Sam

@Busanitian @sinton_alison @CrunchAlias Both c1s and trans women often dress how they feel good. You could find more c1s women looking like porn stars than trans people. You either selectively dont see that as an issue as you're a bigot or you hate sex and female expression.

@sinton_alison @actual_magic @CrunchAlias Also not sure what men who get off on pretending to be porn versions of women has to do with biological sex.

It’s not just the hotheaded insistence with which people claim to believe in “gender identity” which creeps me out. It’s the fact that they don’t seem to remember that 10 years ago they didn’t even know what it was.

@sinton_alison @CrunchAlias It's simple if you refuse to read science

@actual_magic @CrunchAlias Sex is not complex. It's simple. There's male and female. That's it.

"Genocide" and "occupation" are now antisemitic tropes. You probably think this is satire. It isn't. They're being deadly serious. They are determined to rid antisemitism of meaning - to defend Israel as it commits monstrous crimes.

J. K. Rowling is explicitly named in a red flag warning issued by the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention. It’s no longer a debate it never was a debate, or about your opinions. This is the result of your opinions. An official Genocide warning to the UK. That is not commentary. It is in the report. The Institute refers to the UK Supreme Court case brought by For Women Scotland and notes that the group is financially backed by Rowling. That case is then placed within a wider analysis of policy, legal change and public narrative affecting transgender and intersex people in the United Kingdom. The report describes these developments as part of a broader process of erasure. It points to the removal of privacy, the creation of rigid legal categories, and the framing of a group as “other” within public life. It situates these actions within patterns the Institute monitors as early warning signs, including what it defines as the denial or prevention of identity. This is not a passing reference. It connects influence, law and outcome. The significance is not that Rowling is the focus of the report. It is that her position is part of the ecosystem the report is analysing. That is where the discussion changes. Because this is no longer just about individual opinion. It is about how ideas move into institutions, how they shape decisions, and how those decisions affect whether people can exist safely and openly. The report does not rely on rhetoric. It relies on pattern recognition. Legal change. Policy direction. Public narrative. Taken together. That is what is being flagged. @Keir_Starmer @wesstreeting @LGBTLabour @UKLabour @labourpress lemkininstitute.com/red-flag-alert…

@SisterBeech @sinton_alison @CrunchAlias This guy is a Quilette journalist. They've got in trouble for eugenics stuff in the past. His research is poor and against the scientific consensus. You've just proven that transphobia is a hard right and pseudoscience grift.

@actual_magic @sinton_alison @CrunchAlias You need to have a good long browse of this man's account. x.com/i/status/19880…

@CrunchAlias @Glinner Gender identity is just how you describe the mix of male and female traits you have. Stop being such a drama queen with the "gaslighting". Get off X, touch grass and read some post 1950s biology books.

@actual_magic @Glinner “Gender identity” has nothing to do with any of the things you are trying to gaslight me about.

You are just a bully now.

@sinton_alison @CrunchAlias Given how complex sex is, it would be a lot weirder for trans people not to exist than to exist.

@sinton_alison @CrunchAlias We do if you read science. This thread is a good primer by a biology prof. Sex is complex and some people are just aware they're a mix or have programming different to what you'd expect for their body. genderdysphoria.fyi/tweets/AF3D648…

@PatrickLenton @CrunchAlias So much. There's even footage of a prominent terf saying trans women are women and looking much happier than they do now. The real change in the last 10 years has been that transphobia became a grift and a few people also fell for propaganda.

@CrunchAlias This weird historical revisionism you’re doing is just projection - just because trans people didn’t bother you until ten years ago, doesn’t mean we all share that ignorance. I mean, I had trans and gender diverse friends at university in 2004?

So you agree Rowling wishes ill on others?

The terfs next camping we thought was gonna be Gay marriage but it turns out it’s abortion rights. Terfs are actively going against UK abortion rights. We said it was coming and now it’s here. Gender critical and misogynist.

The trans panic will come to be seen as one of the most barbaric social institutions of the early 21at century

I think the hardest part of the current political climate is realizing how many people are actually just evil. Not misinformed or uneducated... just openly and happily enjoying other people's suffering.

J.K. Rowling is not cited in any peer reviewed scientific research on sex development, gender identity, neurobiology, endocrinology, or intersex conditions. She has not contributed to the medical or biological understanding of how human bodies develop.

Says the man who literally put trans people’s safety and respect up for debate.

@david_had1 @JaneWil94237478 @richardpbacon Trump and Netanyahu I'm sure. He's certainly no representative of Jews. In WW2, I imagine he'd have taken the same side the Daily Mail did, which wasn't Britain's.

@JaneWil94237478 @richardpbacon He’s an agent for a foreign power

He needs to be interrupted much more. He’s wrong. And the show lets him get away with it through over politeness.

@JaneWil94237478 @richardpbacon Blaming a whole group for the actions of a few members is textbook bigotry. He doesn't apply the same logic to Christianity, as he's a poor thinker making up arguments to justify his biases.

@richardpbacon Please do tell us all where you think Douglas Murray is wrong

@koshercockney @DouglasKMurray Blaming a whole group for the actions of individuals is textbook bigotry. He wouldn't say Christians should be feared because they have problems they don't address. Murray is just a poor thinker.

This is a must listen and a must share. Seriously. The BBC at its very worst. And this isn’t even @DouglasKMurray at his very best, yet he’s utterly brilliant.