置顶推文
My channel was flagged as “reused content,” but the email I received said “inauthentic content.” This mismatch shows how unclear YouTube’s policies can be.
English
Rhythmic Strings
82 posts
Rhythmic Strings
@RhythStrings
Help me - my channel was wrongly demonetized by youtube, all piano tutorials are original, educational, and created from my own MIDI/FL Studio recordings.
加入时间 Ekim 2020
20 关注8 粉丝
This is what YouTube is doing to original creators right now: dismissing us without reviewing anything, relying entirely on AI and automated replies. Hard-working creators who provide full proof of originality are being ignored. Please stop hiding behind automation and give us real human review and transparency.
@TeamYouTube @YouTube @YouTubeCreators
Giulio Fulchignoni@GFulchignoni
Sadly, I’ve been demonetized by @YouTube for “mass-produced or repetitive content,” and I’m asking for a fair human review of my channel and my work: @giuliofulchignoni" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@giuliofulchig…
I’m not mass-producing content. I’m building original short films within an interconnected cinematic universe that I’ve spent years developing through storytelling, worldbuilding, and filmmaking. There are countless hours of work behind every project: scripting, directing, editing, sound design, music composition, pacing, frames composition, and narrative development. I also work with collaborators, including composers and sound designers, who create original pieces specifically for my films. I use AI only as a tool to create the visuals, which are still carefully directed, selected, and edited by me. The storytelling, creative vision, sound, music, structure, editing, atmosphere, and emotional intent are human-made. I even removed older Videos that may have been misunderstood as repetitive because I genuinely want to align with the platform and continue improving my craft. I’m simply asking for my work to be reviewed fairly as filmmaking and storytelling, not as spam or mass-produced content. Please @TeamYouTube don’t let automated systems destroy creative projects built with passion, collaboration, and countless hours of effort. If you could share this post will help me immensely, thank you ❤️ #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #fairreview #fixyoutube #shortfilms #ai #contentcreator English
This is exactly what I’m going through too. My channel was demonetized for ‘reused content’ even though every piano tutorial is fully original. I’ve already submitted proof of originality, but all I get are automated replies with no human review. Their entire system seems dependent on AI, treated as unquestionable truth that never changes.
It’s ironic how the AI built by humans is now the one controlling them.
Wavears@WavearOfficial
POV: You spent years building your channel… uploading videos, editing till 3AM, grinding every day… just to end up arguing with a smiling copy-paste machine that tells you: “Hi Creator 😊 wait 90 days.” @TeamYouTube #ypp #youtube #yt #inauthentic #demonitized
English
@TeamYouTube I am facing the same issue. My channel was demonetized for "reused content" even though every tutorial is fully original: I record MIDI, arrange in FL Studio, generate visuals in Synthesia, and edit in Premiere Pro/InShot. I have already submitted complete proof of my workflow and originality, yet all I have received are generic responses with no human review.
Please resolve this issue ASAP.
Creators deserve transparency and fair evaluation, not just automated responses.
torkandfrens@LofiSpot31818
@TeamYouTube @YouTube Hello. It's now been over 3 weeks since my channel @H.H.E-" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@H.H.E-
was demonetized for reused content. Keep in mind, all of my videos are created, edited, narrated by me without the use of Ai. Yet strangely, all i've been given from YouTube creator support are Ai responses, even telling me to use my own voice! An Ai, telling a human creator that already narrates his own videos, to use his own voice to create content that can be monetized. All with the same generic email template, that never specified why my channel that was originally admitted into the YPP without any issues, has suddenly been suspended from it. I've had HUNDREDS of people commenting, tagging team youtube on my posts here, but nothing has happened so far. I understand mistakes happen, but the fact that not a single human ever reviewed my channel is disappointing. @TeamYouTube I hope it can be resolved. English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
Hey @TeamYouTube I received a DM from you guys but still no update.
My whole team and me are stressed. It's been almost 2 months. Can you please help and solve this asap!
Please help @Nina7Infinity @RayDocsProd @MovieTalkNOW1 @T00NYBOY @sol_caramel
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
I feel like YouTube can’t even afford to provide support from a real human person. YouTube always talks about its policies, yet it doesn’t follow its own policies itself. I’m unable to get justice, and honestly, this feels cowardly.
@YouTube @TeamYouTube @nealmohan @YouTubeIndia
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
Seeing more and more creators speak out publicly like this really shows how widespread the frustration has become lately.
A lot of creators feel like the biggest issue isn’t even strict enforcement itself — it’s the lack of transparency, inconsistent decisions, and feeling that genuine channels can lose monetization or visibility without clear communication or proper context.
Whether people agree on every case or not, creators absolutely deserve clearer explanations and review processes that feel human instead of purely automated. @TeamYouTube
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
@TeamYouTube Wow, my channel is literally doing so well, but YouTube decided to falsely demonetize my 100% transformative content because their AI thought it was “reused.”
After days of struggling through YouTube Support, X, and email, I keep getting AI/generic responses instead of real help.
This is completely unbelievable. Creators are losing a lot of revenue because of mistakes like this.
I even asked for a proper human review, or at least for someone to tell me which video is not considered original, but I still haven’t received any clear explanation.
As an EU creator, I’m requesting transparency under the DSA. Simply repeating “reused content” without specific examples is not enough.
My original appeal was rejected even though no one watched the appeal video. I don’t know what to think anymore about YouTube. I just want a real human to review my case properly.
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
YOUTUBE just found a NEW WAY to LEGALLY take creators’ MONEY while still PROFITING off THEIRS videos 💀🔥
THIS 450K SUBSCRIBER channel, PyareDesh, got DEMONETIZED for “inauthentic content” despite making fully ORIGINAL videos 😭
NO repost spam,
NO repost spam
NO copied content!
The ONLY AI thing is the voice, which YouTube’s OWN monetization rules already allow 💀
Everything else is manually edited and takes HOURS
The CRAZIEST part about this whole situation,
YouTube says his content is “INAUTHENTIC” when it’s time to pay the creator
BUT suddenly the content becomes “AUTHENTIC” again when it’s time to put ADS on the videos and keep the revenue ☠️
So the videos are apparently:
“Not authentic enough to monetize”
Yet somehow:
“Authentic enough to profit from”
That logic genuinely makes ZERO sense 😭
and thats actually terrifying
Like what is youtube even about anymore?
It means ANY creator using narration, AI voiceovers, or edited commentary content could randomly lose monetization overnight
Today it’s PyareDesh
Tomorrow it could be HALF of YouTube 😭
IS THIS END OF YOUTUBE? @rumblevideo
@TeamYouTube a human NEEDS to SEE THIS
Channel link - @pyaredesh" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@pyaredesh
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
Years of uploads.
Thousands of hours.
Sleepless nights.
One dream.
And after all that?
A copy-paste reply telling creators to “wait 90 days.”
Small creators are not ticket numbers.
We are human beings who built our channels with real passion, time, and sacrifice.
How many more creators need to feel ignored before someone actually listens?
@TeamYouTube
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
This 5-second animation of a single character took me almost 40 minutes using my latest workflow…
and YouTube still calls my videos “mass-produced” and “inauthentic” 💀
That 40 minutes doesn’t even count the time I spent finding the right video idea, filming myself acting out, creating a scene….
Just to be clear: I’m a beginner animator who blew up on youtube faster than I imagined.
I’m still learning as I create.
You can literally watch my progress on the channel: from simple 2D keyframing to complex 3D rotoanimation. It takes me forever to make one video, so I only did 2-3 shorts per month on average.
Yet YouTube keeps saying it looks low-effort or mass-produced.
AND I am stuck in a loop of you saying I should continue the conversation with Creator Support, while I haven’t heard from them for 10 days…
@TeamYouTube I am not mass producing but putting in genuine human effort and learning to level up my content as I keep creating..
So Please, can my channel be reviewed by an actual human specialist? I know they must be super busy and there must already be a HUGE queue, but without an actual human review I'll be stuck in a support loop forever.
Channel link: @Superficial2" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@Superficial2
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
Useless robots making decisions while real creators suffer. Maybe it’s time to throw these broken automated reviews into the trash and let real humans review channels properly.
English
Rhythmic Strings@RhythStrings
It has been 37 days since my channel was demonetized, and there is still no clear explanation. @TeamYouTube As a creator, I have spent years making original content. Yet YouTube support keeps ignoring me as if I am nothing, even though I have provided every proof of originality, workflow PDFs, appeal videos, and learner comments. Chat support only gives template replies, not real solutions. This unfairness is making me lose trust. Please help with a fair human review. @YouTube @YouTubeCreators
QME
It has been 37 days since my channel was demonetized, and there is still no clear explanation.
@TeamYouTube
As a creator, I have spent years making original content. Yet YouTube support keeps ignoring me as if I am nothing, even though I have provided every proof of originality, workflow PDFs, appeal videos, and learner comments. Chat support only gives template replies, not real solutions. This unfairness is making me lose trust. Please help with a fair human review.
@YouTube @YouTubeCreators
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
Dear YouTube Team,
I am formally requesting a fair, transparent, and human review of my channel’s demonetization under the EU Digital Services Act (DSA), particularly Articles 14, 15, 17, and 20.
Over the past few days, I carefully reviewed my channel and could not identify any content that justifies this action. My videos are original, manually created, and require significant time, animation work, editing, scripting, and production effort.
Under Article 17, I respectfully request a clear explanation of:
• Which specific videos violated policy
• What exact elements were considered “inauthentic” or “mass-produced”
At this time, I have not received enough detail to properly understand the issue.
Under Article 20, I request a meaningful human review through YouTube’s internal complaint-handling process. My appeal video still shows 0 views, which raises concerns about whether it was actually reviewed by a person.
I also submitted raw animation files and screenshots to demonstrate the authenticity of my work.
Additionally, YouTube continues to monetize many channels in the same category and style as mine. I am simply asking for consistency, fairness, and transparency in enforcement.
@gravityuz/videos" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@gravityuz/vid…
@WorldData_3D" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@WorldData_3D
@c-ompare" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@c-ompare
@horizon3DC" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@horizon3DC
@Globe-Globe" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@Globe-Globe
@Zorion.1" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@Zorion.1
@nexus_english" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@nexus_english
@prismauz" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@prismauz
@globaldata1" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@globaldata1
@Nexostats_usa" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@Nexostats_usa
@Aesthetic_Data" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@Aesthetic_Data
@historytimelines4" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@historytimeli…
@WatchDataVerified" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@WatchDataVeri…
@DATAPOOL11226/videos" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@DATAPOOL11226…
@TopDeta/videos" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@TopDeta/videos
@BlackHeartDataGlobal" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@BlackHeartDat…
@RealDataComparison147" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@RealDataCompa…
@InfiniteComparison" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@InfiniteCompa…
@GlobalRanking" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@GlobalRanking
@TahersInfo" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@TahersInfo
@nerd_cassette" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@nerd_cassette
@caljucotcas" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@caljucotcas
@PastMorph" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@PastMorph
So why are different standards being applied to my channel?
My Channel: @RealData3D1" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@RealData3D1
I believe my content is high quality, original, and fully deserves a proper review.
“Justice delayed is justice denied.” — William E. Gladstone
@TeamYouTube @DigitalEU @EU_Commission
#inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #contentcreator #fairreview #3danimation #youtubepolicy
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
@TeamYouTube 102 DAYS of silence and frustration. 🚨
My channel ARAS TV has been unfairly demonetized for 102 days. I was just 50k away from 1 MILLION subscribers, but now my dreams are on hold. I have followed every single instruction, removed old content, and even got my secondary channel monetized, yet my main channel remains restricted.
I don’t want generic replies. I am pleading for a REAL MANUAL HUMAN REVIEW. Please, do not let my hard work and dreams fade away.
I miss creating content for my community.
Channel: @ArasTvMedia" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@ArasTvMedia
@TeamYouTube @YouTube @YouTubeCreators @YouTubeIndia @SusanWojcicki #YouTube #Monetization #ArasTV #JusticeForCreators #YouTubeSupport
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
@TeamYouTube please help me with a real human review. My channel is under a 90 day restriction and I can’t use links in description, or post more than 10 a day. I reached 2.8M views in 90 days and was only 200k views for 1st step monetization . Please help sort this out fairly
English
Rhythmic Strings 已转推
Because of being falsely demonetized for “inauthentic content” on April 6, my channel has literally dropped in subscribers, views, and overall engagement.
Even after removing hundreds of videos and checking every remaining video to make sure it follows YouTube’s TOS, my channel is now 100% authentic and follows every YouTube Partner Program policy.
Please, @TeamYouTube , take another look at my channel, as I truly believe it still deserves to provide videos to the audience with passion like i always did.
I’ve been losing thousands of subscribers since I got falsely demonetized..
My channel: @ililyslife?si=Vm0boWjJwA5v7Dei" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">youtube.com/@ililyslife?si…
English
@WavearOfficial I am experiencing the same issue! They keep ignoring me, and youtube support only provides templated replies instead of real solutions. Please help; my channel was wrongly demonetised, and I just want a fair human review.
x.com/i/status/20531…
Rhythmic Strings@RhythStrings
It has been 36 days since my channel was demonetized, and there is still no clear explanation. Support says: - They have no access to review details. - They cannot tell which videos are the issue. - Systems handle reviews. - Creators must "fix" the problem before reapplying. But how do you fix something when the problem is never identified? Creators aren't asking to bypass rules. We're asking for transparency, communication, and human clarity. Behind every channel is a real person who spent years building with passion. This deserves to be discussed openly. I want a fair human review like other creators are getting. My piano tutorials are original and made by me, and I should not be penalized by automated systems mislabeling them. @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators @YouTube @nealmohan #youtube #youtubeMonetization #creatorsupport
English
Another day, another copy-paste reply from YouTube support.
Different agent name.
Same generic response.
Same “wait 90 days.”
Same zero transparency.
Not a single explanation about:
what exact content is wrong
what exact policy was violated
what creators are supposed to actually fix
Years of work reduced to automated paragraphs.
At this point it genuinely feels like small creators are talking to a wall.
@TeamYouTube
English
@WavearOfficial I am experiencing the same issue! They keep ignoring me, and chat support only provides templated replies instead of real solutions. Please help; my channel was wrongly demonetised, and I just want a fair human review.
x.com/i/status/20531…
Rhythmic Strings@RhythStrings
It has been 36 days since my channel was demonetized, and there is still no clear explanation. Support says: - They have no access to review details. - They cannot tell which videos are the issue. - Systems handle reviews. - Creators must "fix" the problem before reapplying. But how do you fix something when the problem is never identified? Creators aren't asking to bypass rules. We're asking for transparency, communication, and human clarity. Behind every channel is a real person who spent years building with passion. This deserves to be discussed openly. I want a fair human review like other creators are getting. My piano tutorials are original and made by me, and I should not be penalized by automated systems mislabeling them. @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators @YouTube @nealmohan #youtube #youtubeMonetization #creatorsupport
English
IS THIS FIGHT EVEN WORTH IT ANYMORE?
😞Because honestly, it feels like YouTube doesn’t care unless a post gets big enough for people to notice.
119 days demonetized.
Appeal rejected.
Policy reason changed.
No exact video named.
No clear explanation.
Support says they can’t access review details.
And after all that, creators are still told: “fix your channel and reapply.”
Fix what? @TeamYouTube
I’m tired, but I’m not the only one. More creators are going through this quietly every day, and most don’t have enough reach to be heard.
If this system can affect anyone’s livelihood with vague answers, then creators need to speak louder together.
English