andrew corbett

31K posts

andrew corbett

andrew corbett

@CorbettAndy

Senior lecturer in Defence Studies at King’s College London. My views are my own, but I might retweet folk with whom I don’t agree.

Katılım Nisan 2018
861 Takip Edilen1.5K Takipçiler
andrew corbett
andrew corbett@CorbettAndy·
@paulallen262 @IBallantyn Ok, but what is air power for? TLAM is UKs longest range strike weapon. With an SSN why would you need air mobility or control of the air, which leaves ISR… that’s a lot of carrier to do recce…
English
0
0
0
8
andrew corbett
andrew corbett@CorbettAndy·
And here is the strategic value of an SSN; stealth. She could be there, then again she might be in the South China Sea. Just by sailing and not reappearing she poses multiple strategic dilemmas for adversaries, including land attack. I’d take SSNs over carriers any day…
Warships IFR@WarshipsIFR

UK SUBMARINE IN THEATRE OF WAR According to a report by the @DailyMail the @RoyalNavy Astute Class nuclear-powered attack submarine (SSN) HMS Anson, armed with Tomahawk Land Attack Missiles (TLAM), is now lurking somewhere in the Arabian Sea. Basing its claim on 'military sources' the report goes into some details on how the boat might operate. It is known, and as previously widely reported by this magazine and others, that Anson was in Australia and then departed some days ago, possibly for the Indian Ocean. Hence, HMS Anson was not involved in a naval review off Sydney this weekend, her previous mission of reinforcing the AUKUS alliance with Australia abandoned. It is surprising that more precise details of Anson's location and alleged arrival - tho' the Arabian Sea is still a big bit of sea to hide in - have been made public at all, via whatever route. The UK Ministry of Defence frequently won't even name submarines sailing into and out of HM Naval Base Clyde. It routinely uses the 'operational secrecy' response to obscure even bland details about Submarine Service operations. The Mail report also cites 'defence sources' but points out that the MoD 'declined to comment'. However, there is no avoiding the fact that a report of Anson in position somewhere off Iran, even if at some considerable distance - and the TLAM Block IV weapon has a substantial range, able to hit targets deep inside Iran if needs be - is major signalling of intent. No other European nation as yet has, as far as we know, committed a submarine to even defensive operations in the Arabian war zone. Meanwhile, UK jet fighters are in skies above the Gulf and other parts of the Middle East defending allied nations, also protecting Cyprus alongside Royal Navy helicopters on air picket and drone interceptor missions. The Daring Class (Type 45) air-defence destroyer HMS Dragon is heading east across the Mediterranean alongside the Royal Fleet Auxiliary landing ship RFA Lyme Bay while the fleet tanker RFA Tideforce called at Gibraltar recently. European navies have a substantial defensive naval presence in the eastern Med already - most notably the FS Charles de Gaulle Carrier Strike Group (CSG) of the French Navy - and there are European Union-tasked units in the Red Sea escorting shipping. The RN Type 45 destroyer HMS Diamond was in 2023/24 engaged in combat operations alongside the @USNavy (USN) in the Red Sea, and a RN frigate was also committed to operations for a period in the same danger zone. Given the once again proven ability of the nuclear-powered attack submarine to sink ships - the USN boat USS Charlotte sank an Iranian frigate off Sri Lanka earlier this month - and the likely heavy use of submarine-launched TLAMs against targets in Iran already, committing a SSN to the region is a significant step for Britain. The Anson has similar capabilities to American SSNs. With the UK Government restricting its forces to a defensive posture - only shooting down drones and such-like so far - HMS Anson is useful for intelligence-gathering, but above all , is a hunter-killer armed with not only TLAM but also heavyweight torpedoes. An interesting question raised by Anson's commitment to operations - and potentially combat ops from off Arabia - is whether or not she retains Australian submariners in her crew. Under AUKUS Royal Australian Navy (RAN) submariners are training in how to operate nuclear-powered submarines. They were reportedly aboard USS Charlotte when she attacked the Iranian frigate. It is no secret that RAN personnel have been included in HMS Anson's complement for some time. Are they still, bearing in mind the Australian government's non-committal stance on the Iran War? •For global naval news, analysis and commentary, including on the Iran War get our magazine, available in shops or direct hard copy sundialmedia.escosubs.co.uk/subscribe/wars… and also digital pocketmags.com/warships-inter… •For more on the submarines of the Royal Navy, plus other parts of the Fleet, check out our latest 'Guide to the Royal Navy' sundialmedia.escosubs.co.uk/store/products… Pictured: in late February HMS Anson prepares to enter the Australian submarine base HMAS Stirling, with Perth in the background. Photo: Royal Navy.

English
3
4
13
995
andrew corbett retweetledi
Ricky D Phillips - Military Historian
@Leonard73714140 Actually that's pretty much what did happen. The USA refused to be actively involved, gave satellite photos to Argentina, leaked the plans for the British recapture of South Georgia, and Kirkpatrick worked actively against the UK. And we recovered the Falklands.
English
11
33
767
12.5K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Alessio Patalano
Alessio Patalano@alessionaval·
Japan sounds alarm over UK delays to combat aircraft project - unsure whats new here. Japanese AND Italian frustration - both being a growing and known fact. Both countries ready to go with first contracts but UK is missing in action. ft.com/content/c3de1d…
English
2
8
16
1.3K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Jonathan Pie
Jonathan Pie@JonathanPieNews·
Does welfare include state pensions? I think it does you disingenuous tit. In fact unemployment benefits are roughly 1% of what we spend on state pensions. We can see what you're trying to do here. Wanker.
Matthew Elliott@matthew_elliott

The Government will collect £331bn in income tax this year, and spend £333bn on welfare. In other words, we now spend more on people not working than we raise from those who do. And the cost? Debt per person has risen from £11.5k in 2000 (inflation adjusted) to over £41k today.

English
255
496
2K
94.6K
andrew corbett retweetledi
WarTranslated
WarTranslated@wartranslated·
Zelensky says Russia has boosted oil sales in recent days after sanctions were eased, using the money to fund the war. He says Russia launched nearly 1,550 strike drones, over 1,260 guided bombs and two missiles at Ukraine in a week.
English
7
43
227
16.2K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Joe Cooprider
Joe Cooprider@joecooprider·
Reminder that Mueller indicted 26 Russians and 8 Americans for working together to interfere with the election. All 8 Americans were convicted in court, but 5 were pardoned by Trump.
English
125
5.2K
18.1K
253.4K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Glenn Tunes
Glenn Tunes@glenn_tunes·
AGREED 🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️🖐️
Glenn Tunes tweet media
English
61
1.1K
2.6K
15.7K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Glenn Tunes
Glenn Tunes@glenn_tunes·
RULES FOR THEE, NONE FOR ME🤷
Glenn Tunes tweet media
English
55
1.4K
2.7K
39.5K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Angry Staffer
Angry Staffer@Angry_Staffer·
- Iran won’t close the Strait because that would be very bad for them - we knew they would close it, I expected oil prices to be worse - the strait will open itself - we don’t use it, allies should open it - OPEN THE STRAIT RIGHT NOW OR WE’LL DESTROY YOUR POWER PLANTS
English
153
1.4K
8.9K
196.8K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Tim Robinson
Tim Robinson@RAeSTimR·
"this could leave the UK “tempted” to try to slow the timetable to make it more affordable in the short term." No-one learnt that slowing projects down INCREASES the overall cost (and leads to fewer a/c being produced). Whole point of GCAP was to avoid making this mistake!
Lucy Fisher@LOS_Fisher

EXC: Japan sounds alarm over UK commitment to the GCAP joint fighter jet programme w/ Italy Crucial development work is stalled due to UK MoD’s late Defence Investment Plan, repeatedly delayed since autumn Via @Urbandirt @harrydemps @sylviapfeifer & me as.ft.com/r/5d8beb2b-819…

English
7
26
206
18.6K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Steven De Smet 💬
Tien jaar na de Aanslagen in Brussel blijft één moment voor mij alles zeggen over waar we toen stonden en waar we vandaag nog altijd deels staan. Op de ochtend van de aanslagen werd ik niet via een officieel kanaal, niet via dispatching, niet via een gecoördineerde veiligheidsketen geïnformeerd over de aanslagen. Ik werd , door een voor mij 100% betrouwbare bron, verwittigd via sociale media. De eerste signalen, de eerste onrust, de eerste realiteit kwam digitaal binnen , rauw, ongefilterd en sneller dan eender welk officieel systeem kon volgen. Met die informatie ging ik onmiddellijk naar de hoogste veiligheidsverantwoordelijke in onze provincie. De reactie die ik daar kreeg, blijft nazinderen:“We hebben nog geen telefoon gekregen.” Die ene zin legt een structureel probleem bloot dat tien jaar later nog altijd relevant is. In 2016 botste een digitale realiteit frontaal op een analoge reflex. Terwijl informatie zich razendsnel verspreidde via netwerken buiten de klassieke hiërarchieën, wachtte ‘het systeem’ nog op een lineair signaal … een telefoon, een bevestiging, een protocol dat in werking trad. De wereld was al veranderd, maar de manier waarop we veiligheid organiseerden nog niet. Vandaag is er zonder twijfel vooruitgang. Er is meer samenwerking, betere informatie-uitwisseling, snellere operationele respons. Maar de essentie van die ervaring blijft confronterend actueel. Want ook nu nog zien we dat digitalisering te vaak wordt benaderd als een ondersteunend middel,  een tool om efficiënter te werken in plaats van als een fundamentele verschuiving in hoe dreigingen ontstaan, evolueren en zich manifesteren. De realiteit is dat dreigingen vandaag digitaal geboren worden. Radicalisering, coördinatie, desinformatie, netwerken: ze ontwikkelen zich in ecosystemen die zich niets aantrekken van territoriale grenzen of administratieve structuren. En toch blijven we veiligheid organiseren in silo’s, in versnipperde systemen, in procedures die wachten op bevestiging in plaats van anticiperen op signalen. Die ervaring van tien jaar geleden stelt vandaag een ongemakkelijke vraag … zijn we echt zoveel veranderd/verbeterd? Of zijn we nog altijd geneigd om te wachten op “de telefoon”, terwijl de wereld ons allang iets anders probeert te vertellen? De les van 22 maart is niet alleen dat we sneller moeten reageren. Het is dat we anders moeten leren kijken. Dat we moeten durven erkennen dat informatie vandaag niet meer netjes via officiële kanalen stroomt, maar chaotisch, gedecentraliseerd en vaak eerst zichtbaar wordt buiten het systeem. Wie veiligheid ernstig neemt, kan het zich niet permitteren om die realiteit te negeren. Tien jaar later zijn we beter voorbereid op wat we kennen. Maar de echte uitdaging blijft of we bereid zijn ons voor te bereiden op wat we nog niet (her)kennen  en of we deze keer wél zullen luisteren wanneer het signaal niet via de telefoon komt?  @BeSafeBEL @vvsg @CPL_Belgium @CPSvzw
Steven De Smet 💬 tweet media
Nederlands
3
11
53
1.6K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Gregg Carlstrom
Gregg Carlstrom@glcarlstrom·
We don't care about the Strait of Hormuz and we're going to wind down the war. Also if you don't reopen the strait, we will massively escalate the war Iran almost certainly will not blink on Hormuz. And needless to say, if Trump does this, Iran will respond by attacking similar targets in Gulf states Also needless to say, this would have profound, long-lasting impacts for millions of Iranians People are still trying to pretend there's some sophisticated plan here, there's not, there's an administration frantically trying to tweet its way through a war that has not gone at all the way it expected
The White House@WhiteHouse

🚨 “If Iran doesn’t FULLY OPEN, WITHOUT THREAT, the Strait of Hormuz, within 48 HOURS from this exact point in time, the United States of America will hit and obliterate their various POWER PLANTS, STARTING WITH THE BIGGEST ONE FIRST…” - President DONALD J. TRUMP

English
105
441
1.7K
203.6K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Chris - The Vibe-Based Systems Engineer™️
Hi! Missile Defense System expert here. There are two US missile defense systems in Romania and Poland coupled with an advanced radar system in Turkey. Additionally, there are forward based US destroyers in Spain. This is all meant to support the defense of Europe from a rogue nation ballistic missile attack. It’s also called Operation Atlantic Sentry. It is a U.S. European Command (USEUCOM) with a NATO mission primarily focused on Integrated Air and Missile Defense (IAMD). Its specific role involves the operation and integration of advanced radar and interceptor systems to protect the alliance from ballistic missile threats. Hope this helps @piersmorgan
Chris - The Vibe-Based Systems Engineer™️ tweet media
Piers Morgan@piersmorgan

So not only has Iran brazenly lied about its ballistic missile range capacity, but this means it can probably hit the UK with them - and we have zero, I repeat ZERO, defence against these missiles. Very worrying.

English
117
386
1.7K
220.3K
andrew corbett retweetledi
Audrey Ludwig MBE
Audrey Ludwig MBE@AudreySuffolk·
This is why many disabled people are rightly concerned about Assisted Dying. If AD is funded and available but a wheelchair ramp isn’t, what does that say about the attitudes towards disabled people?
Spin Decoders@leith1076

"Gauthier, who has been trying to get a wheelchair ramp installed at her home for the past five years, testified on Thursday that a caseworker told her that they could give her assisted dying, even offering to supply the MAID equipment for her." ctvnews.ca/politics/artic…

English
7
1.7K
7.2K
107.9K