@Tsunalyst what exactly has been paid off? gaza is in ruins, is victory to you more losses for the muslims? what exactly is the game plan here?
English
Staunten
169 posts
At times I come across critiques of Sinwar but no one seems to speak of what else could’ve been done given their circumstances. Whether or not these notes are real, what has been proven is that Sinwar’s gambit paid off and we live in a world of his making.
Open Source Intel@Osint613
According to a report by Israel’s Channel 12, newly revealed handwritten notes attributed to Yahya Sinwar show that, while planning the October 7 attack, he acknowledged Israel might respond with overwhelming force, writing that it could even use a nuclear bomb on Gaza. Despite that assessment, he concluded the operation should proceed, reflecting a willingness to accept even the most catastrophic consequences to achieve Hamas’s objectives.
English
So apparantly fiqhmaxxing is not a guys-only problem.
Theres a reason RasoolAllah ﷺ said to ask for husband's permission for voluntary fasts (to fulfill his rights)
Català
@Nazaratives I've seen some people state this, though idk specifically if they were asharis, but it's not exactly crazy that there are people out there who will twist whatever they can to make any family members of the prophet to be Muslims, even if confirmed kuffar.
English
"Ustad" Abdul Rahman al-Hasan claims that Abu Talib died a Muslim according to the Ash'aris (around 07:00). Could any of his fans dig in reasonable evidence to prove that Abu Talib is considered a Muslim in the Ash'ari school?
Most of anti-Ash'ari stuff on internet by Salafis is absolute junk, just that someone with a decent knowledge did not yet get the time to take them to account.
youtube.com/watch?v=rRSJDu…
YouTube
English
@blacklili555 @franzkaftah Next time when you discuss something with someone, please make sure to read what they say, because I already addressed the major points you just sent, I don't think you know what you are talking about.
English
@Stauntan @franzkaftah That's why I said, if your original language is not Arabic, then you are not originally Arab. Culture is also influenced by history, and Levantines do not share the same history as the Arabs. That's why we do not look the same as them nor do we eat the same cuisine.
English
@blacklili555 @franzkaftah english refers to anglos who share a nationality, both an ethnicty and a culture, arab is heavily more influenced to a language and culture, rather than lineage, so not the same
English
@Stauntan @franzkaftah so are we all English too now? Because we speak the language?
English
@IbnMahbub_ you ran away, he challenged you like a man and you ran away 🤣
English
Faris al-Hammadi stayed up for 2 hours after midnight to make a YouTube Live debunking my thread on his deviance and lies. And in doing so just dug more and more holes for himself.
The biggest and most dangerous statements of this unqualified man was that for the millionth time he STILL tried to justify normalisation with the Zionist entity of Israel 𝗯𝘆 𝗯𝘂𝘁𝗰𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗙𝗮𝘁𝘄𝗮 𝗼𝗳 𝗦𝗵𝗮𝘆𝗸𝗵 𝗜𝗯𝗻 𝗕𝗮𝘇, this time, it wasn’t using his low IQ brain, 𝗶𝘁 𝘄𝗮𝘀 𝘂𝘀𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗖𝗵𝗮𝘁𝗚𝗣𝗧
I will respond to his points post by post to show you how unserious, and how lost he is, and that as he has been told, he has no right to delve into these matters.
English
@blacklili555 @franzkaftah Anyone who speaks Arabic is an Arab and shares their culture is an Arab. Not necessarily by lineage
English
@Stauntan @franzkaftah Anyone who has a native language that isn't Arabic is not originally Arab. Syrians aren't any more Arab than Moroccans are French.
English
@mzmz22735 @lookforurself Who said loving kuffar, I said admiring traits
English
@Stauntan @lookforurself Loving the kuffar for worldy reasons is not allowed, but loving them for their deen is kufr
English
loving a kaffir football player, admiring his qualities, and thinking well of him is haram. he's an enemy of Allah.
English
@muwahhid124 @ImamShamilLib Unironically he once said praying to other than Allah isn't shirk, using those exact word, but I assume he misspoke lol
English
@ImamShamilLib @Stauntan Mushrikjew called a spade a spade - out of - obviously that's what it IS to ANYONE - istigatha to saints = PRAYING TO saints.
His sufi-ashari pagan friends told him not to use the word "praying to" but rather just use "istighatha to".
Changing words doesn't change the reality.
English
Ex-Christian: "Can I still pray to Jesus as a Muslim like before? I still want to practice some Christianity"
Jou: "A lot of Muslims believe tht there are others that control the universe & practice praying to others for this. Only wahhabis say praying to Jesus is shirk".
The Orthodox Muslim@muslimorthodoxy
The Progressive Islam Movement Just Got Insane.... youtu.be/KaCbkh6VlHg
English
@lookforurself So if a disbeliever gives in charity, is that a trait of a kafir?
English
@Jdxdd1356 The reports aren't weak, many scholars authenticated this wording from Ibn abbas
English
@Stauntan U clearly have no idea that it was part of the reason Tabari was murdered and that he equated it with shirk. The athar is rejected and just because the Hanbalis of bagdad accepted it doesn’t make it a proof.
Yes it does refute ur point because u can’t base creed on weak reports
English
Ameen. Don't be such a coward in the future to lock your post.
The Sahaba didn't worship an Entity with Two Feets spatially extended on a Chair.
x.com/qurashite/stat…
Abu yahya@qurashite
Mubāhalah challenge to any Ashʿari Jahmi: May Allāh ﷻ curse you if the Prophet ﷺ and his companions weren’t upon your beliefs regarding the names and attributes of Allāh ﷻ. And may Allāh ﷻ curse me if the Prophet ﷺ and his companions were upon your beliefs. Say Ameen.
English
@Jdxdd1356 Doesn't refute my point, Allah has feet and a footstool, mujahid himself said that Allah sits on the throne and at tabari authenticated it
English
@Stauntan The hadith comes in other sahih variants with a different wording. It's not a hujjah.
English
@AMoalim05 Well then the same would follow on kufr and bidah, which the scholars excuse, a man commits major kufr, is he ignorant? If so then he is excused, a man does bidah, not labeled a mubtadi instantly. Likewise scholars differed with shirk
English
The issue of Al Udhr Bil Jahl summed up:
Is this act Shirk?
Yes.
Do we call the person who does this act a Mushrik and treat them as such in this life?
Yes.
Why?
Because names attach to realities, not to what is in someone’s head.
You do the reality of Shirk, the name follows you.
This is the same logic as any deliberate act: it is ascribed to the one who does it by his own will and power, whether he grasps it or not.
So whoever falls into Shirk is named by it and has the worldly rulings applied.
To make ignorance an excuse here in the naming itself is to deny self evident, innate first principles.
What about in the hereafter?
Punishment by Hell Fire and who is held accountable directly before Allah is where there is a genuine difference of opinion & ignorance may be a valid excuse.
English
@TinKnowledge @Archetypical20 Majority of the scholars only speak Arabic sadly, but idk how helpful it would be since clowns always rise in popularity with their circus shows
English
@Archetypical20 The dawah scene is in need of an organization of wise elders and intellectuals that helps in the decisions making process.
English
It isn't appropriate because it makes our sisters in the faith targets for slander and abuse, and further degrades the discourse.
Halal Zoomer@HalalZoomer
Daniel Haqiqatjou speaks on the rise of female Muslim TikTokers debating men and acting aggressively. "I don't think it's appropriate. It goes against femininity. Being aggressive and debating is a masculine thing. Women shouldn't be imitating that."
English
@wannabemuhadith People didn't know the harms of smoking back then, we have mountains of peer reviewed academic research that proves without a shred of doubt that smoking is harmful and causes all types of cancer and illnesses.
English
The kuff mind cannot comprehend the levels of islamic fiqh
Himmel@ibnrajab01
Providing Cigarettes to the Wife. Al Halabi and Al Hifni Al shafi’i mentioned its obligated upon the husband to provide cigarettes for the wife is she is accustomed to it. تحفة المحتاج في شرح المنهاج
English
@blacklili555 @franzkaftah Arab isn't a race nor really an ethnicity, you gonna find black Arabs and white Arabs and whatever Arabs
English
@franzkaftah bitch we literally speak aramaic in many parts. I know Syrian gingers with blue eyes. No one believes Syrians are even Syrians much less Arabs. Our temples of Baal still stand alongside Byzantinian and Caldaanian ruins. The "brainworm" never left. Learn some history.
English
Don't lie about al-Imam al-Shafi'i.
2 years ago, I analyzed every chain of his alleged praise for Muqatil that I could find and not a single one was authentic.
I found 9 chains for it: 2 in Tarikh Baghdad, 2 in Manaqib al-Shafi'i (by al-Bayhaqi), and 2 in Tarikh Dimashq.
@azma27t (Azmat)@Azmatul51794319
Ibn Taymiyyah said :- Al-Shafi'i said: 'Whoever wishes to master Quranic exegesis (Tafsir) is dependent upon Muqatil, and whoever wishes to master jurisprudence (Fiqh) is dependent upon Abu Hanifah.'
English
What a tragedy that two of Islam's holiest sites, the Kaaba and Al-Aqsa, are under the occupation of the enemies of Islam.
English