O.Shane
3.7K posts
O.Shane
@oshane
Lawyer who likes Paine/Henry/Jefferson-type liberty. Former @google. Math @Cornell, JD @uw_law, LL.M. in Admiralty @TulaneLaw
Katılım Nisan 2008
617 Takip Edilen226 Takipçiler
@anderswonders @Clint_Davey1 The hardest part of directing a game of new Root players for me is conveying how quickly Vagabond will take the win if everyone isn’t paying attention.
English

@oshane @Clint_Davey1 Yup - at least in the beginning. Also, people make lots of mistakes on the first run, and a good GM / experienced player usually supports with keeping track of everyone's moves. That's when it is I who cannot control what is going on)
English

This "Celtic knotwork" aesthetic forms the backdrop for my new favourite board game - Bretwalda.

The English Remnant@TradEngland
What people call “Celtic knotwork” did not begin as Celtic. The interlaced animals and knot patterns first appear in Anglo-Saxon and Germanic pagan metalwork during the migration period. Christian monks later adopted the same style for manuscripts and crosses. That’s why it appears in works like the Lindisfarne Gospels and the Book of Kells. But the knotwork style itself grew out of the Anglo-Saxon world before being adopted and preserved by Christian scribes. 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
English
@anderswonders @Clint_Davey1 You mean their inability to control for what’s going on because nothing is symmetric?
English

@oshane @Clint_Davey1 I guess I just lament my own inability to lure people into playing Root without going mental when trying to control everything on the board :D
English
@anderswonders @Clint_Davey1 I do agree that its asymmetry is far more substantive than the cute anthropomorphic animals let on. That said, I’ve seen many people find their way into more complex games because of the marketing. Yes, some of the factions are more finicky than others.
English

I think Root is a niche game rather than a weak one. Once you dig it, you are hooked. From marketing standpoint, however, it's flawed as it signals the wrong crowd with cute and sweet appearance. I love Root and I just wish it was less finicky when it comes to all the faction-specific rules interacting between each other.
English
O.Shane retweetledi
@anderswonders @Clint_Davey1 Asymmetry is the major conceit of Root. You can’t have Root without it. Thus, it is not a weakness of the game in the sense that it is separable from the game. It appears you think Root is just a weak game.
English

@Clint_Davey1 I think it's actually a weakness of Root, as it makes maintenance & teaching very difficult
English
@DymockJohnson @davenport_jl @Clint_Davey1 I’ve played Dune uncountably many times. There’s not a single friendship that has been marred.
English

@davenport_jl @Clint_Davey1 Dune, like Diplomacy is for people who think they have too many friends.
English

Just played Root with my game design class.
It's the best way to teach them about asymmetry.
You have 4 factions who are basically all playing a different game on the same board.
The Vagabond is playing an RPG.
The cats are playing an engine building euro.
The birds are playing a wargame where you have to pre-program your turns.
The Woodland Alliance are playing like the insurgents in a COIN game and spreading sympathy gradually before sparking revolts.
Every time I play this with a group of students they love it. Really shows them what's possible with asymmetric wargame design.

English
@Kornstalx @Clint_Davey1 It is very very good. You don’t need the expansions, but they add to —do not detract from—the experience. They give variety without overstepping on the base game’s elegance.
English

@Clint_Davey1 Root is one of those popular games from the past ~8 years that I slept on. When it was big I looked at my library and said "okay I don't need any more games with a dozen expansions."
You're making me want to at least go back and get the base game. Always suspected I'd like it.
English
O.Shane retweetledi
@DietCoke_Esq I’m the opposite with French. I read it really well. I listen/hear at a high level. Speaking fluently is still hard.
English
@GideonArtifact @Jorge_Schmidt @chevas Is @chevas the bottleneck for you showing us when you’ve got?
English

@Jorge_Schmidt @chevas @oshane Sooner than you think, Jorge. @chevas is pushing hard and the momentum is there. Watch this space. 🎯
English
@RobertFreundLaw I would have made them pay $5000 in costs to each other
English
@autocorrect2_0 Because the argument is just a cover up for the amygdala.
English
O.Shane retweetledi














