The Noise

@MyDustyBin He kept Villa up with Callum Chambers and Ludwig Augustinsson if we're gonna go that far back and choose the worst players each manager has had

@TheNoiseYoutube Could Emery have kept Newcastle up with Paul Dummett and Matt Ritchie.

Question for the Eddie in cult Is Emery a better manager than Eddie? Because so far in the last month I've been told; Alonso isn't Maresca isn't Mourinho isn't #nufc

@Nolberto099 @FishandChipsNE Shahar good enough to captain England at youth level but not good enough to play against Qarabag for more than 3 minutes across 2 legs when we were winning 9-3 on aggregrate?

@TheNoiseYoutube @FishandChipsNE Release clause on by the 30th June that season. Captain Hindsight. Howe always has the long term health of the club in mind. Also Shahar obviously isn't good enough yet. So boring people like you wittering nonsense.

Also why is Eddie Howe v Unai Emery suddenly a “thing”. Two different coaches. Two different clubs. Both done exceptionally good jobs for their clubs. Apples and pears IMO

@Nolberto099 @FishandChipsNE Aye, im sure going from CL to near relegation is great for the long term health of the club Much better than Emery at Villa with his back to back to back european qualification How will they attract any good players now? Finances must be a mess too with all this CL football

@offitman @Nolberto099 @FishandChipsNE We got 15m total for Anderson cos of the structure with Vlachodimos, how much did we sell Longstaff for with a years less contract?

@TheNoiseYoutube @Nolberto099 @FishandChipsNE Could it possibly be because we were offered more for Anderson and Minteh because they are better players than Longstaff and Willock, allowing us to begrudgingly but more easily resolve PSR concerns? No, it's an Eddie Howe conspiracy 😂

@Nolberto099 @FishandChipsNE Emery has qualified for europe every year while already playing Europe and managing 2 games a week, Eddie hasn't managed that once

@TheNoiseYoutube @FishandChipsNE Also Emery has CL football twice so does Howe. Emery finally won a trophy which was a LOT easier than ours.

@Nolberto099 @FishandChipsNE Keeping Longstaff and Willock and selling Anderson and Minteh is for the long term view of the club? Repeatedly running a 34 year old trippier into the ground over giving a youth england captain Leo Shahar any minutes is for the future of the club?

@TheNoiseYoutube @FishandChipsNE One has the long term interests of the club in mind the other one doesn't. Once Emery leaves Villa you will see the mess he will leave. Emery has bought for today. Howe buys with the long term view of the club in mind.

@shimmani3 Yes I underdstand that, I don't think you've understood my post It's the use of "for a 2nd season as if he's on trial" which I did say He has a contract until 2031, until he's sold we're keeping him for another 5 seasons, not 2.

@TheNoiseYoutube Because there had literally been massive speculation he wants to go or we would sell him this summer for the past couple months

Keep him for a 2nd season? Wtf are we talking about? He's contracted until 2031. What a strange post and conversation to even be having. How is potentially the most technically gifted player at the club, Germany's number 9 seemingly on trial? #nufc

@klutschlol Didn't he agree to it then because Amanda went bragging about it he changed his mind?

@TheNoiseYoutube Unai Emery was always a better manager than Eddie, but remember he didn't fancy coming when we were deep in the shit, before eddie was appointed and gave it a wide fucking berth. So even tho we all know he's better he didn't think he'd turn around the shit show. EH did.

@Willg_nufc Also not to mention 7 of the players that started last night and won them the europa league were there when Emery arrived

@TheNoiseYoutube You are describing Emery as a manager which i said he's the best at. Game management, tactics, set up etc. Coaching is working with the player behind the scenes to help them evolve. You have a misunderstanding of what I meant, no worries

@Willg_nufc Well I did say coaching in my explanation id personally say coaching involves more than just man management/player development

@Willg_nufc What qualifies Howe as a better coach? Emery coaching different systems that can adapt the team into to consistently beating all variations of opposition and control games, dictate tempo etc. is why I would say he's not personally

@TheNoiseYoutube Emery the better manager, Howe the better coach

@SAFCMeltdown @daveynicnufc @NUDMC91 I cant understand how you can be so confident of winning a european trophy when we cant beat sunderland and were worried about relegation 2 weeks ago?

@TheNoiseYoutube @daveynicnufc @NUDMC91 Welcome to football it happens. Both games were after away CL games.

@SAFCMeltdown @daveynicnufc @NUDMC91 We lost twice to sunderland...

@daveynicnufc @NUDMC91 @TheNoiseYoutube Look at Villa's fixtures this season in the Europa League. We'd have won it too. Howe out brigade living in cloud cuckoo land as always.

@ThomasMoyse That was the point mate 🤯 to see how far they'll go cos at least to me Emery is undeniably better 🤯

@TheNoiseYoutube The replies to this are alarming. Are these answers reflective for the majority of the Eddie in lot? All mangers listed are better than Eddie.

@daveynicnufc We nearly got relegated this season mate... Pissed the Europa league? You've got to be joking right?

@TheNoiseYoutube Is Eddie now getting penalised for qualifying for the champions league and not winning it? We wouldve pissed the Europa and Conference!!

@HD_07 Shouldn't be surprised really should I

@TheNoiseYoutube That's Luke Edwards' standard of journalism

@davethemag1965 @petemcbee I can't even see what he said, not sure if I've been blocked or something

@petemcbee @TheNoiseYoutube Bye

@Diamond8618 Did you only read the 1st line?

@TheNoiseYoutube Because 1 game a week I think Eddie will be back to 4-3-3 gung ho next season where he 99% will likely work out again playing 1 game a week and if that was the case, Osula is better than Woltemade in that system, just a guess

@BoyYeeting EHFC 3 - Emery 1 27' If 46' Should 82' Could

@TheNoiseYoutube 3-1 Eddie