Abdulaziz

27.6K posts

Abdulaziz banner
Abdulaziz

Abdulaziz

@iz3us

ما نحايد فيك .. والعلم الوكاد .. أنتِ ما مثلك بهالدنيا .. بلد ..

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia เข้าร่วม Haziran 2011
1.2K กำลังติดตาม663 ผู้ติดตาม
Abdulaziz
Abdulaziz@iz3us·
All narrations trace back to a single narrator, Urwa, who uniquely reported from Aisha, and his son Hisham uniquely transmitted from him. The issue lies with Hisham. Ibn Hajar, in Hady al-Sari and al-Tahdhib, cites Abd al-Rahman ibn Yusuf ibn Kharash, who said that Imam Malik disapproved of Hisham. Malik criticized Hisham’s narrations in Iraq, noting that Hisham visited Kufa three times. On his first visit, he said, “My father told me, he heard Aisha”; on the second, “My father informed me from Aisha”; and on the third, simply “My father from Aisha.”In essence, Hisham was trustworthy in Medina, but his memory deteriorated in Iraq, where he began to practice tadlis (attributing a narration to someone other than its source). He used the weaker term “from” (‘an) instead of “I heard” or “he told me,” which are stronger in hadith terminology. The narration in Bukhari uses “from my father,” supporting doubts about its chain. Crucially, Imam Malik stated that Hisham’s narrations in Iraq are unacceptable. Since all narrators of this hadith are Iraqi, it confirms Hisham narrated it in Iraq after his memory weakened. It is implausible that Hisham, who lived long in Medina, never mentioned this hadith there. Thus, no reference to Aisha’s age at marriage appears in Imam Malik’s Muwatta, despite Malik directly interacting with Hisham in Medina. These two issues—Hisham’s weakened memory and the Iraqi origin of the narration—cast doubt on the hadith’s chain, alongside its flawed content, as confirmed by historical comparison.Conclusion: Aisha married the Prophet at 18, not 9, as the Bukhari narration is flawed in both text and chain. It contradicts reason, Islamic law, authentic hadiths, customs, and the timeline of the Prophetic mission. We should not overly revere Bukhari and Muslim at the expense of the Prophet. We can accept what they rejected and reject what they accepted. Islam is not confined to jurists, hadith scholars, or their era. We can critique and reject much of the myths and errors in hadith, fiqh, biography, and exegesis books. These are human works, not sacred or divine. We and the scholars of the past are equal in our humanity; their correct deeds benefit them, but their errors affect us.
English
0
0
0
11
Wolfgang vonScheisskopf
Wolfgang vonScheisskopf@vonscheiss54485·
@iz3us @martianwyrdlord Y some imams and Sharia judges but not all of them not all sects of Islam. They also condemn the victims to either death by stoning or force them to marry their rapist/violator so I won't accept your sanitized version of what Islam preaches when it is so open to local imam abuse.
English
1
0
0
10
Abdulaziz
Abdulaziz@iz3us·
@Tenshiretto طيب ممكن اعرف هذا تساؤل للمعرفة ولا فقط تدخل فيما لا يعنيك؟
العربية
0
0
0
687
Abdulaziz
Abdulaziz@iz3us·
@qahtani_m1 @oncalls6 بيكنسل صفقة بملايين ويدخله منها ملايين عشان تشجيع فريق؟
العربية
0
1
1
166
ابو عبدالكريم القحطاني
موضوع اوسمين باختصار : الادارة السابقة مسلمة المفاوضات وكيل تعاقدات نصراوي والرئيس جالس في فندق باريس ياكل بوف بورغينيون 🤡
العربية
24
44
98
44.8K
Nate T.
Nate T.@Tirroneous777·
People absolutely misuse religion to justify evil. That’s not the dispute. The distinction is whether they are acting against the doctrine or appealing to categories already embedded in the doctrine. The KKK had to corrupt Christianity to justify racial supremacy. Classical Islamic law already contains outsider categories that bad actors actively invoke to excuse abuse.
English
1
0
0
16
Wolfgang vonScheisskopf
Wolfgang vonScheisskopf@vonscheiss54485·
@iz3us @martianwyrdlord Doesn't Islam require that 4 men must verify the rape in several Muslim sects? How does that correlate to "if you rape you get beheaded" when an unknown number, but not small, of clerics follow that as Sharia law?
English
1
0
0
23
Abdulaziz
Abdulaziz@iz3us·
@Tirroneous777 @martianwyrdlord You just are answering yourself. KKK used to kill slaves in US by order of their god. Used to believe that white is godly race. So you can see where this is going. People have used religions for their gains.
English
1
0
1
142
Nate T.
Nate T.@Tirroneous777·
That may be true, but it doesn’t address the deeper concern. The question isn’t whether Islam punishes rape. It’s how Islamic law contains status-based categories (i.e., slave, captive, dhimmi, apostate, enemy..) and exploit this to justify their actions. Many Muslims reject those applications entirely. But those who want to justify abuse actively use those categories as the loophole.
English
1
0
0
145
Abdulaziz
Abdulaziz@iz3us·
@earlfromchatham @jmay111 @Sativa888 @martianwyrdlord Actually I'm staying home. I don't need boats to leave my country and steal someone's land calling it my land. Just imagine an European leaving his homeland to some other continent and call it homeland. OK grandpa?
English
0
0
0
52
Cutter
Cutter@Cutter1616·
@iz3us @martianwyrdlord Of course. But the worst offenders where actually the Nationals. Why? Because they could get away with it. Sorry but Arab Nationals from the GCC are the worst because they get special treatment..same as the immigrants in the west!
English
1
0
0
13