Walter Plinge
9.9K posts

Walter Plinge
@fcqv
Curious about most things other than soccer, whisky, and Star Wars
เข้าร่วม Haziran 2012
1.1K กำลังติดตาม552 ผู้ติดตาม

@fcqv @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th That’s good. It’s honestly not that I think sports is the biggest issue surrounding this whole debate, but I do want my information to be accurate and preferably unbiased. It’s already hard enough as it is to find information without an agenda.
English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th Obviously the recent IOC policy was motivated by different drivers (specifically having to address 46,XY 5-ARD) and all sports are different, but the Rugby policy is still very useful because they were explicit about their scientific references
English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th NP. I am no expert, but the WR workshop included people with a wide range of views, and several of them are active on Twitter if you have any concrete questions
English

@ciphergoth @ClueCultComm @SarahTheHaider Thank you for the data point, and I’ll store it away for future reference, but it’s not particularly relevant to this thread
English

@brookelynn74 @Monika47384 What are you trying to do here?
You keep repeating a claim (TWAW) but make no attempt to defend it rationally, and throw puerile insults at anyone who challenges it.
Do you simply believe this as a faith-based religious belief?
English

@Monika47384 Fuck off, dick cheese.
English

I will never apologize for being mean to bigots. They need to be called out. It's the same theory as always punch the Nazi. This shit is not ok and I will not play nice and smile sweetly and pretend it is!
#TransRightsAreHumanRights
GIF
English

@TimandraHarknes Surely you could have given more than 1 day notice? Oh…hang on😂
English

How To Disagree
One day left to listen to my series on having better arguments: bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0b…
English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th Some of the papers would probably now be superseded by more recent work (often by the same authors) but if the workshop were rerun, the overall conclusions would not change
English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th The top level summary is here:
world.rugby/the-game/playe…
And you can follow the links through to more detailed explanations such as this:
world.rugby/the-game/playe…
English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th This is a common misunderstanding of fairness in sport. Jon Pike’s work in this area is a good place to start if you want to understand the actual meaning of fairness in sport
English

@Lachlan_Edi @fcqv @SalemThe5th I don’t claim to know more. I’m saying that if they would truly care about fairness, they would put in place measurable standards to ensure that fairness. If they don’t, it’s excluding trans people that they care about, not fairness.
English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th The World Rugby policy documents are worth reading as they explain the policy with full scientific references.
The workshop was over 5 years ago and there’s been stronger evidence published since, but it’s a good place to start if you want to understand what you’re talking about
English

@fcqv @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th Any aspect that you claim gives sex an unfair advantage over people of a different sex.
English

@thesundaysport You’re always ahead of the game on the sex arse front, so I assume it’s not that…
English

@BerthonJeanMarc @Marina_Ferrari @ILGAWORLD @francediplo @fs_lgbt @stop_homophobie It’s sex testing, not femininity testing.
Until you understand the difference between sex and gender, all of your opinions on this question are pretty much worthless
English

Following the attempt to rehabilitate Russia, the @IOC has now decided to exclude from the Olympic Games those with variations in sexual characteristics and to impose femininity tests on female athletes that contravene both the law and ethical principles. France, through its minister Marina Ferrari, has expressed its deep concern.


English

@letsjustfckngo @Lachlan_Edi @SalemThe5th Apart from sex, which of the other current agreed categories (age, weight, disability etc) do you want to replace with a different system?
English

@Lachlan_Edi @fcqv @SalemThe5th That’s all fine, but then don’t try to claim that it is about the unfair advantage, cause it isn’t about that. It’s clearly just because you can’t cope with people you don’t understand. Just say that.
English

@BradfemlyWalsh @grace_hawthorn My Dad has the same name problem, compounded by a) the fact that he does have dementia b) for bureaucratic reasons it’s not on his NHS notes, so they always think he must have had a stroke and c) the fact that I have the same first name.
Like bloody Feydeau last time he was in😂
English

@grace_hawthorn She wrote his name on that the first day they did it and they don't bother. She said the way they're treating him has made her terrified to get older (she's 78, he's 85)
English

@anon_gencrit @ukvillafan @PeterTatchell Campaigning for gay rights in many countries around the world; fairly principled on free speech and opposed to no-platforming; consistent critic of Sharia.
He’s certainly horrendously wrong on several other topics, especially women’s rights, but he’s no common or garden TRA fool
English

Olympic ban on all trans women competing in women’s events is unjustified
They’ve no unfair advantage if they’ve had hormone treatment
It reduces muscle mass, bone density & physical strength & endurance. Their performance declines to that of ‘biological’ women
Individual assessment. No blanket ban
@TransLucent_Org @TransITCUK @Mams4Trans @Transgendertrd @TransgenderNews @TransActionBloc @TransPride @LDNtranspride @TransNewsDesk @Mermaids_Gender @BobbityP @TransYouth @transgreens @RuthDavidsonPC @hillarytaylorvi @ZackPolanski @TheGreenParty @rachelmillward @MothinAli @LgbtqIndia @BuzzFeedLGBTQ @lgbtiqa_greens @LGBTIQAGreenLon @LGBTIQRights @LindaRiley8 @DIVAmagazine @glaad @HRC @hilarypepper @CliffJoannou @benjaminbutter
GB News@GBNEWS
'They can go in their own categories!' @Nanaakua1 and Peter Tatchell and Nana Akua go back and forth over the IOC banning biological males from women's sports.
English

@PeregrineT49351 @brookelynn74 @WitchyMcWitch @GirlScout27 @thefempire50 @mar2vickers @ForWomenScot @jk_rowling @sharrond62 Indeed:)
Logically you can construct any number of non-circular definitions (e.g. “woman” means “a human being”; “woman” means “table” and “trans” means “wooden”) but they are not particularly useful for rational people🤣
English

@fcqv @brookelynn74 @WitchyMcWitch @GirlScout27 @thefempire50 @mar2vickers @ForWomenScot @jk_rowling @sharrond62 It doesn't have to be circular. They can be honest and admit that 'woman gender' is just 'femininity'.
This does involve admitting they think butch lesbians aren't really women, so they tend to go with the circular approach. But we know what they actually THINK a woman is.
English

To all media… we are watching you closely. Misinformation, deliberate gaslighting, and ambiguous language is not excusable, you have been told relentlessly and very clearly by the IOC; the policy applies to males not being allowed in the female category, for integrity, safety, fairness and equality of opportunity of females in their category. It’s that’s simple. Feelings and personal identities have no place in sport, just biological reality.
English

@ObhishekSaha @CostelloWilliam AFAIK this is illegal under UK law. If so, do you believe the law should be changed?
English

Relationships thrive, and are built upon, implicit consent. When you know (and you know your partner knows, and you know that your partner knows you know) that it is fine for you to go ahead with an act without explicit consent. I think that if you normally enjoy oral sex, but you would be annoyed at your partner waking you up with one, your relationship with your partner needs improving.
English

Would you be happy or annoyed if a partner woke you with oral sex without explicit consent?
N = 4,413 (24% female)
84% of men said happy
67% of women said annoyed
Large effect size.
The somnophilia fetish is arousal from initiating sexual activity with someone who is asleep.

William Costello@CostelloWilliam
Would you be more happy or annoyed if a sexual partner woke you up with oral sex without explicit consent? Are you male or female?
English








