@gunder_yan@JMC_Starbug@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling No. Your logic fails because species and sex are not the same thing. Don't write anymore stupid blue check essays. Because physical biology is mutable, sex is mutable. Sex is not an esoteric concept it is a series of characteristics which can be modified.
No, I don't think 'all people should have the right to decide their own rights', because a pluralistic democratic society can't function that way.
Which rights are trans women and 'fans of Pride' missing?
@JMC_Starbug@gunder_yan@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling They can modify their sex. They are the ones saying they are transgender men. Millions of them.
Why do you need to know anything? Other people's genitals and birth sex are none of your business.
@theklutzydom@dragnet1979@JMC_Starbug@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling Rational reasoning, clearly .. "These people are women because they are trans women" I guess then your anti-scientific nonsense spouted so far is just a new form of biology - "trans-biology".
Is your "trans-biology" also science because it has declared itself to be science?
@JMC_Starbug@gunder_yan@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling Sex is not immutable though you can alter it. Sex is not an esoteric idea, it's not chromosomes it's not gamete production it is a bundle of characteristics. Many of which can be modified. Deal with it.
@gunder_yan@JMC_Starbug@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling Sex is a series of characteristics. It is not anything else. It's not a pathway, primary and secondary characteristics make up part of sex. Chromosomes make up part of sex. There is not one individual thing that defines sex among them. It is a bundle of things.
‘Trans people exist. I have no desire for them not to exist; indeed, I wish them safety, happiness and health. However, 'existence' does not, and should not, mean the violation of other people's right to privacy, dignity and freedom of speech, or the reconfiguration of society to indulge a fallacy.’
J.K. Rowling on Twitter/X.
@JMC_Starbug@gunder_yan@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling They can't change it fully but it certainly can be modified and that's what mutability is.
That is not ideology that is medical science obviously or it wouldn't be a surgery that you could get. Your standard for what change means is irrelevant to medical science.
@theklutzydom@JMC_Starbug@gunder_yan@CJstillyoung@theglassfish13@jk_rowling This is where you’re easily demolished. Gender and anything deriving from it eg transgender, gender stereotypes, gender rules and expectations etc is a social construct - a product of social…so no one can be born transgender. Being ‘on the side of gender’ has social causes.
@BurdzPoop@IanGee2023@theglassfish13@jk_rowling Wow this was a whole bunch of babble. You don't know what chromosomes people have and you really don't know anything about people's penises and should mind your business regarding other people's genitals.
@LightninLex@JeanHatchet@BonhamBeezy@ZackPolanski So you think it’s right to blame immigrants and foreigners for the dire conditions caused by imperialism, war and exploitation? Thereby doing the work of far right forces.
WARNING
“Conversion practices” are not what you think!
The UK is making great strides in restoring understanding and respect for the sex-based rights of women and LGB people.
Those who oppose these rights, and instead promote the primacy of subjective “gender identity,” are furious.
To appease the angry people, the UK govt has promised to introduce a “fully trans-inclusive ban on conversion practices.”
Most people assume that must be a good thing. After all, conversion therapy is horrible, isn’t it? Trying to “cure” gay people with electric shock treatment?! Awful. In the discussion of this topic in the Council of Europe, it was clear that many ill-informed representatives seriously believed that that was what this ban was all about.
It has nothing to do with those horrendous practices, which were stopped and outlawed decades ago in most European countries.
It’s another word game.
First: It’s not about gays, it’s about gender identity. That’s what “trans-inclusive” means.
It’s especially about kids who say they are the opposite sex.
Second: The people promoting the ban want to ban therapists, teachers, even parents from challenging a teenager’s claim to be the opposite sex.
They claim such discussions are a kind of “conversion practice” and must be banned.
This is a frightening, pernicious proposal, which places vulnerable young people, especially lesbian teens, in danger.
Please explain this to those around you.
And especially to your MP!
Oppose the proposal to ban “conversion practices.”
Don’t hesitate to DM me if you have any questions!
@theklutzydom@wellsmitchell60@BevJacksonAuth You said it yourself , it’s YOU who doesn’t think there such thing as women’s rights, workers rights, sex based rights etc etc .
When women organise together for WOMEN’s rights .. you tell them “there’s no such thing”
You’ve lost yet again.
@dragnet1979@wellsmitchell60@BevJacksonAuth You think there's no such thing as women's rights??
Wow you are a misogynistic Trumpite creep. That tracks because Trump is anti-trans just like you.