@franzkaftah not really their fault their language loves ks apparently and the name structure was Comintern mandated I believe
English
Promit ☀️
605 posts
Promit ☀️
@promit_f
Free and unbound from the ideas of those who came before
Se unió Şubat 2025
179 Siguiendo50 Seguidores
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik You just fundamentally don’t understand what I’m saying which I mean fair enough you’re a polish maoist lol
English
@promit_f @Jacquieshevik it did. ur asking of independent trade unions. lenins point about relation to them stands.
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik why TF would I have heard of an polish anarcho syndicalist org with less than 4k members whose name I can’t even pronounce. And as far as I can tell, what growth they have is attributed to the fact that the general trade union movement died after solidarity 😭
English
@promit_f @Jacquieshevik your ignorance makes me bored, have u heard of Inicjatywa Pracownicza, established just a couple years ago? yea, now theyre putting out a presidantial candidate
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik HAHAHAHA no I don’t think there’s a thriving trade union movement, much less a german leftcom style political one, in poland. Name one.
I don’t have a “political orientation,”
English
@promit_f @Jacquieshevik multiple ones in the third world, like in Philipines, Kenya or even including poland, where i live. its v telling abt ur political orientation how dead-set u r on imp core
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik like with a few notable exceptions, if communists are creating trade unions, they probably will not be competing with “non-political” ones. It’s also just not something that happens even, can you name a political union that isn’t a hundred year old corpse propped up by larpers?
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik Lenin’s talk of trade unions is about how communists should not be creating new, explicitly communist trade unions. Nevermind the fact I brought it up, it doesn’t strike me as relevant considering just how dead trade unions as a whole are.
English
We are not doing this charade of pretending Jujutsu Kaisen is bad to compensate for our own lack of understand regarding its narrative, get a grip most of its complexity isn’t even hidden behind translations or Buddhism you’re just dense
Jason Klum@PokemanZ0N6
God I wish this show was actually well written because the production quality never fails to deliver
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik Larper posting “nobody does the reading” while it’s clear you haven’t 😭read it dude it’s hyper specific to inter-european communist debates of ~1920. These debates have been over for over a century, yes it’s largely irrelevant. Obviously it’s not completely useless but
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik The “dictatorship of leaders vs masses” stuff applies to many a modern communist tho, as well as generally the commitment to discipline and gaining experience, showcasing how other movements are wrong, and the trade union and parliament stuff more or less
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik I have, except the like epilogue notes bc I didn’t realize they had stuff in them. I don’t particularly want to go over the whole text with some random maoist, especially because the vast majority of it is largely irrelevant to 2026.
English
There are so many Lenin quotes like this. He was genuinely an enemy to the working class. He looked down on the proletariat as stupid and incompetent.
Under Lenin, bourgeois specialists were paid six times the wage of the average worker.
Insane Communist Quotes 🇵🇸🚩@commie_quotes
"We have many such Communists among us, and I would gladly swap dozens of them for one conscientious qualified bourgeois specialist." - Vlladimir Lenin, 1921
English
@AnarkYouTube @Kemloten Why does an anarchist of all people think socialism and the state can coexist
English
@Kemloten Socialism was established after the October Revolution. It was dismantled by the Bolsheviks
English
@marxistlogician @Jacquieshevik there are words in the text beyond the title. There are communists of every “tendency” that are guilty of what lenin criticizes in the book
English
@Jacquieshevik i know you didnt read it, so i might help by emphasizing that its about “left communists”.
also, arent u like 19?
English
@Neo_Brisk why is everybody going larp like that’s not obviously the joke
English
@Valeshevik As early bukharin, my wonderful goat, says, all modern capitalism is “state capitalism.” You actually reinforce ML concepts about those things when you make the distinction
Promit ☀️@promit_f
@AliceBright_ just say statist/capitalist etc. “State Capitalism” is just how capital functions, obviously a class society has a state to manage it. Making the distinction between ML “state capitalism” and “normal” capitalism washes over the fact that their societies follow the same logic.
English
Anarchism is when you don't think state capitalism is socialism
☭ 🇵🇸 🇷🇺 🇨🇳 🇰🇵 🇨🇺 🇳🇮 🇧🇫🔻@leoney_1
LeftComs are Anarchists who pretend to be Marxists
English
@pissvortex Ok then, name a Marxist who is currently engaged in meaningful struggle
English
@stolperson @GunterFehlinger it’s interesting that his anti-russianism had beaten out his otherwise incredibly shameless first worldism like you’d expect him to 100% believe the entente narrative
English
@GunterFehlinger It's seems a bit late to join this debate, no?
English
@olimarnocap @ExpiredGrap3 @HoeannaNewsom It’s a saying to verbally explain that you’re quoting something. With text, you can just ACTUALLY quote unquote
English
English
@trashbaby40k @lemmingstribes @purplewaves7 ukraine never would’ve been in nato before 2014, it’s not even clear if they’ll be let in once the war’s done over lol
English
@lemmingstribes @purplewaves7 not interested in an argument as i’ve seen how useless they are with your cohort but i’ll just say that i fundamentally disagree. if ukraine was in nato, russia would’ve never illegally annexed crimea or started de facto “proxy” war in donbas or full scale war in 2022.
English
It’s funny how “campism” doesn’t mean anything any more. What would supporting an international military bloc led by the United States be called? It’s literally one of the camps the term originally referred to
trash baby 🇺🇦🇪🇺🇹🇼@trashbaby40k
@mxllysworld @ZachTGR that should be considered a serious problem for anyone associating w/ DSA that doesn't hold those campist views. even if i was sympathetic to many of the other domestic policies (I'm not), campist trash like what's on their national platform page is disqualifying for many of us
English