Rishabh Mukherjee

31.8K posts

Rishabh Mukherjee banner
Rishabh Mukherjee

Rishabh Mukherjee

@rishabhm

Eater of food, facilitator of liquidity. All views are mine and do not reflect those of my employers - past or present.

Singapore Katılım Nisan 2009
599 Takip Edilen5.3K Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
I will say this - LLMs are not replacing humans any time soon. I have experience in my domaim and know what to elicit from an LLM. I'm saving myself the hassle of typing 100K LoC every year. But if companies stop hiring young people, there will be a void in the pipeline and it will create havoc. "AI will replace SDEs" is a marketing gimmick. AI will make people more productive and result in more people writing more software. This non-hiring of juniors will be fixed soon enough.
English
2
3
26
35.3K
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
@nileshtrivedi Also one other thing - all these IIITs have nothing to do with each other. At all. You have IIIT-H and you also have IIIT-A which is....
English
1
0
0
34
Nilesh Trivedi
Nilesh Trivedi@nileshtrivedi·
@rishabhm Yes, doubling down on CS depth is definitely one option IIITs have. My main point is that the industry demand is going to change drastically from how it was in last 15-20 years.
English
2
0
0
35
Nilesh Trivedi
Nilesh Trivedi@nileshtrivedi·
For many years, IIITs - with their sole focus on CS, ML & SWE - were graduating students with more ready-to-use skills compared to IITs. I now expect the pendulum to swing back in favor of IITs where the curriculum includes plenty of physical sciences: Atoms, Materials, Electricity, Chemicals, Fluids, and Engg processes. As problems of manipulating atoms become more valuable than those of manipulating bits, IIITs might have a curriculum redesign problem at their hand. 🤔 CS remains necessary. But it might no longer be sufficient for a long successful career.
Nilesh Trivedi tweet media
English
3
6
93
4.7K
Nilesh Trivedi
Nilesh Trivedi@nileshtrivedi·
That was a response to the market and salaries. CS skills by themselves paid the best and guaranteed a good career. It made sense to build deep expertise in CS alone. And that is what I now see as changing. SWE, and even core CS, is now getting commoditized by coding agents, which is why I have been arguing that CS alone for many will stop being sufficient (even though it will remain necessary). FWIW, I think the differences are huge. Every CS grad from IITs came out having done welding, CNC, Design of structures, Electrodynamics, Engg Graphics etc.
Nilesh Trivedi tweet media
English
2
1
0
172
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
I'm surprised at how little CS kids from IIT-K are going to end up studying by year 2. I think I'll stick with the atom-less course at IIIT-H. BTW this curriculum is designed to facilitate research and is not focused on the job market. I managed to publish two papers as a dual degree student. One of them became quite a sleeper hit and won a best paper award at a joint ACM/IEEE conference. That was made possible by the depth and breadth of courses and research exposure I had. Almost everyone in my dual degree batch published at that level. There were fewer papers from the 4 year guys, but some exceptional ones were there - I think at SODA, CVPR and ACL. This absolute top tier stuff was made possible by this curriculum.
English
1
0
1
67
Nilesh Trivedi
Nilesh Trivedi@nileshtrivedi·
@rishabhm This is first 4 semesters at IIIT-H. Very little exposure to atoms.
Nilesh Trivedi tweet media
English
1
0
0
44
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
This is all good in theory. But having worked with dozens of CS grads from IITs through my career, they all despised that stuff and universally considered it a waste of time. It left no major impact on them. That said, we also did a bunch of courses in math, physics, and electrical engineering. The differences are minor at best. Claiming them to be some sort of a differentiator is way off the mark.
English
1
0
1
28
Nilesh Trivedi
Nilesh Trivedi@nileshtrivedi·
Typically, the first year curriculum is common for all the majors, and that has a very different composition at IITs than at IIITs. Then there is the whole environment - electives, labs, batchmates in different majors that you regular brainstorm with - that encourages interdisciplinary conversations.
English
2
0
0
129
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
I've been using Fable for a couple of weeks and it's been burning through tokens like a drunken sailor on shore leave after the battle of midway. I tried Kimi K3 yesterday for a bit. I am not setup as optimally as I am with Claude Code, but there are substantial qualitative differences between Kimi K3 and Fable for my area of work - i.e. high performance systems and quantitative libraries. Of course this doesn't say anything about their usefulness as general models. On a totally unrelated note, I'm surprised at how behind the curve Grok is...
Rohan Paul@rohanpaul_ai

"American companies such as Modal, Fireworks, and Baseten will be able to serve Kimi K3, at one-tenth the cost of their Chinese competitors because they have access to advanced Nvidia and AMD chips. There is some irony here. Much of the model’s research and development has shifted to China, but once the model is optimized for next-generation hardware such as Nvidia’s Rubin architecture, its operating cost could fall by 10 to 100 times." Emad Mostaque, co-founding Stability AI. ---- From "Peter H. Diamandis" YouTube channel, (full video link in comment)

English
0
0
0
323
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
Pakistan hasn't ever admitted it's losses in Kargil. A conflict where the videos of their soldiers were buried with full customs by India. Fat chance of them accepting their losses in Op Sindoor.
Aditya Raj Kaul@AdityaRajKaul

#BREAKING: Top Pakistani politician and MP Fazal-ur-Rehman has hit out at the Pakistan Army days ahead of Kargil Vijay Diwas. Rehman alleged that the Pakistan Army concealed its casualties during the 1999 Kargil War with India and, to date, has not publicly released the list of Pakistani soldiers killed in the conflict, whose numbers, run into the hundreds.

English
0
0
8
684
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
In college, there were quite a few guys who just pretended to be super woke, feminist and leftist to improve their chances with the opposite gender. At the time, I thought it was odd and probably an uncommon strategy. Turns out it wasn't.
Chandrabhushan Joshi (CJ)@MatruBhakt

@ANI One month of Samosa, Chole Bhaturas, Flirting with chics around. Some Anti National Statements from people on the stage. The Drama is about to get over.

English
1
3
22
890
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
@unrave20 I once went from SIN to BOM via MAA so that I could meet my cousin who was in MAA. I had to go from the international terminal to the domestic one. My first reaction upon landing in MAA was "Where the fuck am I???". Even Kolkata wasn't this bad....
English
0
0
3
134
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
I really admire both people in the thread for various reasons and both of them are wrong on different counts. ITES cos are not in the model development business because they do not have the required capabilities to execute a project like this. This is not a criticism of these companies. Building frontier models has had very little to do with the core business of ITES. No company is ever expected to redirect significant amount of it's opex to a non core initiative. This doesn't align with MSV and would be bad governance. Better to pay out a dividend and move on.
Mohandas Pai@TVMohandasPai

Useless failures like this one pontificate and preach without understanding business and industry. Idiotic comments. AI models are created by start ups not cos like Accenture, Apple, they need huge capital, billions which is not available in India. Our start ups like @SarvamAI are doing a great job but need more Capital. This is like asking a commercial bank to become a venture fund. People who do not understand industry should not make loose comments

English
3
0
8
1.9K
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
As a matter of common sense, protesting against a bad policy is a worthwhile cause. Protesting against bad execution is typically unlikely to draw much interest because people understand that whatever went down was never what was intended. Especially if this is an infrequent problem, not affecting too many people. While OP has the luxury of taking a day off and chilling in the great weather of Bengaluru, others do not.
Dravisha@dravishakatoch

Went to the protest in Bangalore today at Freedom park. The strength today was extremely disappointing. Asked publicly if anyone from my tech/startup circle wanted to come. Almost zero replies. This city has one of the most educated, most privileged tech populations in the country. And when it actually mattered, everyone stayed inside their fancy offices and fancy homes. Reposting is not activism. Show up.

English
1
4
37
3.6K
Rishabh Mukherjee
Rishabh Mukherjee@rishabhm·
The lukewarm reception to this scheme is IMHO down the govts constant flip-flops on issues related to taxation and their penchant for litigation over the last 5 years. After one rug-pull too many, investors are giving this a pass.
Neil Borate@ActusDei

India's FCNR scheme is falling short, and that gives NRIs some bargaining power The FCNR(B) scheme (Dollar Deposits from NRIs), RBI's go-to for rupee support since the 2013 taper tantrum has mobilised just $3.08 billion so far from disclosed numbers. Original estimates pegged this scheme at $50-70 billion. That's not a shortfall, that's a scheme running at a fraction of its target with the window closing September 30, 2026. For NRIs, that gap is leverage literally and figuratively. Some points to note: → Only a handful of banks have disclosed numbers, and each has a long way to go to achieve their target. PNB: $425mn raised against a $2.5bn target. Indian Bank: $140mn against $2bn. Union Bank: $106mn against $2bn. If a bank is telling you its target, it's also telling you how much room it has left to fill. → HDFC, ICICI, Kotak, Federal, and Yes Bank haven't disclosed their numbers publicly. That doesn't mean the appetite isn't there. It means you have to ask and compare, bank to bank, rather than assume one is offering the best deal. → Leverage on these deposits ranges from 8-12x at Indian banks, up to 19x at some overseas institutions, a meaningful difference depending on where you bank. → The leverage math isn't universal. FCNR interest is taxed on a gross basis for most NRIs, and per HDFC Bank's own CEO, leveraged positions mainly pencil out for depositors in the Gulf and Singapore. If you're in the US, UK, or Australia, the tax treatment in your country of residence changes the calculation, even though the interest itself is tax-free in India. The bottom line: banks are competing for NRI dollars right now, with roughly ten weeks left on the incentive window and the system nowhere near its mobilisation target. Most depositors don't realise how much negotiating room that gives them. We will guide you through this, including the risks to watch out for. Schedule a call with us on thefynprint website. Sources: Hindu Business Line, Mint, ET HDFC Bank management commentary. #NRI #FCNR

English
0
1
20
1.3K