@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 “Is the extent of your argument” And I just told you what that meant. “It is about as good of an argument as you can provide” learn to fucking read.
English
Waldreg the Papist
5.3K posts
Waldreg the Papist
@Real_mnelson
Catholic. Waldreg. Tolkien Fan. Middle Earth Adaptation Fan. If you block me, you lost.
Katılım Temmuz 2024
175 Takip Edilen97 Takipçiler
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Just incredible gymnastics from you, have some shame, pack it in 👍🏻
English
This would certainly be a MASSIVE development if it happens. Personally, I’d love to see tales from The Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, etc not only get cinematic treatment, but video games and other media as well!
Fellowship of Fans 🐎@FellowshipFans
🚨BREAKING: Peter Jackson reveals that him and his team are negotiating with the Estate to license more rights from Tolkien’s works. “Combination of Warner’s and us have been talking to the younger Tolkien members about the possibility of actually licensing some of the rights to the other books”.
English
English
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 You fucking told me my argument was centred around ‘But black elf bad’ 🤦🏻♂️ and then when I point out the actual flaws you respond with ‘I didn’t say the show was lore accurate…’ the equivalent of running away with your tail between your legs.
English
@Willyjakblak @PMitzfatrick @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 She’s not the right hand of Gil Galad in the show. Elrond is.
English
@Real_mnelson @PMitzfatrick @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 You’re splitting hairs on Galadriel. Those few sentences Tolkein wrote about her in unfinished tales does not translate to commander of the northern armies. Right hand of Gil galad… that’s elronds position.
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 What about it? When did I say it was a good show, or lore accurate?
English
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Except for one small issue there… the rings of power is the 2nd age 🤦🏻♂️🤣🤣🤣 wow
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 I’m not the one who contradicts myself.
English
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Hobbits appear first in Arnor. Galadriel was described as an athlete and compared to the amazons, and Gandalf appears in the 3rd age on a ship, where he receives Narya from Cirdan. Anything else?
English
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Yeh you don’t understand any of the source material do you? 😂 can you tell me where ‘Hobbits’ oh sorry ‘Harfoots’ 🤣 appear? Maybe you can tell me where Galadriel is a fearsome warrior? Or perhaps when Celebrimbor hadn’t a clue what an alloy was? Or perhaps where Gandalf appears
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 I’m probably more critical of the show than you. You wouldn’t have a problem if my profile was Alfred. What I pointed out, is that you contradicted yourself, by going back one tweet later.
English
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 And my point of defending a show that directly contradicts everything Tolkien put into story and and descriptions of his characters and how they behave is indefensible. I’m sure you want it to be, your fucking profile has Waldreg 😂 remember he started Mount doom via switch? 🤣🤣
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 No, “extent of your argument” means that’s about the level of arguing against the show I imagine you could provide.
English
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 You just said ‘Black elf’ is the extent of my argument 😂😂😂 tell me how it contradicted my point…
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Never said you did. You said this- “Anyone who disagrees is either a shill, or they didn’t like Tolkien or his messages/characters in the first place.” Then immediately after contradicted it.
English
@Real_mnelson @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Let me know how it contradicts it when I said absolutely nothing about the race of an elf 😀 look forward to your detailed response.
English
Waldreg the Papist retweetledi
@nonregemesse @exanxc You’re a heretical Protestant. Kinda invalidates anything from you.
English
@exanxc You are not speaking without bias. You have a Vatican flag in your bio and you have an ai knight as your profile pic and you rant about Jews infiltrating the church.
Your source analysis is non-existent. You simply don’t want a negative story about a pope to be true.
English
There was a Pope who died after being thrown out of a window by a man who walked on the Pope sleeping with his wife
Ramin Nasibov@RaminNasibov
What historical fact sounds fake but is true?
English
@Ben35Dnny76257 @DontTreadUpon @liberty_lyss @MrBang21 @Paraplane100 @_LeadPoisoning_ @grok You made the point of “damaging God’s design”.
English
@Real_mnelson @DontTreadUpon @liberty_lyss @MrBang21 @Paraplane100 @_LeadPoisoning_ @grok The entire conversation has been about infant circumcision stay on topic
We don't tattoo babies so don't put those two in the same conversation
English
For anyone wondering, cutting off 50% of a newborn infant’s penile skin does, in fact make his penis smaller.
By design, it causes the penis to be shorter as well.
Your baby is perfect. Don’t cut him so some doctor can profit and some celebrity can use his skin in a face cream.
Steven The Heathen@StevenHeathen
@liberty_lyss @johnsonstickk @LindberghsGhost We already went through this too but I know what you're doing. You're fucking jobless so you're just trying to keep the interaction going. Enjoy your $10 paycheck from X. I lost all respect when you incorrectly said circumcised are smaller which is also not true 😂
English
@Jasminedragnfx2 @ezikagorlalt @DontTreadUpon @MrBang21 @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @liberty_lyss @grok It was a surgery gone wrong. And a mistake on their part, that they should be entirely liable for.
English
@Real_mnelson @ezikagorlalt @DontTreadUpon @MrBang21 @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @liberty_lyss @grok Well. I guess you dont have a reply to that? You dont seem to have better words for it. So it will remain rape, mutilation, and sexual assault
English
@PMitzfatrick @Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 This completely contradicts what you just said idiot. “Reings oF powah bad becase blak elf” is the extent of your argument.
English
@Willyjakblak @PloddingPilgrim @nerdoftherings1 Absolutely! People can enjoy what they like, as long as they don’t pretend it’s anywhere near good enough 😂 the Star Wars prequels I like as well, terrible movies, and that’s ok.
English
@sgtkwol @MrBang21 @Joseph4GI @DontTreadUpon @BanTheSnip @adkisojk @liberty_lyss @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @grok I think I should be honest though, a lot of the arguments on the damage, in my opinion, are blown out of proportion. Some definitely are present.
English
@sgtkwol @MrBang21 @Joseph4GI @DontTreadUpon @BanTheSnip @adkisojk @liberty_lyss @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @grok I understand that, and I think I agree for the most part. Where we differ, is simply that, I think, rather than a specific movement on this, it should be an all encompassing movement. I see a lot of people who cry for the right to abortion, turn, and advocate against this.
English
@foreskinsight @liberty_lyss @MrBang21 @Paraplane100 @DontTreadUpon @_LeadPoisoning_ @grok One of who?
English
@Real_mnelson @liberty_lyss @MrBang21 @Paraplane100 @DontTreadUpon @_LeadPoisoning_ @grok This is disgusting. You should feel ashamed of yourself. Downplaying forced infant genital mutilation. You are waving it away like it is nothing. Do you talk about female circumcision this way? I don’t believe you to be real. I have my suspicions you are one of them.
English
@sgtkwol @MrBang21 @Joseph4GI @DontTreadUpon @BanTheSnip @adkisojk @liberty_lyss @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @grok Not necessarily with you. I’ve been discussing this with 7 or so different people, half of them are throwing out redundant, straw man arguments. But none of them have gotten anywhere. I don’t see why to keep the conversation going, if we’re in the same spot as yesterday.
English
@Real_mnelson @MrBang21 @Joseph4GI @DontTreadUpon @BanTheSnip @adkisojk @liberty_lyss @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @grok I don't recall any argument. A discussion and solicitation of feedback, sure.
English
@sgtkwol @MrBang21 @Joseph4GI @DontTreadUpon @BanTheSnip @adkisojk @liberty_lyss @_LeadPoisoning_ @Paraplane100 @grok I don’t know. Advocate for other issues with it, combine them, a bodily autonomy movement. Against trans, against circumcision, against abortion. I’m not going to continue arguing with you after this.
English