”
English
@Resurgamblog @grace_hawthorn @SlightPeeve Lot of terfs have said trans women will dominate female sports. Meaning that women are inherently inferior in all those sports when that's not true
English
@grace_hawthorn @AdrianRedac @SlightPeeve Also, the one thing actual radical feminist have been consistent on, is that difference does not equate inferiority as a human being.
English
They're just setting up the scene to end equal pay for women and bring back sex segregated workplaces and jobs.
Now TERfs have established ALL women are inferior to ALL men at every single activity except babies, then equal pay for women is doomed.
Daily Mail@DailyMail
Transgender women dart players to be banned from female tournaments, says sport's regulator, in a blow for six-time champion Noa-Lynn van Leuven trib.al/qE2rBCR
English
@grace_hawthorn @SlightPeeve I mean claiming women are lesser at throwing things is weird and implies that
English
@AdrianRedac @SlightPeeve it's also not answering the question. the original claim was that "terfs" have claimed thatALL women are completely inferior to ALL men, and i'd like to see the workings for that.
it's not true.
English
@grace_hawthorn @Resurgamblog @SlightPeeve Gymnastics is an incredibly difficult sport that trains kids differently since they're young. Most professional gymnists are really young, unfortunately if they're trans it would be difficult to transfer the skills between groups. Pool and darts are not like that.
English
@AdrianRedac @Resurgamblog @SlightPeeve we're talking about male people claiming space in female sport. why is it, do you think, that male people want to run/ play darts/ play snooker against female people, but not do gymnastics?
English
English
@Resurgamblog @AdrianRedac @SlightPeeve there are *very* few male people trying to get into women's gymnastics bec women are much much more flexible, & stretchy, & men just can't do the kind of things women do in that sport 🤷♀️
English
@j0970515696684 @gl4ssprince Ah I thought you were saying cîs men taking testosterone.
A lot of the advice would still apply to cîs guys, as trans men end up having the same levels, not drastically higher or anything
English
@AdrianRedac @gl4ssprince she takes hormones. people who take test are taking hormones. and when i said "a man who takes test" i meant a trans man who takes test. so now i dont see how what i said is stupid, or maybe you just misunderstood
English
@Resurgamblog @grace_hawthorn @SlightPeeve Or is it perhaps that certain things are viewed as "for women" or "for men" so the odd gender out doesn't get as much support
English
@AdrianRedac @grace_hawthorn @SlightPeeve And over 60% of the worlds professional equestrians are women, proving that statistically, women are better riders.
Does that make men inferior as a sex?
Do we really need to go on?
English
@Yeetlethebeetl2 @restoretheW @TranscendentEva No one has ever said they have no risk. Any surgery has risk. Almost all do not regret it, doesn't mean the current surgery options meet every trans person's needs
English
@AdrianRedac @restoretheW @TranscendentEva You fuck of lol
Wearing a wig and a stress a woman does not make.
I thought surgeries carried no risk and were 99.999999% regret free? ROFL
English
@Yeetlethebeetl2 @restoretheW @TranscendentEva Sorry I don't want to force people to pretend to not be trans if they're unable to medically transition I guess?
English
English
@Resurgamblog @grace_hawthorn @SlightPeeve what about darts, billiards, or chess do males have an advantage
English
@AdrianRedac @grace_hawthorn @SlightPeeve It could be to do with spatial capacity.
But then men are inferior in many forms of gymnastics. Does that make them inferior across the board?
Or is that different?.
English
@Yeetlethebeetl2 @restoretheW @TranscendentEva So they have to completely transition currently to be trans yet that's also a bad thing? Fuck off. People are trans regardless of how far they want to or can take their medical transitioning. Current surgeries may be too risky for some or be too expensive.
English
@AdrianRedac @restoretheW @TranscendentEva Which means they aren’t actually trans. It’s a costume.
Hose who go through hormones and surgery and nearly all unable to orgasm and nearly all are rendered infertile.
English
@Yeetlethebeetl2 @restoretheW @TranscendentEva Very few trans people go through all of that, and sexual function and pleasure won't completely go away for most even with surgery
English
@AdrianRedac @restoretheW @TranscendentEva If they go through hormones and surgeries, yes they are rendered infertile and unable to orgasm.
Yes, putting on a wig doesn’t stop you from being fertile or orgasming, but that’s not really transitioning.
English
English
@AdrianRedac @VarounP17 @nyaraVT People have a "magic power called eyesight".
Most trans simply DON'T PASS. People around them say that they pass in order to be nice but they don't.
English
I don’t demand anything.
I just go into the women’s bathroom. Go into a stall. Pee. Wash my hands and leave.
All I’m asking for is to not be used as a political tool to distract commoners from real issues in the world and to not be hate crimed.
Dermal Denticles@Chondrichthyes1
@nyaraVT You’re free to believe whatever you want about yourself. When you, a man, start demanding access to women’s spaces, you’re forcing your worldview on women.
English
@TolaimShelEldad @nyaraVT Ur really comparing rape to pissing behind a closed door by yourself?
English
@nyaraVT yeah, Harvey Weinstein wasn't "demanding" either.
.... she didn't say no.
English
@VarounP17 @nyaraVT Weird to investigate someone's genitals. Especially since if they're in a closed stall, you'd have to spy on them to know..
English
@nyaraVT If u have a penis n u go into a stall with a daughter or niece of mine. Hope u can take the Caribbean ass whooping we serve to u. U delusional weirdo pedo. We don’t play that 💩 here u have a dick best be swinging it in the men’s bathroom u weirdo
English
@becki_hammil @nyaraVT Pissing in a single closed stall shouldn't be crossing anyone's boundaries
English
@nyaraVT Translation = “I’m an entitled privileged male who can and will invade any/all female only spaces set up for female safety and dignity, regardless of how uncomfortable said females are in those spaces and regardless of whether females consent to their boundaries being violated.”
English
@JackieDavi20008 @sticky_possum If he's claiming to have been on estrogen there would be permanent effects
English
@sticky_possum I thought it was supposed to be reversible ???
English
He's either straight up lying(likely)
Or they gave him nothing but puberty blockers. Cause young transtioners do not look like that.
Genspect@genspect
Detransitioner Jonni Skinner on his experience at the Californian bill debate yesterday. "I wouldn't have been able to stand up and share my lived experience like that if I didn't have such kind people supporting me that day. Wiener had tried to call all of us opposing his bill hateful, tried to claim we hate trans people to dismiss our testimonies. It was interesting, as a member of the committee did stick up for us, though I still felt as if my testimony fell on deaf ears. Many people seem to be under the impression that gender identity and sexual orientation are two sides of the same coin, instead of one being a pattern of behavior/experience that carries no harm and the other (gender identity that is) is a start towards a path of medicalization that will carry long lasting effects and far reaching consequences. I'm very grateful to have the support to cultivate the resilience to take an experience that ruined my life and try to do something good with it by educating the public, stopping the same harm from befalling another, and hopefully to help foster a conversation around how we might address these sorts of issues in a more holistic way, with non-medicalized approaches that foster confidence and self-acceptance rather than suggesting body modification as a solution to emotional distress." ____________ Across X we are witnessing powerful testimonies from Detransitioners giving evidence to California lawmakers. They were making representations on Bill 934 - a bill which could ban qualified therapists supporting people experiencing confusion around “gender.” Genspect ambassador @JonniSkinner talked about his inability to experience orgasms subsequent to taking puberty blockers and cross sex hormones. We asked him how he felt about the committee hearing. Above are his words. This photo was taken outside the courthouse yesterday. The vote is out on whether it was before or after he gave evidence!
English