Gautam Menon

19.8K posts

Gautam Menon banner
Gautam Menon

Gautam Menon

@MenonBioPhysics

Prof. Physics & Biology | Biophysics, epidemiology, sci-comm, climate change | Cats | Music | He/Him | Ashoka U | Lancet Comm| My views, not my employers

Katılım Eylül 2018
1.2K Takip Edilen14.5K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
Starting a thread with the music I like, an eclectic mix of Indian classical, world music, jazz + others. Later additions will come below [@PMenonIFPRI] Alison Brown Quartet's "Under the Five Wire" from Bluegrass Underground ... youtu.be/fUvLgx-3Rbc via @YouTube
YouTube video
YouTube
English
215
37
334
0
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
An exciting opportunity for potential postdocs: to study genome organization from a computational and ML/AI point of view at the new Brahmachari lab at UTMB. Modern cutting edge approaches will make a huge difference to the field. Details below.
Sumitabha Brahmachari@sumitabha590

📢 We're hiring! BrahmachariLab at UTMB studies the physics of genome organization by combining statistical physics, simulations, and AI/ML. 🔗brahmachari-lab.github.io/index.html 📌 Postdocs: biophysics, comp bio, or ML background welcome 📌 PhD students: via UTMB Graduate Programs

English
0
0
0
342
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Ramachandra Guha
Ramachandra Guha@Ram_Guha·
Back in 1998, the great playwright Girish Karnad wrote a brilliant essay on the arts and social change in India. Sadly, it was published in Holland so little read here. It is wonderful to see the essay now available online for desis and non-desis both: worldofgirishkarnad.substack.com/p/tell-it-agai…
English
12
127
508
63.2K
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
There's much here that makes sense. Above all, abandon senseless centralization to fulfil a political aim. This is a diverse, large country: one exam to rule them all may make sense in restricted contexts but should not be the norm.
Maheshwer Peri@maheshperi

Before we get into making a safe examination system, @NandanNilekani must examine the need for any entrance exam. Most exams are territorial power centres and business opportunities. Take for example CUET. It is the most unnecessary examination Imposed on the hapless Delhi students that made the CBSE scores useless and killed school education. This was done to neutralise the AAP investment in government schools a waste. These kids cannot afford private coaching and a state topper is also denied a seat. Similarly, NEET is useless for those who want to join a private medical college. The price differential (5 lacs and 1.5 crores) is so huge that at rank 30,000 all government colleges close their admission while even at rank 13 lac, private colleges are unable to fill seats. Private colleges are reserved for the rich 1% of India. If you indeed fighting against reservation and for meritocracy, shouldn’t you include this? The TET, even JEE advanced, UGC NET etc can be modified to make it a test for those who don’t cross a certain level of education. We must reduce the entrance exams. We must reduce the number of students who should take the exam. Increase the eligibility. For Ex: Make 80% in boards a qualification to get into all India institutions like AIIIMS, IITs etc. Make school education mandatory. Punish those in dummy schools. Hedge. De-risk. Spread. Make sure that a 3 hour exam doesn’t become the life altering exam. It will reduce stress. Reduce suicides. The business of entrance exams has to be reformed before we reform the conduct of such exams.

English
0
1
13
1.1K
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
Starting a thread with the music I like, an eclectic mix of Indian classical, world music, jazz + others. Later additions will come below [@PMenonIFPRI] Alison Brown Quartet's "Under the Five Wire" from Bluegrass Underground ... youtu.be/fUvLgx-3Rbc via @YouTube
YouTube video
YouTube
English
215
37
334
0
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Sarah Leah Whitson
Sarah Leah Whitson@sarahleah1·
The US government pressuring the newly installed Venezuelan government to withdraw from the ICC is a harbinger of what's to come; many other ICC member states will face US threats and bullying to withdraw, all with a singular goal: protecting Israeli criminals from accountability: state.gov/releases/offic…
English
25
260
377
9.7K
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Sarah Leah Whitson
Sarah Leah Whitson@sarahleah1·
An Israeli human rights organization is begging the international community to intervene and stop its own government's violence. It's not a position they've taken lightly. For many decades, @btselem advocated for the Israeli government to hold itself accountable, investigate, punish etc. They now recognize that it is beyond reform.
B'Tselem בצלם بتسيلم@btselem

Urgent call to the international community to take immediate action to stop Israel's violence and prevent pogroms by settler militias and the Israeli army across the West Bank. In recent days, violence by settler militias, enabled and supported by the Israeli army, has escalated across the West Bank, including the torching and destruction of Palestinian property, and the forced expulsion of families and communities. These attacks have been met with silence and inaction from much of the international community, allowing the violence to continue and intensify. Today's event in the village of Tell (Area B) when a settlers' "tour" in the village ended with the killing of at least 4 Palestinians and 1 settler and several people injured is leading to escalated violence in the area with settlers, ministers, and Knesset members calling for further revenge attacks which already started across the West Bank. Experience shows that these events can escalate quickly into mass pogroms when met with silence. We call the international community to act now. Immediate pressure must be placed on Israel to stop further attacks, prevent pogroms and further killings, and ensure the protection of Palestinians, in accordance with Israel's obligations under international law. Adalah; Akevot; Bimkom; Breaking the Silence; B’Tselem; Emek Shaveh; Gisha; HaMoked; Haqel; Human Rights Defenders Fund; Ir Amim; Leap; MachsomWatch; Parents Against Child Detention; Peace Now; Physicians for Human Rights Israel; Rabbis for Human Rights; UCPIP; Yesh Din; Zazim

English
21
699
1.1K
133.8K
Gautam Menon retweetledi
mustafa yazıcı
mustafa yazıcı@myzccc·
Gazze hastanelerinde gönüllü olarak görev yapan Japon hemşire, Japonya'ya döndükten sonra basın toplantısı yaptı: "Gazze halkı neyi yanlış yaptı? Hayatın ağırlığı herkese eşit değil mi? Bu dünya bir türlü adil olamadı. Bütün dünya onlara saldırıyor, birey olarak hiçbir hakları yok… Hem topraklarını işgal ediyorsunuz hem de onları öldürüyorsunuz. Belki bu sözler bile dünyaya ulaşmayacak, hatta görmezden gelinecek… Filistin halkı varoluş mücadelesi veriyor… Gazze halkının sesini dünyaya duyurmaya çalışacağım…”
Türkçe
739
32.6K
86.6K
3.2M
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Caitlin Johnstone
Basically we've got two choices: we either aggressively denormalize Israel or we watch our society become more and more Israeli. We either collectively reject Israel, or we watch western militaries fuse inseparably with the IDF. We either turn support for Israel into political campaign poison, or we watch politicians obliterate our right to criticize Israel while backing increasingly evil Israeli military agendas. We either ferociously oppose our government's involvement in middle eastern wars, or we watch Israeli leaders grow more and more ecstatic as more and more western blood and treasure flows into the war machine. We either normalize viewing Israel as a freakish abomination, or we sit passively watching authoritarian Zionist operations like Palantir get inseparably interwoven into every level of western power institutions. We either stand together to oppose Israel for the racist apartheid state that it is, or we watch our Muslim neighbors suffer increasing discrimination and abuse at home while our governments help massacre our Muslim brothers and sisters using high-tech war machinery abroad. The west's growing collective rejection of Israel is the growth of the western conscience. The burgeoning pro-Palestine movement. The disgust with the Iran war. Young people's cultural cringe around all things Israeli. The increasingly unapologetic eye-rolling every time "antisemitism" is used as an excuse to shut down criticism of Israel. These are signs that we are growing morally healthier. That's a good thing. The more we unite around a red hot "NO" to Israel and Zionism, the harder it will be for those in power to normalize the increasing Israelification of our society.
English
278
2.4K
6.5K
94.8K
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
An important question. Our examination systems and public institutions have no flexibility to identify clearly off-scale candidates who specialize in one area, if they can't cross an exam barrier which demands more (although only in a restricted sense) broad-based exam skills.
Suresh Govindarajan DLM@modularform

Can we replicate this in India? As @peeleraja likes to say, "Can these two get into CS at IITB?" That, as we know, is considered the pinnacle of achievement.

English
2
0
20
2.2K
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
@cspramesh I emphasize the need for south-south collaboration in global health every chance I get.
English
0
0
1
114
Pramesh CS
Pramesh CS@cspramesh·
If only we could look beyond the US and Europe! South-south collaboration is such a missed opportunity...
Pramesh CS tweet media
English
1
0
10
1.5K
Gautam Menon
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·
I'm beginning to feel the same, although I'm hardly the power user @curiouswavefn is. This is transforming the work of almost every scientist.
Ash Jogalekar@curiouswavefn

I came to the present AI revolution not as a credulous enthusiast, but as someone deeply skeptical of new technologies in science. For twenty-five years I have seen too many of them arrive surrounded by extravagant claims before settling into a useful but much more modest place in the scientific toolkit. What has astonished me is that the latest agentic systems appear to represent a qualitative change. I have now run upward of two hundred scenarios and AI for science workflows, each one navigating a complex, multistep scientific protocol across diverse fields of chemistry, biology and materials science, and I think I have enough data now to make a credible judgment. Over just a few months I have seen these models and algorithms leapfrog over increasing levels of difficulty, starting almost as a toddler and turning into an adult interlocutor. Every day, something moves my baseline for what they can do. They autonomously install, run, and debug dozens of computational tools; clean and structure data; parameterize molecules; launch calculations; and manage complicated, multistage investigations. But as it turned out, that was just the beginning. More fascinatingly, they increasingly display recognizable scientific judgment: proposing positive and negative controls, discovering that a method does not work, generating competing hypotheses, systematically eliminating them, changing direction when evidence contradicts an initially promising idea, searching an entire target space, constructing unexpectedly sophisticated models, and finding useful analogies across distant fields. This is no longer merely workflow automation or doing the same science faster. It is beginning to feel like genuine intellectual and creative collaboration. Interacting with the system can resemble a conversation with a smart and experienced student or colleague: ideas are proposed, challenged, refined, rejected, and unexpectedly pushed in new directions, with both the human and the AI acknowledging mistakes and adjusting course. The exhilarating possibility is the sheer multiplication of intellectual labor - the ability to explore almost any question under the scientific sun and to see those “mountains beyond mountains", as Tracy Kidder eloquently put it. In a week a scientist or a team can come up with dozens or hundreds of ideas and hypotheses, most of them reasonable and actionable. The physical lab is now the only bottleneck, and even that is being accelerated by AI. As a scientist, AI has made me feel more intellectually alive and excited than I have felt since graduate school and my postdoctoral years more than two decades ago. I can begin with an idea in the morning and, by lunchtime, watch a rational, testable hypothesis take shape; within days, an investigation can progress from literature and classical calculations to increasingly rigorous quantum-mechanical analysis and experimentally actionable predictions. Eating and sleeping have often taken a backseat, exercise seems like a distant goal, and every night I feel like I did when I was a kid and begging my dad or mom for just *one more story*. Except that this time it's just *one more prompt*. One more cycle of compute. One more result that will startle or confound. Every night I have to force myself to detach from the computer, and on more than one occasion I have fallen asleep at my desk, only to wake up and see the potential for yet *one more prompt*. Precisely because these systems are beginning to criticize our assumptions, tell us when something does not work, and think alongside us rather than merely obey us, it feels as though we may already have passed beyond the first age of AI. Of course, these predictions and results will stand or fall based on experimental testing, that's how science always has been, but that's no different from the pre-AI age. More importantly, in almost every case they appear as conclusions that any good scientist will regard as reasonable, at least as starting points. And sometimes they genuinely throw up a surprise. AI-enabled science should still be judged by the novelty, rigor, reproducibility, statistical validation, and epistemic integrity of the science, not by the novelty of the technology. But there is no doubt now that a Rubicon has been crossed, and either we cross over to the other side or get left behind. What a time to be alive.

English
0
1
5
651
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Pratap Bhanu Mehta
Pratap Bhanu Mehta@pbmehta·
From 2024: On elections and exams "So a collapse in trust in the exam system is tantamount to a collapse in trust in the system as a whole. Imagine a day where trust in the UPSC exam collapses. More than a revolution, that might make the Indian state collapse."
Pratap Bhanu Mehta tweet media
English
93
187
653
140.3K
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Praveen Swami
Praveen Swami@praveenswami·
A senior official said this: “Composed as the crowd was of the scum of Delhi city, I am of firm opinion that if they had got a bit more firing given them it would have done them a world of good and their attitude would be much more amenable and respectful.”
English
6
27
114
21.7K
Gautam Menon retweetledi
Rohini Singh
Rohini Singh@rohini_sgh·
I am amazed, but not surprised, by the shamelessness of Noida channels. For more than a decade they have turned TV studios into factories of lynch mobs- peddling ‘thook jihad’, ‘choodi jihad’, ‘land jihad’ and every other manufactured bogey to target ordinary citizens. Farmers were branded Khalistanis, anti CAA protestors Pakistanis, opposition supporters anti-national, independent journalists the ‘tukde tukde gang’. Anyone demanding accountability from the government was vilified, hounded and intimidated. Instead of introspection, accountability or course correction, they are outraged that people aren’t welcoming them with flower petals while they continue to demonise and dehumanise the very citizens they are covering. Any form of physical violence is unacceptable. But long before fists were raised on the streets violence was normalised in Noida’s TV studios- through hate, propaganda and the systematic dehumanisation of fellow citizen
English
56
397
1.6K
74.4K
Gautam Menon retweetledi
ُ sushi ibushi 𖣂
you see this red splotch covering Gaza? it is made of red dots, each single dot represents an airstrike under the Biden’s administration. it took two years of tremendous relentless unforgiving bombing and 4 US vetos to complete. you can’t regret your way out of this.
ُ sushi ibushi 𖣂 tweet media
The New Yorker@NewYorker

Top officials from the Biden Administration now express regret over their failure to rein in Netanyahu. newyorker.com/magazine/2026/…

English
213
11.9K
37.6K
563.1K