Till Festenberg
1.1K posts

Till Festenberg
@TFestenberg
Math and markets














Market Insights with The Carny – December 19, 2025 (Please like, RT and comment if useful, thank you!) There is a large discussion on FinTwit right now about whether it is possible to trade for a living as a retail trader. It has all the familiar arguments. Passive investing is king. Ninety eight percent of traders fail. The usual cautionary tales about not having an edge or any informational advantage against firms with billions of dollars and massive teams of data scientists at their disposal. While many of these points are valid, they ignore one glaring reality that rarely gets discussed. Failure is one of the most basic aspects of life. The man who saved for years to open a restaurant. The woman who tried to start a nonprofit to feed the homeless. There are endless graveyards of noble ideas and genuine attempts to change one’s life that failed badly, yet we rarely scoff at them or treat those efforts as foolish. In life, anything you try to do to advance in a career or entrepreneurial endeavor puts you at a mathematical disadvantage as you attempt to edge your way out of the center of the bell curve. By definition, most people are average. You, me, anyone is far more likely to sit near the middle of the distribution than out on the wings… not to mention there are two wings, and only one of them lands you on the positive side. The cards are, and always will be, stacked against you. While many of the people I work with and interact with daily are not US citizens, I think we can all agree on the foundation of the idea of the “American Dream.” That you should be able to chase advancement up the social hierarchy at the cost of failure. That the system is meant to churn, discard bad ideas, and allow the good ones to rise to the top. While we all know these ideals do not fully live up to reality, the idea itself is rooted in a universal truth. So what is the truth about trading? It is painfully simple. You are likely not cut out to succeed in a job where you fail more than half of the time… while dealing with the stress of an inconsistent paycheck and life’s inevitable curveballs. If you have people who rely on you, dependents, a spouse, you probably do not have the financial flexibility or time required to sit in front of a screen every day and succeed. If you think one thousand, ten thousand, or even a hundred thousand dollars is enough starting capital to fight the market daily, again, NGMI. And one of the most important points: if you think trading is exciting, fun, or fulfilling on a daily basis, you are mistaken. Most of the time it is boring, mind numbing, and tedious, with rare flashes of excitement surrounded by long stretches of slow PnL bleed while the big up days only come a few times a year. The cards are stacked against you. You are likely to fail. But what people deny you through scare tactics and horror stories is your God given right to fail, learn, dust yourself off, and carry those lessons forward to the next generation. Trading is about failure. It is about losing on a mathematically uncomfortable scale that almost no one can tolerate, and surviving long enough to win the larger battle. It is a marathon of self confrontation that most people want no part of, and the odds are absolutely stacked against you. But if I can do it, so can you. And while I fight daily to move toward the edge of the bell curve, the scars I carry, both physical and mental, are real. I have failed more times than you can imagine, and I am better because of it. A close friend of mine, my pastor, has a saying. Those who say “yes” to risk are rewarded with adventure. Those who say “no” are rewarded with safety. Each path has its benefits, and each has its costs. So @#$% those who say you can’t do it. If you have decided the risk is worth it, and you understand that adventures often end at the feet of dragons, move forward and try anyway. No one writes stories about those who never take the risk, and at the same time... no one really cares about the burnt remains of those who tried and failed. Trade at your own risk. - Nik " The Carny" Lentz ---------------------------------------------------------- Follow @PiQSuite for best News Source on the internet! Disclaimer: The information provided here is for educational purposes and should not be considered financial advice. Markets carry inherent risks, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Please conduct your own research or consult a financial professional before making investment decisions. All opinions are my own. Please trade responsibly ---------------------------------------------------------- == Preparation Beats Prediction == ----------------------------------------------------------






















