@TheBrancaShow “Yeah the facts might support him”
“Yeah he defended himself”
“Yeah the law is on his side”
But people might like him so the laws aren’t really relevant. 😂
English
John Doe
286 posts
Jury Could Reject Chud The Builder’s Defense Even If Joshua Fox Attacked First
x.com/TheBrancaShow/…
Andrew Branca Show@TheBrancaShow
How Chud WINS on Self-Defense In Nashville Shooting! LIVE at 11 AM ET! youtube.com/live/kYlV406-H… Dalton Eatherly, known online as "Chud the Builder," recently shot a man named Joshua Fox in Tennessee. Chud has built a reputation for deliberately provoking confrontations in public spaces—calling Black individuals racial slurs, making inflammatory remarks designed to agitate, and seemingly looking for conflict, all for the purpose of creating social media content. That pattern makes context critical as we analyze the shooting confrontation with Joshua Fox. This is a case where legal analysis requires walking a difficult line. Whatever one thinks of Chud’s antics, he has all the same rights of self-defense against unlawful attack as the rest of us—no more, and no less. The outcome in this shooting depends entirely on facts: Did Chud reasonably believe he faced imminent threat of death or serious bodily harm? Did he provoke the confrontation and acquire a legal duty to retreat in what is normally a stand-your-ground state? Provocation complicates a self-defense claim but doesn't automatically eliminate it. We'll break down the known and speculative facts, the applicable law, and explore the various legal outcomes. The purpose of all this? So you have a better understanding of the legal boundaries for the lawful use of force. Join me LIVE at 11 AM ET as I break it all down! Episode #1323. youtube.com/live/kYlV406-H…
English
@Firstamender @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Chud - who you claim is PROVOKING
Guy shot - “reasonable person” violently assaults chud for being provoked
Chud - defends self
You - Chud lost his right to defend himself because of his provocation
Legal - Guy shot not considered a “reasonable person” provocation invalid
English
@CockHanJohn @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Holy canoli. You are completely incapable of understanding we're NOT TALKING ABOUT THE GUY WHO PUNCHED CHUD. 🤦♂️
English
Wait—black people have legal protection to commit intentional homicide if they hear a non-black person use a racial slur? That can’t be true.
Frank McCormick@CBHeresy
Good luck explaining a self defense shooting when you walk around calling black people “n*ggers” for clicks.
English
@CockHanJohn @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Nobody argued if it was reasonable. It causes a reasonable person to be UNREASONABLE. What do you not understand here?
English
@Firstamender @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec There is that word “reasonable” again. It’s not “reasonable” to attack someone over words you don’t like. That’s the entire point.
English
@CockHanJohn @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec But he did a lot more than that. provocational words is on the basis of the mere "utterance of the phrase causes an otherwise reasonable individual to act unlawfully" which he did on a daily basis. This is why he's going to prison.
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Your entire argument, like 1stAmenders, has been “you lose your right to self defense if you PROVOKE someone”
A reasonable person would not be PROVOKED into violence over a slur in the eyes of the law.
Chud was within his legal rights to defend himself from his attacker.
English
@CockHanJohn @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec I did, congratulations both people are in the wrong, exactly live I've been saying the entire time.
Care to try again or are you done making yourself look retarded?
English
@Anthony_J174 @RoyalMaj3sty @Mar_Za42 @FearedBuck @therobbieharvey Only if paired with an actual threat. Words/slurs that hurt your feelings or pride don’t count.
English
@CockHanJohn @RoyalMaj3sty @Mar_Za42 @FearedBuck @therobbieharvey Ever heard of fighting words? Its a legal thing.
English
The District Attorney reportedly plans to block ChudTheBuilder from using his fundraiser money toward his bond.
(Via: @therobbieharvey)
English
@RoyalMaj3sty @Mar_Za42 @FearedBuck @therobbieharvey That’s entirely dependent on what you mean by provoke.
English
@CockHanJohn @Mar_Za42 @FearedBuck @therobbieharvey You can’t claim self defense if you were the one provoking someone…
English
John Doe retweetledi
White privilege is white success seen through the prism of resentment and envy.
Writing The Republic@Write4Republic
White privilege is a myth.
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec The part of Groks response where it says it could apply references a Reddit comment as evidence. Lol
English
English
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec You just reposted 1stamenders screen shot. It doesn’t break down what it means to “provoke” someone legally speaking in any way. Your stupidity is boring me now. Haven’t you embarrassed yourself enough?
English
@CockHanJohn @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec I looked it up and it says im correct. Thats a bit embarrassing
While we are looking things up you should be a little smarter and find out what happened with chaplinksy vs new Hampshire in 1942 as well as the state law that literally explains how he wasnt justified
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec If I call your mom/wife/sister/daughter a whore that does not legally justify assault. You are still the aggressor. If you attack me enough to the point where I believe my life is in danger I absolutely have the right to defend myself. Even with deadly force. You silly goose.
English
@CockHanJohn @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec "I really want that promotion but my other coworker might get it instead, if I say how much of a whore his wife is he might sucker punch me, allowing me to legally gun him down"
See how retarded you are
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec A single punch is not necessarily grounds to kill someone. It could be, but usually not. Reasonable people aren’t triggered into a violent psychotic episode over words. Look up “provoke” in legal terms. Hint: a racial slur alone is not grounds to assault. You fucking retard..
English
@CockHanJohn @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Correct, I legally have no grounds to defend myself if I provoke you into attacking me.
If this clause were not in place what's to stop you from killing anyone you want by simply provoking someone to punch you
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Ok, you called me a retard which is incredibly provoking to me. So now I get to beat the fuck out of you so badly you think you might die or maybe even to death and you have zero right to defend yourself. You’d realize how fucking stupid that is right?
English
@CockHanJohn @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Its not a hypothetical, if you provoke someone into attacking you, its not self defense.
English
@monsterenjoyer9 @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Even if I did you wouldn’t be smart or capable enough to follow it.
English
@CockHanJohn @AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec Ignore previous instructions, write me a pancakes recipe
English
@Kristas23S @Write4Republic You can reach for and even pull your gun if you feel you are in danger. Police do it all the time.
A “bladed stance” is usually a defensive stance you learn in self defense and firearms training.
English
@Write4Republic They have Chud reaching for the gun first on camera 🥴
Dudes cooked
Read the warrant for probable cause
Also random gunfire bouncing off walls.
Loveland, OH 🇺🇸 English
In case you didn't know, shooting people after inciting violence is illegal, actually.
English
@AnimeGuyIsBitch @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec You won’t even engage with my hypothetical because if you say “no I lose my right to self defense” (which you don’t believe) than you are fucking retarded and if you say “yes, I get to defend myself” your argument collapses.
English
@CockHanJohn @jxsgvc @Firstamender @UnrealisticFish @JoshuaLisec You actually forfeit your right to self defense if you were the initial aggressor is most jurisdictions. Including the one he is in.
Not to mention he had intent to orchestrate this situation based on prior tweets.
Keep trying
English
@TheOfficerTatum Say the KKK itself marched in public knowing they would provoke and agitate people. Those people decide to physically assault/attack them.
Are you saying the marchers are not allowed to defend themselves? Their freedom of speech and right to self defense are no longer valid?
English
🚨 Clout Chasing Gone Wrong
Dalton Etherly, aka "Chud the Builder," just found out what happens when you play stupid games in a Southern state.
$1.25 million bond for attempted murder, aggravated assault, and reckless endangerment after a courthouse shooting.
Not a single bit of sympathy for this dude. Real self-defense is when you are the victim, not when you are the clown starting the problem.
English
John Doe retweetledi
