MJKM 😊

Ok. So take a look at this person. I’ll tell you who it is in the next post. Decide what you can about this person. You have eyes. This is not a trick. You will be right. 1/

Caster Semenya only appears to be an elite athlete because Caster Semenya is a male who has been misclassified as female. Many thousands of males would appear to be elite athletes if they were classified into the female category. This does not mean those thousands of males would or should be elite athletes if they were classified into the male category. There is precisely no reason to believe that these males would or should be able to keep up with elite males. Trying to argue or prove that individuals like Caster Semenya do not have male advantage because they do not put in elite male track times is bizarre. I have no idea where this leap of non-logic comes from or why sensible people cannot see the glaring gaps in the premise. And there is even less reason to argue that Semenya et al must be female because they don't run like elite males. This is clearly a batshit assertion. (Reposted as a standalone)