@HockeyThinkTank Toph - you have lots of good takes but I disagree on this one. If you listen to even the first five mins, you will hear him deflect from players and take a lot on himself. He also is stating a fact - anybody afraid of that is afraid of accountability.
@ZmanMagnolia@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ Please 30 goal scoring winger for almost no cap hit. That's easily on the Kahdri Schenn tier but continue living in denial. No sweat off my back.
Enjoy the first round exit
Penguins are a good example of what not to do. They built around an aging core to generate a playoff birth with no real chance to win
Tear it down and rebuild properly
Flyers top 6 point scorers all age 30 and under. Penguins top 6 all age 31 and older.
Drastic difference
@ZmanMagnolia@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ You trade Mantha when you know he's leaving and you'll lose him for nothing. I'm sure this first round exit is well worth not getting something like Kahdri or Schenns (1st, prospect, +)
When Mantha leaves for whichever team offers him a boatload you'll likely change your tune
@TheChancellorVC@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ If you want to say it sucks they started winning and it forced the GM to do nothing then so be it.
But Dubas has done nothing wrong and he played his hand exactly like he should have.
@ZmanMagnolia@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ And you aren't trading them just for picks, but also prospects. Manthas cheap cap hit wouldve gotten a ransom at the deadline.
Dubas is all over the board, getting Karlson in 2024 says going for it, getting picks last year says rebuild. Then is stagnant this year.
@ZmanMagnolia@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ Spoken like a true fan thinking of only the now. Gms gotta be big picture. Mantha and Karlson cannot help you win a championship, you sacrifice the current season to set yourself up for a better future. Particularly Mantha, there's no clause to waive and you know he's leaving
@Jayesskayeye@ProducerDrew_ I should have been more clear
Holland sold the future to extend the playoff streak. Pittsburgh isn't doing that but they also aren't selling to get a rebuild more firmly going. Prime example is Mantha should have been traded, he could have gotten quite the haul at the deadline
@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ What “future” did they sell lol? The picks for Chinakov and Soderblom? Who have only increased their value since coming over?
@PaulHouse12@ProducerDrew_ I should have been more clear
Holland sold the future to extend the playoff streak. Pittsburgh isn't doing that but they also aren't selling to get a rebuild more firmly going. Prime example is Mantha should have been traded, he could have gotten quite the haul at the deadline
@ZmanMagnolia@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ They were never once this season a contender, and if you aren't a contender you retool or rebuild. When the core is 35+ you rebuild. They should have been a big deadline seller but instead you'll watch Mantha leave for nothing. Half in half out
@TheChancellorVC@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ Again. They were competing for a division title. You legit thought they should have traded Mantha during that time? You’re nuts if you seriously throught that should have been their play.
No team in sports would have traded their top scorer when the team was in this spot.
Awesome game, but genuinely believe offside should have an expiry, like goalie interference. If we can say “goalie had enough time to reset” after some bumps, can’t we say “defence had enough time to reset” 10 seconds after an entry? 15?
@ZmanMagnolia@Weyer_216@ProducerDrew_ You guys are so non commital on a rebuild you didn't even trade Mantha. He would have gotten quite the haul at the deadline espewoth what prices were but instead you'll watch him leave for free as a ufa to the highest bidder
@FunosGaming@ProducerDrew_ I should have been more clear
Holland sold the future to extend the playoff streak. Pittsburgh isn't doing that but they also aren't selling to get a rebuild more firmly going. Prime example is Mantha should have been traded, he could have gotten quite the haul at the deadline
@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ Pittsburgh has been selling for the past 2 years. The only time they bought is for Chinakhov and that was only a 2nd and 3rd. They are nothing like Detroit.
@Weyer_216@ZmanMagnolia@ProducerDrew_ The Penguins haven't been drafting mid to high. They haven't had a top 10 pick in 14 years.
If you truly think the Penguins rebuild is set to win next year or the year after you might just be fully delusional
@ZmanMagnolia@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ Like I said in my 1st reply, they don’t have any top tier prospects in their system. Horcoff and Kindel will be decent NHLers but I’m not expecting them to be contenders if that’s the best they’re going to get
@CornerGordo@ProducerDrew_ Mantha for sure should have been traded as he is a ufa, big miss there. You might not get full value but 75% of value is better than nothing. Like Malkin last year of his deal should have done everything you could to get him on to a contender for another cup run
@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ They should’ve moved Mantha or Brazzeau but that’s about it. Faulk gluing for a first meant none of the 3 you mentioned could get their value.
@CornerGordo@ProducerDrew_ And they should have multiple 1sts this year too. If that was the price for Faulk imagine what Karlson, Malkin, Crosby could get. They'd pick were they were going but for a haul. It's a very unpopular move but would help the rebuild tremendously and likely kept it a lottery team
Someone please help, I thought they changed the offside rule so that your skate can be in the air over the blue line??? Did they forget about this?? Unless Staal was offside and they deemed he did not have possession
@ZmanMagnolia@ProducerDrew_ And that's part of the problem it shouldnt be the same. They can't afford to make the playoffs, gotta sell anything and everything you can. Continually making the playoffs when you can't contend keeps you in purgatory and requires a ton of draft luck to get out of
@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ But they aren’t trading assets away. They did nothing at the trade deadline to risk a single thing.
Everything is the same as it was.
@CornerGordo@ProducerDrew_ Most Wings fans were ecstatic about extending the playoff streak too 🤷🏼
You're right you do have to get lucky in the draft but it's easier to be lucky when that pick is higher
@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ Most pens fans are happy. Couldn’t care less about doing that. You still need to be extremely lucky in the draft. Jackets,Sabres, wings all shown tgat
@CornerGordo@ProducerDrew_ Haven't yet and hope they don't but I'm just saying as an impartial bystander it's giving late Holland era Detroit vibes.
Name of the game is sell sell sell. You can't contend, you must sell. You can't afford to make the playoffs and must be in the lottery
@TheChancellorVC@ProducerDrew_ Who had them being close to a playoff team? It’s not like they went out trying to be one and signed players to crazy contracts.