پن کیا گیا ٹویٹ
Fr. Paul
77.9K posts
Fr. Paul
@BackwardsFeet
catholic priest of 10,000 takes God, gains, and games personal account
شامل ہوئے Şubat 2013
623 فالونگ30.9K فالوورز
Fr. Paul ری ٹویٹ کیا
"All Christians must reject unjust discrimination on the basis of religion or ethnicity. But that principle must not be misused to silence legitimate criticism of governments."
Archbishop Sample@ArchbishpSample
I urge my fellow Christians to approach these matters not through the lens of personal ideology or political preference, but according to the moral principles handed on by Holy Mother Church and her magisterium. All Christians must reject unjust discrimination on the basis of religion or ethnicity. But that principle must not be misused to silence legitimate criticism of governments.
English
Fr. Paul ری ٹویٹ کیا
Interestingly, equating "the Jewish people" to "the state of Israel" leads to both disgusting antisemitism AND an inability to critique Israeli actions.
English
@KirbyODonnell22 The person who was quoting Joseph Goebbels in my replies probably disagrees with you
English
@BackwardsFeet Absolutely no one hates Jews for being Jewish.
English
Let's be clear.
Anti-Semitism, which is a hatred rooted in ethnic or religious reasons, is evil.
However, disagreement with the political and military actions of the modern state of Israel is not that.
U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops@USCCB
Catholics are called to reject antisemitism and the lies and conspiracies that fuel it, and to stand clearly against hatred and violence directed toward our Jewish brothers and sisters. To defend religious freedom with integrity, we must also reject antisemitism. @ArchbishpSample @archdpdx Watch the full video at: ow.ly/sYF550Yw6cA
English
@TBroberg63939 That's absolutely not what I'm doing, my post is very clear, it's incredibly uncharitable for you to assume that.
English
@BackwardsFeet It sounds like you are trying to excuse the rising antisemitism amongst some members of the Church. As a Catholic myself, it has been breaking my heart. Please don't try to deny that it is happening.
English
@BonumBoniBono Because take a look around the comment section and you can see that it's not actually clear to first graders.
English
@BackwardsFeet Why do we have to clarify what 1st graders already know? We’re adults. We don’t hate people because they’re different. We love our enemies. Makes sense. But can we drop the albatross around our necks and proceed with the natural reaction to being targeted by crazy people?
English
@Gailsaysso Yes, which is why it's all the more important to make very clear distinctions as my post is doing.
English
@BackwardsFeet Of course, Fr. Paul, but what is also true is that there are people who will use such disagreements as a way to obscure their hatred. This is nothing new. The same old Jew hatred only people are a little more sophisticated these days.
English
@s_sultzer You are committing the exact error I mention in my tweet by comparing being a Jew as being equivalent to the country of Israel.
It is also not the case that all actions are fair in war.
English
@BackwardsFeet Damn the Jews for refusing to be destroyed by Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iran after Oct, 7. I don't know, Fr., but that sounds a lot like it has firm roots in anti-Semitism.
English
@ShimonKefa76 there is, of course, such a thing as nuance and decisions beyond a black or white "rolling over" and "anything goes"
English
@BackwardsFeet Because of course had their Iranian funded bombs gone off accidentally in their residential property blowing up and killing our parishioners we should have just rolled over and said “as you were nice mr ayatollah carry on promoting worldwide terrror! Sorry to get in your way”
English
@ShimonKefa76 No, it is not legitimate to do "anything" to stop such a regime, which is also why Hiroshima and Nagasaki were evil.
English
@BackwardsFeet Just for a bit of extra info the Iranian Government had a cell of terrorists planning to blow up Jews in England 300m from the front door of our parish Church in Rochdale. Anything we can do stop such an evil regime is surely legitimate.
English
@ShimonKefa76 The United States of America were unquestionably evil when they bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki, yes.
Targeting of innocent civilians, or even targeting military targets when there will be a disproportionate number of civilians killed, is evil.
English
@BackwardsFeet Support of blatantly antisemitic systems
And regimes is equally abhorrent!
Would America have gone to war if Pearl harbour had only been 1200 (Oct7) instead of 2400? America killed more in 2 days in Japan than Israel has in 2.5 years! States kill people especially yours!
English
@hoomver41 Is that why someone has already disagreed with me by replying with a quote from Joseph Goebbels?
English
@BackwardsFeet There is no special unique hatred called antisemitism. It’s a concept invented to bully and intimidate people.
English
@Dude92274864733 I do not claim to teach with the magisterial authority of a bishop, but I think that my tweet pretty clearly lays the distinction out.
English
Especially after October 7th 2023, the Church is going to have to more finely lay out and explicate what constitutes "antisemitism", and what constitutes legitimate critiques of Judaism and Zionism.
Fr. Paul@BackwardsFeet
Let's be clear. Anti-Semitism, which is a hatred rooted in ethnic or religious reasons, is evil. However, disagreement with the political and military actions of the modern state of Israel is not that.
English
@amy_likes_owls You must have missed the second sentence of my tweet where I explicitly condemn that sort of thing.
English
@Cernovich @Pontifex >he doesn't know that Pope St. JPII helped bring down communism in Poland with the Solidarity party
Goodness, get a grip, man
English
All men and women, especially Christians, are called to fix their gaze on those who suffer, on the pain of the lonely, and on those who are emarginated for various reasons, for without them we cannot build a just society. Only together can we build communities of solidarity capable of caring for everyone, in which wellbeing and peace can flourish for the benefit of all. Caring for the humanity of others helps us to live our own lives to the full.
English
@JendersII There are, of course, people out there who do make their anti-semitism & their anti-zionism one & the same, and those who lean into conspiracies. Such things should be condemned. But the church also should be clear the modern state of Israel is not synonymous with being Jewish
English
@BackwardsFeet No, I meant by the bishop's statement, not you. Lol
Sorry for the confusion.
English
Of course, I agree, Father.
But the first part doesn't need to be said, because no Catholic apologist nor any members of the religious liberty commission were engaging in the hatred of Jews.
They were reciting Church teaching and condemning objective moral evils. Why attack us?
Fr. Paul@BackwardsFeet
Let's be clear. Anti-Semitism, which is a hatred rooted in ethnic or religious reasons, is evil. However, disagreement with the political and military actions of the modern state of Israel is not that.
English
@stet_dot_net No, there's nothing anti-semitic about disagreeing with Israeli foreign or domestic policy, and the implication that all people of Jewish ethnic or religious heritage are automatically interlinked with the politics of a nation-state they may not agree with at all is, in fact, bad
English
@BackwardsFeet And yet it’s fruit of the same poisoned tree. Don’t excuse it.
English