J.Bhandari
2.6K posts

J.Bhandari
@jsb31
Associate Professor - Economics and keen researcher














Might be one of the best eco-friendly Resort in India. And we Nashikars are truly living our best life here!🙂↔️









If you look at the report, you'll find considerably more than two. Real algebra errors in the core setup of a paper with modeling are a very serious problem in macro - definitely enough reason to reject. Not because they're unfixable, but because good papers don't have them by submission time. Of course, one always has to check whether they're simply typos (as they tend to be in good human work), but in this case they are not. I know that finding such errors helps editors reject slop because editors at top journals tell me that this happens. Regarding the implicit question about whether Refine offers big-picture comments, I'm not sure whether you've looked at the report Ben linked - check out "Overall Feedback."














