X Notification

1.4K posts

X Notification banner
X Notification

X Notification

@LarryRothfield

Official X Notification account.

เข้าร่วม Mayıs 2014
23 กำลังติดตาม46 ผู้ติดตาม
Edward N Luttwak
Edward N Luttwak@ELuttwak·
Trump has many defects but he is lucky: now he is coming out the winner from a messy war with Iran ultimately made necessary by Obama's over-generous nuclear deal, whose covert purposes included side-lining Israel and Saudi Arabia. The Euro refusal to help was a bad mistake
English
87
107
928
41.7K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@instapundit Your use of the word "literally" is a tell that you may be too blithely self-confident about a subject you are likely completely ignorant on to argue with about this.
English
0
0
0
4
Michael Kontos
Michael Kontos@kontos_michael·
@carney Furthermore we are a republic which is meant to temper public opinion . The senate was meant to meant the saucer that cools the hot tea or the House of Representatives .
English
1
0
0
4
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@john23089884 @carney Right, except that the Founders also thought slavery was okay and that women should not vote, and that only electors should be able to vote for president, etc. etc. But it sounds like you think we have too many people being permitted to vote now.
English
0
0
0
1
john
john@john23089884·
@carney So too the Senate. So too the Supreme Court. The Founders distrusted the mob so America is a Republic not a democracy.
English
1
0
0
29
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@carney By your logic, why not institute electoral colleges at the state level too, to prevent majorities from oppressing majorities within states?
English
0
0
0
2
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@wolftivy That's the opposite of the truth. It would be far more difficult to swing a national popular vote through fraud than in a state, where far more often the margin might be narrow enough that fraud could work.
English
0
0
2
14
Wolf Tivy
Wolf Tivy@wolftivy·
Actually the argument for the electoral college is that it puts a hard limit on the gains from election fraud. One state can pump their "popular vote" numbers way up with fraud, but can only affect their own electors.
James Surowiecki@JamesSurowiecki

There's no good civic argument for the electoral college. It was arguably necessary to ensure the ratification of the Constitution, but it's an anti-democratic device that gives some American citizens far more voting power than others, based purely on where they live.

English
47
24
410
17.3K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@FacultyLeaks The right doesn't see liberalism or progressivism as competing viewpoints to be debated. They see them as moral failings, and speak of those who hold them as infections to be rooted out.
English
0
0
0
34
FacultyLeaks.com
FacultyLeaks.com@FacultyLeaks·
The left doesn't see conservatism as a competing viewpoint to be debated. They see it as a moral failing to be quarantined. Harvard's gesture toward viewpoint diversity isn't a concession — it's a threat. That's not academic disagreement. That's a closed system defending itself.
Brandon Warmke@BrandonWarmke

I often say that many left-wing faculty see academia as their rightful domain and that even an inch of incursion from the "right" is illegitimate and must be crushed, even as they thoroughly politicize entire disciplines, but it's nice to have the view so explicitly stated.

English
6
8
88
2.8K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@Grunt2A Counterpoint: You would have preferred not to have expanded the franchise at any point in US history.
English
1
0
0
6
Spaceballs The X Account
Alow me to simplify why a national popular vote for the President is a bad idea and why the Electoral College is a feature, not a bug. The Electoral College actively prevents us from being a true democracy because true democracies are really bad ideas and allow a low information electorate to simple take what it wants from anyone else. Property rights cease to exist in a true democracy. So do civil rights, minority rights, or any other rights that 50.1% of the people who show up to vote don't want you to have anymore. The country would be run by New York, LA, Chicago, and Dallas. No one's opinions outside of those cities would matter. By having the electoral system it forces Presidential candidates to cater to all 50 states, not just the most populated cities. This ensures that a farmer's rights in Bismark, North Dakota are as important as a homeless man's in New York City, thus making sure the entire nation is represented by the Executive Branch equally. Remember in The Hunger Games where the people of the outlying cities existed only to feed and entertain the residents of the central city under threat of death? That is what not having an electoral college would cause in the United States. Additionally, removing it would require a Constitutional Amendment. And because it would require a Constitutional Amendment anything that attempts to change the process without an Amendment is an end run around the Constitution and is invalid on its face per Marbury v Madison.
Spaceballs The X Account tweet media
English
257
518
2.1K
32.6K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@neontaster @John_Lawlz @Sudsiii And a lot of people from red states, encouraged by Republicans who unlike Democrats love to divide us and who use the exact phrase, define the rest of as not being the "real America."
English
0
0
0
16
Noam Blum
Noam Blum@neontaster·
@John_Lawlz @Sudsiii This depends on whether you view the US as one big entity or as a union of entities. Ironically, a lot of people who want our voting system to obey the former view people from red states as fully not their fellow countrymen.
English
4
0
35
568
Noam Blum
Noam Blum@neontaster·
This literally is an actual argument. You might not care for it, but the only one hand waving here is James.
Noam Blum tweet media
English
109
119
1.4K
38.2K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@neontaster @Sudsiii Trump won the national popular vote, running on exactly the policy against immigrants you favor.
English
0
0
1
14
Noam Blum
Noam Blum@neontaster·
The best practical illustration of this argument was how New York and Chicago's mayors turned on a dime once immigrants from the border started getting bused to their cities. Different places in this country bear the brunt of certain policies more than other places, and their interest would be totally drowned out in a national popular vote system. Again - you might not agree, but that is the argument.
English
7
2
96
1.5K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@neontaster How can a popular vote in which everyone's vote counts the same be controlled by "a handful of apartment building residents"? That is nonsensical.
English
0
0
0
10
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@hpmcd1 During the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Piker, in partnership with CARE, raised over $200,000 for Ukrainian relief funds while playing Elden Ring, with an average of over 70,000 people watching his coverage of the conflict.
English
1
0
0
644
Park MacDougald
Park MacDougald@hpmcd1·
Between Hasan and Fuentes/Tucker, we're watching the emergence of a new Podcast Consensus: - Russia and China are good - America is evil - Islam is good - Israel runs America What separates the "left" from the "right" is, as far as I can tell, how you feel about trans people
The Nation@thenation

At Yale, Hasan Piker quoted Lenin. He quoted Mao. He said Benjamin Netanyahu was the real American president. Then he called the fall of the Soviet Union one of the greatest catastrophes of the twentieth century. bit.ly/4vylh6X

English
161
750
5.9K
227.7K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@JamesWHankins1 As well as monastics in Monte Cassino, St. Gallen, Lindisfarne, etc., and if one counts Justinian's legal code, Byzantium too, no?
English
0
0
0
599
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@lalalainsd @mike_frags Lisa, there were two recounts of Georgia's votes (by the Republican Secretary of State), one by hand, the other by machine. Trump lost both.
English
0
0
1
56
Lisa
Lisa@lalalainsd·
The election was stolen, but that is beside the point. They recounted ballots in Florida for Gore; in fact, they hand-counted them. For some reason, they would not do the same for Trump in Georgia. No one got disbarred or went to jail for questioning the results in Florida. That was the difference because a red state acted honorably and satisfied Gore. I thought the whole thing from the outside seemed to be done honorably.
English
4
1
30
1K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@mike_frags When the Supreme Court rules 5-4 along partisan lines to peremptorily stop a recount in progress, with the majority saying their ruling is valid only for this particular case, it is impossible to avoid questioning the legitimacy of the result.
English
0
0
0
8
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@paleonormie @MonicaBaumann California is 10% of the total vote. Also, Trump won the national popular vote in 2024, and there's no reason to think the R candidates in future elections couldn't win. Unless of course they have shitty candidates and shitty policies.
English
0
0
0
9
pnorm
pnorm@paleonormie·
@MonicaBaumann the alternative is California voter supremacy where the corruption is even worse. Doesn't sound like an improvement to me
English
4
1
71
577
pnorm
pnorm@paleonormie·
My impression of the anti-electoral-college sentiment is “this feature that was added to prevent small states from becoming electorally irrelevant is working as intended and that’s bad actually” Did a federalist steal your girl or something
English
34
34
708
7.9K
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@paleonormie The EC does not favor small states. It favors swing states. Big difference.
English
0
0
0
20
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@Marxon1134x The 3/5 compromise was not "away from the electoral college". It was part of the overall deal. 2 out of the top 4 states with illegal immigrants are Texas and Florida. But it seems you want to go back to the original EC without you or me having any right to vote.
English
0
0
0
7
Marxon
Marxon@Marxon1134x·
@LarryRothfield 3/5ths compromise was a distinct part away from the electoral college and was remedied by emancipation. Saying this also means you have to acknowledge that democrats stuffing their cities with illegal migrants who can't vote, is the same immoral rigging of the system.
English
1
0
0
14
X Notification
X Notification@LarryRothfield·
@vjoshuaadams You do know that Trump slapped an 8% endowment tax on Harvard and other based on per-tuition-paying-student endowment, right?
English
0
0
0
21