@dstock_insights Looks like your insights are indeed very poor. While the table is shown at 816 seats, of which TN is shown to receive 59 seats, you are using an arbitrary number (the upper limit) to claim an even bigger share.
English
Thyagarajan
4.9K posts
Thyagarajan
@thyagumds
Chartered Accountant based out of Chennai, India
Chennai 参加日 Nisan 2009
308 フォロー中155 フォロワー
If 7.18% for Tamil Nadu is 39 out of 543, then 7.18% in 850 should be 61 seats for Tamil Nadu… 🤡 Where is the UT in equation?
BJP@BJP4India
𝐅𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐬 𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐫 𝐦𝐢𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐟𝐨𝐫𝐦𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧. HM Shri @AmitShah made it clear in the Parliament that there will be no injustice to southern states in delimitation. Their representation will increase from 23.76% (129 out of 543 seats) to 23.90% (195 out of 816 seats). This is a proportionate rise, not a reduction. The same principle applies to every state. 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐟𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐬 𝐚𝐫𝐞 𝐬𝐢𝐦𝐩𝐥𝐞. 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐧𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐯𝐞 𝐛𝐞𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐩𝐮𝐬𝐡𝐞𝐝 𝐢𝐬 𝐧𝐨𝐭.
English
@HindutvaDon_ With these numbers, it appears that Gujarat and for that matter most other southern states other than TN have been treated unfairly.
English
Gujarat Population - 7.2M
LS Seats - 26
Tamil Nadu Population - 7.2M
LS Seats - 39
Now tell me who is being treated Unfairly???
English
The #NariShaktiBill is doomed to confusion -- and that is precisely the intent of the BJP-led NDA government. Enough to generate a political narrative, not sufficient to fulfill a constitutional imperative.
English
@SriramMadras @Tejasvi_Surya A Raja is trying to make amends after his gaffe. Will he succeed or does he have to bend even backwards
English
@AravindRajaOff All the above statements are true. The only thing affecting TN and its citizens is the DMK misrule
English
2017: நீட் தேர்வால் மாணவர்களுக்கு பாதிப்பில்லை
2019: CAA சட்டத்தால் முஸ்லிம்களுக்கு பாதிப்பு இல்லை
2019: கொரோனாவால் தமிழ்நாட்டுக்கு பாதிப்பில்லை
2020: வேளாண் சட்டங்களால் விவசாயிகளுக்கு பாதிப்பு இல்ல
2026: தொகுதி மறுவரையறையால் தமிழ்நாட்டுக்கு பாதிப்பு இல்லை.
தமிழ்நாட்டின் துரோகி எடப்பாடி பழனிசாமி.🤧
தமிழ்
@hariiyengaar Or continue to be an idiot like you losing objectivity and reality connect at all times, merely to serve your masters and earn a few brownies
English
Idiots who cheer for Delimitation should just talk to Ladakh people. They cheered removal of 370. Look where they are now.
English
@KartiPC Your father and your party have all been there and done that!!! Now the shoe is on the other foot!!!
English
The delimitation “sales pitch” by the government is like that of an insurance salesman, they say one thing & the fine print says something else.
English
@dipunair @khushsundar @ptrmadurai The major reason for PTRs educational qualifications could also be due to entitlement. We don’t know if Khushboo came up from the ranks or was similarly entitled. Conversely would PTR have acquired the education if he were from the cattle class? Comparing apples with oranges.
English
Educational qualifications -
@khushsundar - 9th failed
@ptrmadurai - Engineering degree from NIT Trichy, a master's degree (implied SUNY), and an MBA in Finance from the MIT Sloan School of Management.
Khushbu is literally the Smriti Irani lite version of BJP from south!🤡
News Arena India@NewsArenaIndia
"We are educated, dignified people unlike Minister Palanivel Thiaga Rajan." - BJP leader Khushbu slams DMK leader for 'derogatory remarks' on her husband Sundar C, who is NDA's Madurai candidate
English
@sardesairajdeep My take. @sardesairajdeep should seriously consider quitting as a media person and join politics, which he is (c)overtly doing anyway, before giving his lousy sermons on what the ruling party should do. He can be more silly with full of bluster and noise then.
English
My take: if the Modi govt is serious about women’s reservation ahead of 2029 GE , simple solution: just amend Article 334 A and go back to the 2010 bill formula that provided one third seats for women from existing 543 seats. Doesn’t need a link with census or delimitation. Can be done tomorrow morning!!🙏
IndiaToday@IndiaToday
Rajdeep's Take on Women's Reservation Bill & Delimitation Debate If the Modi government is truly serious about women’s empowerment and women’s reservation, why not simply stick to the original 2010 bill — a legislation that was already passed in the Rajya Sabha? There are 543 seats; go ahead and reserve one‑third of them for women- @sardesairajdeep #NewsToday
English
VIDEO | Delhi: “Tamil Nadu people will not forgive AIADMK leader Palaniswami for supporting Delimitation Bill, betraying the State”, says Congress MP Jothimani (@jothims).
(Full video available on PTI Videos - ptivideos.com)
English
@KartiPC We guess you know your english when you reproduced the post . Not sure about the original contributors skills though, with words like gerrymandering!!
English
Yes to Women’s Reservation, but within a Parliament of 543 members.
No to a house of 850 after delimitation & gerrymandering.
English
@KartiPC To claim that increasing MPs is "ineffective" is to argue that a single person can effectively represent 25 lakhs people. Historically, no healthy democracy has ever successfully functioned with such a massive ratio.
English
An 850-member Parliament will be even more ineffective than the current 543-member House. MPs are legislators, not administrative executives. Simply adding more of them does not—and cannot—improve constituency administration, because MPs are not the administrative heads of their constituencies.
English
@ravikchandar Does he even make any sense, comparing two incomparable? Next he will say that education is more important than even parents, so on and so forth. Very rhetoric than imaginative
English
MK Stalin: “For a woman, education is of greater help than a husband.” 😍🔥🔥
Dare any other political leader say this so assertively!
English
@PWilsonDMK @AIADMKOfficial Perhaps they are more mature than your party leaders
English
Now the people can see what AIADMK @AIADMKOfficial is about. They will gladly sell Tamil Nadu's power, dignity and voice for their self interest!
Sun News@sunnewstamil
#BREAKING | தொகுதி மறுவரையறையில் தமிழ்நாட்டுக்கு பாதிப்பு இருக்காது - இபிஎஸ் #SunNews | #Delimitation | #ParliamentSession | #EPS
English
@sumanthraman What do you think is the problem? Emotional responses do not take one very far. The per capita MP is the highest in the country and we are not able to fix accountability from them. Lesser per capita would help there. Ideally we need an MP for every 10 Lakh citizens
English
Quite apart from the unjust manner in which delimitation is planned, the thought of another 300 freeloaders living off the taxpayer is quite disgusting. Does anyone seriously believe India's problems are because we have too few MPs?
#Delimitation
English
@karthik11235 @TripurariMedia Annamalai is a very tall and mature leader and is more capable than all the 2nd generation leaders put together starting from Udhayanidhi and moving down
English
@TripurariMedia Annamalai is a big leader for northern bjp Fandom but he is zero in TN.
English
Delimitation is not DMK's Problem. It is Tamilnadu's Problem. Every Tamils Problem.
Just don't get carried away with your DMK hatred.
#FairDelimitation
English
@karthik11235 @ShryanshJain4 These are the facts of the day whether one likes it or not. Rich will always gain more than the poor
English
@ShryanshJain4 You have 100 rs and I have 50 rs.
You are richer by 50rs. Am poor by 50rs.
Doubling it makes you richer by 100rs. Me gets poorer by 100rs.
You will support it because you are getting richer.
Now you will take that money also from me saying I have more mouths to feed than me.
English
@karthik11235 It is purely DMKs problem. We don’t even know the contours of the proposals except the fear-mongering by these politicians
English
@sanjayuvacha Fallacy of ad hominem, a logical error where one attacks his opponent’s character, motive, or attributes rather than addressing the substance of their argument. After all if something goes wrong the Courts can easily intervene unless this writer is casting aspersions on them too.
English
Absolute bunkum.
The constitutional amendments proposed do not reference the 2011 census, but ANY census that Parliament may decide. Nothing prevents this Parliament from using the 2027 census which will be available before the 2029 elections.
Every question of delimitation will be left to a delimitation commission without constitutional protection or guidance. It will be headed by a retired Supreme Court judge who may be trusted to remain as fair in the commission as in the previous avatar in court.
Without a full road map, jumping into constitutional amendments that would distort power within the federation, disproportionately empower the populous states at the expense of the disciplined states, will be casting an unfair and iniquitous burden on the latter. An imperfect union can survive but an unjust union won't.
katibettu Sudhindra/ ಕಾಟಿಬೆಟ್ಟು ಸುಧೀಂದ್ರ@skatibettu
There’s massive confusion on Delimitation , mostly manufactured, partly misunderstood. Let’s set the facts straight 👇 GOI has NOT said seats will be redistributed purely on population basis. The reference is 2011 Census, but that does NOT automatically mean “North gains, South loses.” The idea being discussed = increase total seats (~50%), not aggressively cut or shift existing ones. 👉 In simple terms: Expand the pie, don’t reshuffle it brutally. So why the panic? Because people are mixing 3 different things: Census data 📊 Population-based allocation ⚖️ Seat expansion ➕ These are NOT the same. Also remember,Delimitation has been frozen for decades to ensure states controlling population are not punished. Now suddenly every discussion is being spun as: “South will lose power” That’s not what has been officially stated. Reality check: ✔ No final formula notified ✔ No official redistribution model released ✔ Only broad direction discussed But social media is already running full political narratives. Bottom line: Until a clear framework is out, everything else is speculation, fear mongering, or agenda driven noise. Let policy come first. Debate later.
English
@madversity Unfortunately the present dispensation is taking a very narrow and possibly parochial view and losing out on the elite status of being the voice of Indian south. Other southern states may well argue that TN is getting excessive parliamentary representation.
English
If India is the voice of the Global South, #TamilNadu is the voice of the Indian South -- which involves much more than southern India.
#GlobalSouth #IndianSouth
English