Curious Reason

355 posts

Curious Reason banner
Curious Reason

Curious Reason

@ReasonCurious

Creating science education videos for 8 years about geography, geology, human anatomy, and history.

Katılım Nisan 2018
150 Takip Edilen75 Takipçiler
Sabitlenmiş Tweet
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
🚨 Day 23: YouTube DEMONETIZED my 165K-subscriber science education channel as "Inauthentic content." My channel: youtube.com/c/CuriousReason - see for yourself, how is this inauthentic? I research, write, and produce every video myself. Vectors in Illustrator. Animation in After Effects. 3D scenes built by my team of Blender artists - who depend on me for their salaries. It takes at least 150-200 hours to produce a single 15-minute video. My most-viewed video - "How Fast Can Humans Theoretically Run" - has 9 MILLION views, posted 5 years ago. The theoretical human body limit niche is exclusive to my channel. Nobody else on YouTube makes these videos. Each one takes weeks of original research and writing. When I challenged this on X, @TeamYouTube replied that my content is specifically "mass produced.", I attached their response. Here's the actual math: I POSTED 12 VIDEOS IN THE LAST 8 MONTHS. 120 videos in 8 years. Mass-produced channels (the kind this policy was designed to catch) upload 30–50 videos per DAY. I upload 600× LESS than the channels YouTube's AI is actually trying to flag. How is 1-2 videos a month "mass produced"? No strikes. No prior issues. No copyright claims. I submitted an unlisted appeal video showing my full research and writing process. The response was a copy-paste reply with not one thing specific to my channel. They say wait 90 days, but WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO CHANGE IN MY CONTENT? After 23 days, I still don't know what I'm supposed to change - because my channel is the antithesis of inauthentic content. Below: a clip of my actual production workflow - animation, scripting, and research - on some of my most complex videos. Watch the layers. Watch the thousands of keyframes. Watch the work. This is my full-time work. My Blender and Vector team is waiting on salaries. The worst part is that if you don't have a following, then you are treated like disposable garbage; it's gut-wrenching to be honest. Congrats on the remonetization @AydinPaladin @adamfrancisco_ @bear_ing @Drunk3po @Sugar_Tits_Bear @MovieTalkNOW1 @olleshortz - Please help me spread the word, it's getting quite dark out here. As I said, you are garbage for YouTube Support if you don't have a following here on X. I don't have any active ticket case with Creator Support via email, the last thing they said was that they can't help me. I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for ONE real human at YouTube to actually look at my channel. @reneritchie @YouTubeCreators @TeamYouTube @nealmohan @UpdatesFromYT - can you escalate this to an internal team for a real second look? This is a clear AI mistake. #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #contentcreator #monetization #youtubepartner #fairreview #fixyoutube #youtubepolicy #supportcreators
Curious Reason tweet mediaCurious Reason tweet media
English
3
1
2
171
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
Hello @TeamYouTube I posted 12 unique, original, educational videos in the last 8 months. But the review came back as "mass produced". There was definitely a mistake during the review process. Please, let a human or Youtube rep take a look at my channel.
Curious Reason tweet mediaCurious Reason tweet media
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious

🚨 Day 23: YouTube DEMONETIZED my 165K-subscriber science education channel as "Inauthentic content." My channel: youtube.com/c/CuriousReason - see for yourself, how is this inauthentic? I research, write, and produce every video myself. Vectors in Illustrator. Animation in After Effects. 3D scenes built by my team of Blender artists - who depend on me for their salaries. It takes at least 150-200 hours to produce a single 15-minute video. My most-viewed video - "How Fast Can Humans Theoretically Run" - has 9 MILLION views, posted 5 years ago. The theoretical human body limit niche is exclusive to my channel. Nobody else on YouTube makes these videos. Each one takes weeks of original research and writing. When I challenged this on X, @TeamYouTube replied that my content is specifically "mass produced.", I attached their response. Here's the actual math: I POSTED 12 VIDEOS IN THE LAST 8 MONTHS. 120 videos in 8 years. Mass-produced channels (the kind this policy was designed to catch) upload 30–50 videos per DAY. I upload 600× LESS than the channels YouTube's AI is actually trying to flag. How is 1-2 videos a month "mass produced"? No strikes. No prior issues. No copyright claims. I submitted an unlisted appeal video showing my full research and writing process. The response was a copy-paste reply with not one thing specific to my channel. They say wait 90 days, but WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO CHANGE IN MY CONTENT? After 23 days, I still don't know what I'm supposed to change - because my channel is the antithesis of inauthentic content. Below: a clip of my actual production workflow - animation, scripting, and research - on some of my most complex videos. Watch the layers. Watch the thousands of keyframes. Watch the work. This is my full-time work. My Blender and Vector team is waiting on salaries. The worst part is that if you don't have a following, then you are treated like disposable garbage; it's gut-wrenching to be honest. Congrats on the remonetization @AydinPaladin @adamfrancisco_ @bear_ing @Drunk3po @Sugar_Tits_Bear @MovieTalkNOW1 @olleshortz - Please help me spread the word, it's getting quite dark out here. As I said, you are garbage for YouTube Support if you don't have a following here on X. I don't have any active ticket case with Creator Support via email, the last thing they said was that they can't help me. I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for ONE real human at YouTube to actually look at my channel. @reneritchie @YouTubeCreators @TeamYouTube @nealmohan @UpdatesFromYT - can you escalate this to an internal team for a real second look? This is a clear AI mistake. #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #contentcreator #monetization #youtubepartner #fairreview #fixyoutube #youtubepolicy #supportcreators

English
1
0
1
32
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
🚨 Day 23: YouTube DEMONETIZED my 165K-subscriber science education channel as "Inauthentic content." My channel: youtube.com/c/CuriousReason - see for yourself, how is this inauthentic? I research, write, and produce every video myself. Vectors in Illustrator. Animation in After Effects. 3D scenes built by my team of Blender artists - who depend on me for their salaries. It takes at least 150-200 hours to produce a single 15-minute video. My most-viewed video - "How Fast Can Humans Theoretically Run" - has 9 MILLION views, posted 5 years ago. The theoretical human body limit niche is exclusive to my channel. Nobody else on YouTube makes these videos. Each one takes weeks of original research and writing. When I challenged this on X, @TeamYouTube replied that my content is specifically "mass produced.", I attached their response. Here's the actual math: I POSTED 12 VIDEOS IN THE LAST 8 MONTHS. 120 videos in 8 years. Mass-produced channels (the kind this policy was designed to catch) upload 30–50 videos per DAY. I upload 600× LESS than the channels YouTube's AI is actually trying to flag. How is 1-2 videos a month "mass produced"? No strikes. No prior issues. No copyright claims. I submitted an unlisted appeal video showing my full research and writing process. The response was a copy-paste reply with not one thing specific to my channel. They say wait 90 days, but WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO CHANGE IN MY CONTENT? After 23 days, I still don't know what I'm supposed to change - because my channel is the antithesis of inauthentic content. Below: a clip of my actual production workflow - animation, scripting, and research - on some of my most complex videos. Watch the layers. Watch the thousands of keyframes. Watch the work. This is my full-time work. My Blender and Vector team is waiting on salaries. The worst part is that if you don't have a following, then you are treated like disposable garbage; it's gut-wrenching to be honest. Congrats on the remonetization @AydinPaladin @adamfrancisco_ @bear_ing @Drunk3po @Sugar_Tits_Bear @MovieTalkNOW1 @olleshortz - Please help me spread the word, it's getting quite dark out here. As I said, you are garbage for YouTube Support if you don't have a following here on X. I don't have any active ticket case with Creator Support via email, the last thing they said was that they can't help me. I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for ONE real human at YouTube to actually look at my channel. @reneritchie @YouTubeCreators @TeamYouTube @nealmohan @UpdatesFromYT - can you escalate this to an internal team for a real second look? This is a clear AI mistake. #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #contentcreator #monetization #youtubepartner #fairreview #fixyoutube #youtubepolicy #supportcreators
Curious Reason tweet mediaCurious Reason tweet media
English
3
1
2
171
Monumental
Monumental@real_Monumental·
@TikTokSupport My account was rejected from the creator rewards program for "unoriginal content" -- but ALL of my content is MY original work. I use AI voices and visuals to create films and documentary analysis videos. Everything on my TikTok page is content that I personally wrote and edited. I submitted an appeal and it was rejected. Can you please help me with this? My account handles is @monumental.video
Monumental tweet mediaMonumental tweet media
English
7
0
1
189
Nina Infinity
Nina Infinity@Nina7Infinity·
@chrispavlovski Recommend other things other than right wing politics. Educational, pop culture and entertainment. I'm sick of seeing Dan Bongina's face.. I don't even follow him.
English
8
7
94
1.3K
Chris Pavlovski 🏴‍☠️
I've seen a lot of feedback -- we love developing and listening to our community. With that being said -- how would you setup the Rumble's home screen?
English
158
36
139
36.3K
TeamYouTube
TeamYouTube@TeamYouTube·
@ReasonCurious We've replied to your DM with more details. Totally understand how important this is to you, be sure to check that out
English
2
0
1
150
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
Day 19 since YouTube DEMONETIZED my ORIGINAL 165k subscriber science educational channel as "Inauthentic content." My channel: youtube.com/c/CuriousReason I research, write, and produce every video myself, create vectors on Illustrator -> Animate them on After Effects. I also have a team of Blender 3D animators for 3d scenes that I hired and depend on my for salaries. My videos are original analytical angles on geography, megaprojects, and the limits of the human body. Every single video is unique. For example: Theoretical limits of the human body, like my most viewed video: How fast humans can theoretically run - 9 million views, posted 5 years ago created from scratch - so are all my videos. Theoretical human body limit videos are exclusive to my channel, nobody but I do these videos. How is this inauthentic? @TeamYouTube @YouTube @nealmohan @YouTubeCreators @UpdatesFromYT No strikes. No prior issues. No copyright claims. I submitted an unlisted appeal video showing my full research and writing process. The response was a copy-paste reply, not one thing specific to my channel. @TeamYouTube, @reneritchie can you pass this over to an internal team for a second look? Because it's a clear confusion and a mistake. Even after 90 days, I don't know what to change to comply with "inauthentic content" because my channel and videos are the antithesis of what is an "inauthentic content" is. I don't have any active ticket cases with Creator Support. Below: three short clips of my actual production workflow — animation, scripting, and research — on some of my most complex videos. Watch the layers. Watch the thousands of keyframes. Watch the work. This is my full-time work. DOES IT LOOK INAUTHENTIC? ,I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for ONE real human at YouTube to actually look at my channel. The worst part is the you can't pay salaries for blender artists you already hired💔 #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #contentcreator #monetization #youtubepartner #fairreview #fixyoutube #youtubepolicy #supportcreators
English
11
6
21
1.1K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@olleshortz I posted 12 long form and 6 shorts in the last 8 months. But YT is insisting that I am specifically mass producing and demonetized me. Clown world we are living in.
English
0
0
2
416
Olle Kaas
Olle Kaas@olleshortz·
If you think you are uploading alot of shorts, remember there are channels uploading 40 shorts a day:
Olle Kaas tweet media
English
5
1
63
5.4K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@danbayron6 Hi, sorry you have been going through this. Can you please tell me where you can see these active cases? I can't find it.
English
2
0
1
301
Rank Up
Rank Up@danbayron6·
YouTube removed my monetization for “reused content” after I spent months building my channel and editing every video myself. I showed ALL of this in my appeal video step by step The craziest part? My appeal was rejected so fast that the video still had 0 views. So how was my evidence even reviewed? At this point it genuinely feels like automated responses instead of a fair human review. I’m just asking for one real person to actually look at my case properly. @TeamYouTube @YouTube #YouTube #DSA #Demonetization #SmallCreator
Rank Up tweet media
English
15
10
40
3.8K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@chrispavlovski @ric_rac The day you stop promoting Rumble as a political platform is the day you become a true competitor to YouTube. Hope that happens soon enough
English
1
0
2
232
Chris Pavlovski 🏴‍☠️
Three Rumble features I’m waiting for… 1) Recommended For You to replace Editor Picks. 2) Ability for creators to boost channels and content across Rumble. 3) Ability for creators to inject mid-rolls in their livestreams, controlled by them. @ric_rac is cooking.
English
61
35
213
17.2K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
I was Reddit famous 6 years ago.
Curious Reason tweet media
English
0
0
2
65
Dragon Quiz
Dragon Quiz@KevalKevaldk·
Yeah… it’s totally confusing and unfair and the worst part is their broken creator support system. Their ai will reject appeal, and then no matter how much you try, you will always get the same automated reply. It’s totally frustrating and unfair. I wish your channel gets remonetized again. I have lost all hopes in mine. But i wish you all the best.
English
1
0
1
18
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
But thousands of channels use AI voice, not clones, but generic ones are still monetized. There are podcast channels like Aydin Paladin, who doesn't use any AI or Pilotphotog, who appears on his own videos and records himself, that have been demonetized as well. Its so random and confusing.
English
1
0
1
31
Dragon Quiz
Dragon Quiz@KevalKevaldk·
@ReasonCurious Yeah it shouldn’t be the issue, but its common in all demonetized channel. In all niches. So who knows? Because youtube doesn’t clear any confusion.
English
1
0
0
35
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
No, I didn't tick altered content because AI voice, especially your own cloned voice, is not classified as altered content. It's my own voice, but cloned. Sometimes, I get sick, or my throat hurts, I don't want that to disrupt the production process, so I cloned it and use it. There is a special disclosure right below the altered content option, which says if it's your AI-cloned voice, then you shouldn't tick. Because YT dubs to other languages automatically when you upload a video, they clearly use the AI voice for all videos across YouTube, so the AI voice by Elevenlabs shouldn't be a problem at all. But still, I wonder if it's giving false positive flags - this is the real question, their AI moderation is absolutely trash.
English
1
0
1
23
Dragon Quiz
Dragon Quiz@KevalKevaldk·
@ReasonCurious Did you tick altered content while uploading? Maybe they are tracking ai voices. Because one thing is common in all demonetized channel. No matter which niche, all have ai voice (elevenlabs) , maybe they are punishing those who didn’t turn on altered content.
English
1
0
0
23
Video Game History
Video Game History@VideoGameHstry·
Just when we though it couldn't get any better than this
English
252
422
8.3K
868.2K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
Thanks for the update! @TeamYouTube But I posted 12 unique and original videos and 6 shorts in the last 8 months. HOW IS THIS MASS-PRODUCED? Can you please escalate this to a human review?
Curious Reason tweet mediaCurious Reason tweet media
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious

Day 19 since YouTube DEMONETIZED my ORIGINAL 165k subscriber science educational channel as "Inauthentic content." My channel: youtube.com/c/CuriousReason I research, write, and produce every video myself, create vectors on Illustrator -> Animate them on After Effects. I also have a team of Blender 3D animators for 3d scenes that I hired and depend on my for salaries. My videos are original analytical angles on geography, megaprojects, and the limits of the human body. Every single video is unique. For example: Theoretical limits of the human body, like my most viewed video: How fast humans can theoretically run - 9 million views, posted 5 years ago created from scratch - so are all my videos. Theoretical human body limit videos are exclusive to my channel, nobody but I do these videos. How is this inauthentic? @TeamYouTube @YouTube @nealmohan @YouTubeCreators @UpdatesFromYT No strikes. No prior issues. No copyright claims. I submitted an unlisted appeal video showing my full research and writing process. The response was a copy-paste reply, not one thing specific to my channel. @TeamYouTube, @reneritchie can you pass this over to an internal team for a second look? Because it's a clear confusion and a mistake. Even after 90 days, I don't know what to change to comply with "inauthentic content" because my channel and videos are the antithesis of what is an "inauthentic content" is. I don't have any active ticket cases with Creator Support. Below: three short clips of my actual production workflow — animation, scripting, and research — on some of my most complex videos. Watch the layers. Watch the thousands of keyframes. Watch the work. This is my full-time work. DOES IT LOOK INAUTHENTIC? ,I'm not asking for special treatment. I'm asking for ONE real human at YouTube to actually look at my channel. The worst part is the you can't pay salaries for blender artists you already hired💔 #inauthenticcontent #youtube #youtubedemonetization #creatorsupport #youtubecreators #contentcreator #monetization #youtubepartner #fairreview #fixyoutube #youtubepolicy #supportcreators

English
0
0
0
52
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@TeamYouTube As you say, it's mass-produced in the DMs. How is this mass-produced? I posted 12 videos in the last 8 months. How is this mass-produced? I need a human to talk to and escalate.
Curious Reason tweet media
English
0
0
0
16
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@LyonsRegis17104 FYI, static images and especially fictional stories trigger "inauthentic content" and are perceived to be mass-produced and templated by YT.
English
1
0
0
779
Just Some Guy Stories
Just Some Guy Stories@LyonsRegis17104·
I’m tired of pretending this is just “part of being a creator.” 24 days ago YouTube demonetized my channel and since then my life has genuinely been falling apart. This wasn’t some extra side income. My family depended on this. My mom depended on this. I made my own character. My own stories. My own ideas. I spent years building something I was proud of. Now all of that gets reduced to two words: “inauthentic content.” No real explanation. No actual human response. Just copy pasted replies while I sit here trying to understand what the hell I supposedly did wrong. Do people understand what this does to someone mentally? I can’t sleep properly anymore. I barely eat. Every day feels like panic the second I wake up. I keep checking my emails hoping maybe this time there’ll finally be a real answer. And the worst part is watching my family slowly realize I might not be able to fix this. I saw my mom crying recently because she thought I didn’t notice. That completely destroyed me. People online talk about “creator economy” like it’s some dream life, but the reality is one automated system can wipe out years of work overnight and nobody is even required to explain why. If my content was truly violating policy, then SHOW ME. Show me the videos. Show me the problem. Talk to me like I’m a human being instead of sending automated responses while my real life collapses behind the screen. @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators @nealmohan
Just Some Guy Stories tweet media
English
63
51
210
16.2K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@KevinEspiritu I got demonetized - no AI slop or templated or anything. I would say 95%, not 99% - the system makes mistakes. There are legit creators who use Blender solely to make videos - real work and value.
English
0
0
0
74
Kevin → Plant Daddy
Kevin → Plant Daddy@KevinEspiritu·
YouTube is correct in 99%+ of these demonetization cases. This channel is pure AI slop & they hired a guy off Fiverr to make the video below for sympathy. Account is from Vietnam. You're not entitled to ad rev for making the world's laziest content possible at scale, parasites
Fluffy Animal Tales@FluffyTaless

YouTube demonetized my channel, Fluffy Animal Tales, for “Inauthentic content” a few weeks ago. I want to share my full story because this decision has seriously affected my work, my channel, and the animals I try to help. Fluffy Animal Tales is a wildlife storytelling channel focused on emotional rescue stories, animal rehabilitation, and the bond between humans and wild animals, especially bobcats and lynx. Every video is created with care. We research real wildlife rescue situations, build original storylines, write the scripts ourselves, create unique visuals, edit each video manually, and shape every story to spread kindness, awareness, and respect for animals. This is not automated content. This is not mass-produced. This is not reused content. Every video is made with effort, emotion, and a clear purpose. Because of this demonetization, YouTube has removed over $15,000 from my channel. This money helped support the work behind the channel and our mission to keep creating meaningful animal rescue stories. It disappeared almost overnight with no real explanation. I submitted an appeal video showing my full creation process step by step, but I believe it was rejected by an automated system without a real human review. The response felt like a copy-paste message that many other creators have received. I have followed the process. I have reached out. I have provided details. But I keep hitting the same wall. All I am asking for is one real person at YouTube to actually review my channel and my appeal fairly. @TeamYouTube @YouTubeCreators @YouTube, please do the right thing. If you believe creators deserve fair treatment, please repost this.

English
15
7
138
12K
Curious Reason
Curious Reason@ReasonCurious·
@MovieTalkNOW1 There are too many recycling of the same thing/concept but with better resolution and lighting. Penguin and Fallout series are somewhat breath of fresh air but still.
English
0
0
1
26
David Perez - Movie Talk NOW
Asked my audience on YT, did you enjoy The Punisher: One Last Kill' or 'Dardevil: Born Again- Season 2' more? The results were pretty surprising...
David Perez - Movie Talk NOW tweet media
English
2
0
2
205