
Kyle Schwarber's HOF case is unique and fascinating.
We never really got to test the automatic nature of 500 non-PED homers opening the doors to Cooperstown for an otherwise one-dimensional player because Dave Kingman and Adam Dunn both fell short. But it's looking more and more like Schwarber won't.
Now, while some of You People™ regularly mention Schwarber and Kingman in the same breath, I think most folks with multiple brain cells can agree that Dunn and Schwarber are vastly superior hitters (not to mention more popular human beings) than Kingman. Their batting averages are all in the .230s, Kingman trails the other two by about 70 points of OPS, which is significant.
I continue to think that Dunn would have been the first player to truly test the automatic nature of 500 homers. He couldn't run, he couldn't field, he couldn't hit for average, and he was constantly in record-setting strikeout territory. And yet, it would be completely unprecedented to keep someone out of Cooperstown that hit 500 homers without the benefit of steroids.
Now here comes Schwarber, who has all of the same limitations as Dunn –– can't run, can't field, can't hit for average, strikes out 200 times a year –– but he feels different. He's wildly popular and a team leader in Philadelphia, and perhaps MOST importantly, he has the benefit of the Universal DH. He's still hitting bombs like it's his job (because it is) and he's the face of this generation of Phillies. His postseason slash line (.234/.361/.545, .907 OPS over 73 games) is consistent with his career production and intangibles further buoy his candidacy.
I think he reaches 500 homers.
And I think he gets his plaque.

Not Gaetti@notgaetti
Like it or not, Kyle Schwarber appears headed for Cooperstown. He's currently on pace to tie the single-season HR record of 73, and he's already tied the greatest player of all time (Gary Gaetti) on the career homers list. But in all seriousness, wowowow.
English










