James Larkin

@HilarityjaneArt So naturally Catholic traditionalists mistrust and resist the hierarchy. But choosing our own pastors and hierarchs based on private judgement about who is faithful to Tradition seems incompatible with Catholicism too.

Novusordoism simply does not prioritise salvation.

@_pistism @AzPetrich Jesus Christ is “an invisible being?” Are you saying that the Incarnation didn’t happen or that Christ didn’t really take on human nature?

Neither of the two images look like him. You can’t paint a picture of an invisible being. Even when Moses was leading the Israelites, the God descend on the mountain to talk with Moses, he will always charge Moses to tell the people not to come near the mountain nor peep to see him. God deliberately hides the face Jesus from man to prevent idolatry, cos of human nature. Even when Moses died, God hid his body for the same reason. As far as the worship of God is concerned, it is base on faith, not on an imaginary image of him! If the word of God and the one spoken by Jesus while he was on earth could be preserved up to this age, his image also could be preserved but God ensured that didn’t happen! As believers, our faith is in the word of God and on his son Jesus, and not on any picture of imaginary image!

Just a reminder for Christian's celebrating Easter this week. Jesus looked like the guy in the first picture - not the second.

@amuse @porterstansb He was obviously joking.

Honestly, have you looked at the data? The perpetrators and victims of gun crimes are predominantly from one race. If you look at gun crime stats and filter out just one race our gun crime rates are similar to most of Europe. If you filter out two they're lower than most European countries.

Race has nothing to do with this. The problem is guns, not people.

@johnamonaco I was met with scorn and hostility when I tried to engage with seminary professors about the plain language of papal documents. I like your phrase — I was supposed to wink and nod. I couldn’t do the mental gymnastics anymore.

Progressive Catholics treat Catholicism like an elite club where you’re supposed to wink and nod your way through all Church teachings. Then they see Catholic converts who actually *believe* what the Church teaches, and they panic, for they know no one converts for their brand.

@espekadaengrish @JayDyer @seeyoutwominute Can you point to an error taught by Orthodoxy?

@JayDyer @seeyoutwominute It's not an all or nothing question. I'd say there doesn't exist a Christian sect that doesn't teach some error.

This loser who ran from a public formal debate has now classed me above Martin Luther! I’ve won

@apostolicunfl Who says that? The papacy is seriously disordered, but I’ve never hear anyone claim that the pope is Jesus on earth. Catholics do say that all priests act in the person of Christ in celebrating the Eucharist and forgiving sins.

For those who used a computer between 1995 and 2001, what's the computer game from that time that sticks with you the most, and why?

@conservmillen Expertise in theology is not a reliable proxy for faithfulness to Christian revelation. Pope Leo manifests a different agenda, and a post-Christian vision of world order.

Very strange to highlight a random job I had after college to try to discount my argument, but ok! If you were good at this at all, you would know that’s an authority fallacy used by people who are too intellectually insecure to contend with the substance of someone’s argument. Also, you’re a Democrat, Christopher. You believe in legally killing babies. You don’t have any authority when it comes to matters of Christianity or in matters of Catholicism. Stay in your lane.

@conservmillen @michaelbd Pope Leo certainly has enough theological training to know that his claim is unbiblical and unhistorical. He is simply showing his progressive orientation; he believes that it is necessary and right that doctrine should change over time.

@michaelbd No, this passage has nothing to do with war. Just read the whole chapter

Pope Leo: “[Jesus] does not listen to the prayers of those who wage war, but rejects them.” There is absolutely no biblical basis for this whatsoever. Christians should strive for peace, yes. We don’t revel in death and destruction. And a Christian could make a sound argument against the particulars of many wars throughout history, including the war with Iran today. A Christian could also agree that God shouldn’t be used to justify unjust wars. But to say that God is against war per se is flat out false. All throughout the Old Testament God calls for war in defense of His people. Exodus 15:3 declares, “The Lord is a man of war; the Lord is His name.” David constantly prayed to the Lord while battling his enemies. He says his cries to the Lord “reached His ears” and God answered him. God didn’t just answer David by hiding him away but by giving him lethal strength: “He trains my hands for war” (Psalm 18:6, 34). If you discount these examples because they’re in the Old Testament, you don’t understand Scripture or God. Jesus is God; therefore everything God has ever done Jesus has fully agreed with and participated in, and He does not change (Hebrews 13:8). Mind you also that Jesus Himself promises to come back as a warrior to wage war against evildoers. There are categories of people whose prayers God does not answer: the self-righteous, those who pray with selfish motives. People who wage war are not automatically in one of these categories. I’m so glad our founders did not believe this way. I love this retelling of the story of the pacifist Quaker who allegedly heard Washington praying in the woods at Valley Forge: “He was at Prayer to the God of the Armies, beseeching to interpose with his Divine aid, as it was His crisis, and the cause of the country, of humanity, and of the world.” Sometimes force is necessary to defeat evil and advance good. When it comes to these matters, Pope Leo has repeatedly proven that he is not wise.

@ICannot_Enough I remember elevator operators in NYC in the early 1970s.

Nobody is skeptical of autonomous elevators because nobody alive today was even around to see a human elevator operator in real life before the last one got laid off. Automation is far safer.

@michaeljknowles I hold the Orthodox view. In this matter the Catholics and the reformers also hold the Orthodox view.

When it comes to the perpetual virginity of Mary, do you agree with the Catholic view or with the view of Protestant reformers Martin Luther, Ulrich Zwingli, and John Wesley?

@TheWayFrwrd @JayDyer @Trent_Horn @paleochristcon @C2Antiquity I’d visit both and speak to the priests there when you are ready. The details of iconography will vary a little. The Russian monastery is sure to be more observant in some ways than the Antiochian parish, but that doesn’t mean one is better than the other.

@JamesTLarkin1 @JayDyer @Trent_Horn @paleochristcon @C2Antiquity I read somewhere that the Russian church is a bit more mystical and icon heavy. Is this true or is the difference pretty much negligible. There is a Russian monastery near me and a Greek antiochian church. Hardly any churches near me, basically just these.

I don’t have any personal issue with @Trent_Horn but saying @JayDyer and @paleochristcon are going to hell and are leading people there for using potty words, while also believing Muslims and Hindus might be saved is WILD work.

@TheWayFrwrd @JayDyer @Trent_Horn @paleochristcon @C2Antiquity No. There is one Orthodox Church, entirely united in its theology, worship, and sacraments. Visit whatever parish is closest to you, or visit more if you have many nearby. Russian and Greek Orthodox are the same religion with different accents.

@JayDyer @Trent_Horn @paleochristcon @C2Antiquity Hey orthodox people. I’m looking into orthodoxy, and am wondering if there is a significant enough difference between the Greek and Russian orthodox churches to really matter if making a decision.

@HilarityjaneArt And we’re fighting them with Tribbles.

They're the Borg.

@JayDyer That wasn’t a debate — it was an hour of futile attempts to reason with a toddler.

@JayDyer VS @CaptainTazaryach youtube.com/live/NDHWID2gh… BIG DEBATE SOON!!!

@DarthArcanus @JayDyer @RealCandaceO “The Orthodox Way” by Kallistos Ware is a great place to start. It points to the beauty of the Orthodox faith, worship, and ethos.

@JayDyer @RealCandaceO As a Roman Catholic, and interested in reading more about Orthodoxy, where should I start? Is there someone that explains it best, simply. I love Jesus, but I'm probz retardz.

Never in my life have I seen this many people have such strong opinions about the Catholic faith. It is fantastic. A new dawn in America. ✝️

@HilarityjaneArt It is strangely heartening to occasionally see an Orthodox priest or bishop being deposed and sometimes defrocked. It is a sign of a body with a functional immune system.

But that's the catch of the whole business: the Shepherd never answers.

@HilarityjaneArt @unherd @holland_tom @freddiesayers @nickcave That is as neat a definition of Christian as I’ve seen!

@unherd @holland_tom @freddiesayers @nickcave You can "call" yourself a hippopotamus if you want, but it doesn't affect reality. A Christian is someone who is baptised and can recite the Nicene Creed, without interior qualms.

“I call myself a Christian because I think that my values are Christian” Historian @holland_tom joined UnHerd’s @freddiesayers and rock icon @nickcave to discuss what makes him a Christian, and why being ‘culturally Christian’ is indistinguishable from just being Christian.

@PeterSweden7 @grok What is the national background of the bombers in Sweden?

This just happened in France. Someone threw a grenade in the house of an elderly couple. Things like this happen often in Sweden. There's been over 750 b*mbing attacks in Sweden the last 5 years.

@HilarityjaneArt @sitsio The hypocrisy at work is mind-numbing. Half the novus ordo clergy don’t accept the teaching of Niceae, Ephesus, Chalcedon, etc., or find them irrelevant. Opus Dei pays lip service to Vatican II. Only being plain-spoken is punished.

@sitsio Great. So what's the alternative? We just sit there, do nothing, and the Church collapses. The SSPX is a lifeboat because the "Barque of Peter" already is up to the gunwales in water. But sure, stick with the perverts and criminals in Rome. THAT'S "where Peter is"... for sures.