Arch Stanton

4.6K posts

Arch Stanton banner
Arch Stanton

Arch Stanton

@Mrchi21

Old enough to know better. Young enough to keep doing it. Toxic male. Formerly proud Canadian. Pronouns: go/fukurhat

Republic of Alberta Katılım Ağustos 2015
852 Takip Edilen169 Takipçiler
Free 'Berta
Free 'Berta@Free_Berta·
I told you conservatives outside of Alberta would eventually turn hostile once they realize Alberta is escaping without them.
Billboard Chris 🌎@BillboardChris

For everyone who thinks Alberta can simply vote to leave Canada and take the oil with them, it doesn’t work like that. A referendum does not automatically achieve independence. Under Canadian constitutional law, informed by the Supreme Court of Canada’s 1998 Reference re Secession of Quebec and the federal Clarity Act (2000): • Unilateral secession is illegal. Alberta cannot simply declare independence. • A “clear question” (the proposed wording aims to meet this) and a “clear majority” (not precisely defined, but the House of Commons would assess factors like the size of the yes vote, turnout, and overall circumstances) would create a reciprocal obligation for the federal government, other provinces, and relevant parties (including Indigenous nations) to negotiate in good faith on potential constitutional changes to allow secession. • Negotiations would cover complex issues: division of national debt, borders, currency, trade agreements, military/NORAD/NATO membership, pensions (CPP/OAS), equalization, Indigenous treaty rights (Treaties 6, 7, 8 cover much of Alberta), environmental obligations, and more. These would require a constitutional amendment approved under Canada’s amending formula (typically involving Parliament and at least seven provinces representing 50% of the population). • First Nations groups have launched court challenges arguing that the petition and referendum process violates treaty rights and the duty to consult, potentially delaying or blocking certification of signatures. In short, even a strong yes vote would start a long, uncertain, multilateral negotiation process—not an immediate exit. Failure to reach agreement could leave the status quo or lead to prolonged uncertainty.

English
53
63
467
10.8K
Muskoka Bob
Muskoka Bob@mcisaac_bob·
@Grimerica @Martyupnorth Perhaps Alberta first Nations should explore lawsuits regarding unceded federal lands, because with what is happening now I’m sure the federal government will side with First Nations and tie this matter in court for years
English
1
0
0
3
Martyupnorth®- Unacceptable Fact Checker
"...Alberta can simply vote to leave Canada and take the oil with them...." That's all you need to read. The rest is just nonsense and incorrect.
Billboard Chris 🌎@BillboardChris

For everyone who thinks Alberta can simply vote to leave Canada and take the oil with them, it doesn’t work like that. A referendum does not automatically achieve independence. Under Canadian constitutional law, informed by the Supreme Court of Canada’s 1998 Reference re Secession of Quebec and the federal Clarity Act (2000): • Unilateral secession is illegal. Alberta cannot simply declare independence. • A “clear question” (the proposed wording aims to meet this) and a “clear majority” (not precisely defined, but the House of Commons would assess factors like the size of the yes vote, turnout, and overall circumstances) would create a reciprocal obligation for the federal government, other provinces, and relevant parties (including Indigenous nations) to negotiate in good faith on potential constitutional changes to allow secession. • Negotiations would cover complex issues: division of national debt, borders, currency, trade agreements, military/NORAD/NATO membership, pensions (CPP/OAS), equalization, Indigenous treaty rights (Treaties 6, 7, 8 cover much of Alberta), environmental obligations, and more. These would require a constitutional amendment approved under Canada’s amending formula (typically involving Parliament and at least seven provinces representing 50% of the population). • First Nations groups have launched court challenges arguing that the petition and referendum process violates treaty rights and the duty to consult, potentially delaying or blocking certification of signatures. In short, even a strong yes vote would start a long, uncertain, multilateral negotiation process—not an immediate exit. Failure to reach agreement could leave the status quo or lead to prolonged uncertainty.

English
55
86
588
10.9K
Duane Bratt🇨🇦
Duane Bratt🇨🇦@DuaneBratt·
You want to increase support for Alberta separatism? Have a judge tell them that they cannot even consider doing it! 3/3
English
55
58
485
16.6K
Duane Bratt🇨🇦
Duane Bratt🇨🇦@DuaneBratt·
I am not a separatist. Nor am I a lawyer. But it seems to me that requiring a Duty to Consult before a successful referendum seems premature. Treaty rights would matter in any negotiations, but it is still hypothetical at this point. 1/3
English
58
28
268
38.8K
Captain Canadian
Captain Canadian@furmsies·
@k_kfrock Being Canadian is all the reason almoat all of us need. Greatest country in the world. Im sorry our happiness make you so angry.
English
29
0
27
966
Captain Canadian
Captain Canadian@furmsies·
A question for Alberta separatists: Do you actually believe that an independent Alberta would not charge you any taxes? If so, just thought you should know that your stupidity is showing.
English
200
67
449
10.3K
Jacques Cloutier
Jacques Cloutier@saturn92526·
@RickBellwrites Nenshi is not the person to lead the opposition… Get someone that the average folk can relate to and move the party more towards the centre and it’ll work…
English
1
0
2
51
BertaProudDad
BertaProudDad@BertaProudDad·
🚨 Judge just BLOCKED Elections Alberta from counting signatures. Less than 1% trying to silence us with the courts. This is tyranny of the minority — NOT democracy. We’re not defeated. Keep signing before May 2. Independent count incoming to the Premier. The harder they push, the louder we fight. Still in? Drop a 🔥 Alberta! #AlbertaIndependence #FreeAlberta #AlbertaStrong #IAmAlberta #StayFreeAlberta
English
211
554
1.8K
27.1K
Jeffrey Rath
Jeffrey Rath@JeffreyRWRath·
STAYFREE ALBERTA NOTICE! OFFICIAL THE RECENT COURT RULING DOES NOT AFFECT ALBERTA INDEPENDENCE SIGNATURE COLLECTION! PLEASE KEEP WORKING LIKE THE FUTURE OF YOUR CHILDREN IS AT RISK BECAUSE IT IS! SFA HAS CONTINGENCY PLANS TO ENSURE THAT YOU SIGNATURES WILL BE COUNTED AND YOUR VOICE WILL BE HEARD. FEEL FREE TO BE ANGRY BUT BE RESPECTFUL. IF YOU WANT TO SHOW YOUR CONCERN WITH A CANADIAN COURT INTERFERING WITH YOUR RIGHT TO HAVE YOUR VOICE HEARD COME OUT AND SIGN THE PETITION IF YOU HAVEN’T DONE SO YET! ALBERTA FREEDOM WILL PREVAIL! Please share this message.
English
124
1.3K
3.7K
43.9K
Arch Stanton
Arch Stanton@Mrchi21·
@The_Best_Take @Tablesalt13 You don’t have a clue either. Or a vote. I’d tell you to look up equalization but you’d probably get that wrong too. Have fun hooking up with China and the EU.
English
1
0
0
10
Tablesalt 🇨🇦🇺🇸
Floor crossing is going to be spark that gets Alberta over the 50% mark to leave Canada it will flip 5-10% of undecideds and make them realize this country is not salvageable.
English
180
571
4.1K
31.3K
SueConal
SueConal@sunn_time·
@ThomasHall17 @CMDoze Do these separatist hillbilly buffoons realize that GoC/CDNS(not them/not AB)own 5 National Parks in AB,indigenous owns land/mineral/resource rights. So hands off Banff,Jasper,Wood Buffalo,Elk Island,Watertown Lakes & all natural resources, pipelines,airports!No CPP/CN Passports!
GIF
English
1
3
16
617
B. Thomas Hall
B. Thomas Hall@ThomasHall17·
Alberta separatists appear to think that all they have to do is adopt a resolution in a referendum to separate. Referendum yield a yes vote, and it's a done deal. Not true. Little known legal/constitutional fact: the monarchy, through the office of the provincial lieutenant /2
English
28
49
227
21.5K
Elke Babiuk
Elke Babiuk@ElkeBabiuk·
@ThomasHall17 @Frazzling What separatists also don't acknowledge is how much of Canada's debt Alberta would be saddled with if they left.
English
1
3
30
1.7K
Arch Stanton
Arch Stanton@Mrchi21·
@The_Best_Take @Tablesalt13 Terry, you watch too much CBC, but it doesn’t matter. You don’t get a vote on October 19th. We’re gone and there’s nothing you can do about it.
English
1
0
0
9
Terry
Terry@The_Best_Take·
@Mrchi21 @Tablesalt13 Explain how you are the "piggybank"? The private/foreign companies give you a cut for doing literally all the work in oil. You need workers from other provinces and territories to do around a third of the labour...
English
1
0
0
11
Terry
Terry@The_Best_Take·
@Mrchi21 @Tablesalt13 I am a northerner and you are 100% reliant on Canada, you will be screwed if you became your own "country", that is a legitimate fact.
English
1
0
0
10