@C2Cbsbl Ultimately it would depend on the return. My point is we have NO rotation outside of him. A proven Ace is more valuable than prospects
English
KWFF_TheFish
996 posts
@Kyitsui77 I think he could easily pull 2 T100 guys, that feels like way too much to pass up
The control and friendly contract make him a guy that even the small markets can go after, so everyone will be bidding
English
For those against trading Logan Webb, I’m interested in why you feel that way
From a strictly baseball perspective, because I understand fans love him, but that’s not a reason not to trade him
Not trying to argue, just curious
#SFGiants
English
@C2Cbsbl I'm all for it if there's a true "haul" but he's not gonna bring in what people are hoping for. If you wanna trade someone, ship off Devers
English
@Kyitsui77 My thing is that they probably aren’t competing in the next 2 years, but Webb could bring in a massive haul to stack the 2029ish timeline we have going right now
Also, is keeping people in the seats really an important perspective for fans to worry about?
English
@GarlicFryRy He swung harder than I've ever seen him on that 3-1. Hopefully he didn't tweak nothing. But you could tell he wanted to extend that hitting streak 😅
English
I hate that Arraez can’t take a walk. He had Ball 4 like 3 times and swung at all of them 😅
English
I'm also disappointed that the @SFGiants thought their mediocre/young bullpen guys were gonna take a leap, instead of signing some guys. But everyone needs to stop acting like spending $150M on Kyle Tucker, Framber Valdez, and Edwin Diaz would've made this team any better
English
@giantssfcentral Why do so many people have this horrible take? I get where you're coming from, but having a strong loyal fanbase is nothing but a good thing. They've made plenty of moves and spent plenty of money, They've just signed the wrong guys. Empty seats isn't gonna help that
English
This is why this team will never be good again. The #SFGiants fans of the 2010s would’ve never stood for this horrible joke of a team. That stadium would’ve been a ghost town by now.
95.7 The Game@957thegame
35K plus Giants fans (with some Cubs fans sprinkled in) signing, staying strong, hoping for a miracle.
English
@GarlicFryRy @leveon38 Vitello has been very bad so far. Luckily for him, the front office has been so bad, he's gotten a lot of apologists. But they haven't felt like a TEAM all year. And that's not even mentioning the bad lineups or bringing in guys at the worst times a ton
English
@leveon38 They are supposed to be united as a team but yesterday they felt different divided. They should have had a meeting as a team and talked about it so when they went on the field they were unified. It’s supposed to be 26 men playing together as one but yesterday it wasn’t.
English
This man is right lol half of our team is racist MAGA and the other are the Latinos they want gone
Could be a reason why they suck? Clubhouse vibes and lack of talent? I don’t know but you are right
Garlic Fry Ry@GarlicFryRy
I didn’t love the bible verses on the hats much either but most Major League Baseball players are from the south… what did @SFGiants fans expect? Also, sorry to break it to you but like 80% of the league are Republicans too 😅
English
@Jacobtheclipper Where was the yellow card on the 482 other times it happened?
English
@itstheredman @GarlicFryRy Also, agreeing with anything Grant Cohn says is a bad look 😅
English
@GarlicFryRy Hard disagree, man. From here, plays right, gives a shit, all grit, and fucking great - doesn’t get the shine he deserves and doesn’t cry about it. Guys like that benefit teams beyond the stats. Forever Giant and should retire a Giant.
English
@GiantHotTakes Finally some Devers shade. He's the worst hitter on the team, yet no one ever calls for him to move down the lineup or for him to get shipped out of town like Chapman, Adames, and Lee(until 2 weeks ago) he's an unproductive out nearly every AB
English
What’s the first thing you think of when you see Emilio Estevez?
English
@GarlicFryRy @ABartholomew_05 Why would you include 2016? 😅 they had a team 3.65 ERA and Bumgarner and Cueto were elite that year
English
@ABartholomew_05 Most entertaining Offense on a bad Giants team I agree. Watching the pitching is the least entertaining it’s worse than 2016-2018.
English
It’s definitely the most entertaining bad Giants team I’ve ever watched
Giant Hot Takes@GiantHotTakes
For being 13 games below .500 this is the happiest the fanbase has felt on an off day all year. The future is here, and while this will likely end up being a hugely disappointing season, the emergence of Bryce Eldridge has made it exciting. I can’t wait to see him play tomorrow.
English
@JoshReynolds24 Or Wemby coulda not bricked those 2 free throws. Why is no one bringing that up anywhere?
English
Josh Hart needs to send De'Aaron Fox the most expensive bottle of wine on planet earth…
If Fox pulls the ball out, eats some clock, gets fouled & hits freethrows, we all look back at this miss…
Now, not a single human will remember this in a week
English
@FattyBarrels Why is Buddy Kennedy on the team? Is the better question
English
Why take out Cox for Buddy Kennedy? That's the meanest thing you could do.
English
@GiantHotTakes Everyone is better than Devers. He has the lowest OPS on the team. Still don't get why he doesn't get bashed like Willy and Chapman
English
Bryce Eldridge may already be better than Rafael Devers.
English
@GarlicFryRy @SFGiants I am, and pretty tired of watching this guy pop up and strikeout every AB. Would prefer to have a solid young starter back in the rotation 🤷♂️ Devers has the lowest OPS in the lineup, but no one flames him like they do Adames and Chapman
English
Why did no @SFGiants fan bring anything up about Kyle Harrison’s start last night? What happened?? Did he go 6 or 7 shut out innings again??? How many K’s????
English
@grantcohn He's constantly criticized. He was trending yesterday 🙄 every one of your takes is atrocious
English
The Giants are so interesting because they were stuck in mediocrity and were sick of it, they hired Buster Posey to get them out of it, he made a bunch of big moves that backfired, they’re awful, it’s his fault and a lot of people are afraid or unwilling to criticize him.
English
@Eldridgeisking Devers is a literal automatic out, and they don't have a single reliable bullpen arm. It's pretty simple. That's not even mentioning Houser and Mahle being completely useless
English
The 2026 Giants Top 7:
1 Casey Schmitt: Breakout Star
2 Devers: Established elite hitter
3 Arraez: Best contact hitter in MLB
4 Adames: Established power hitter
5 Jung Hoo Lee: Breakout Star
6 Bryce Eldridge: Elite young bat
7 Chapman: Established hitter
HOW ARE THEY SO BAD???
English